Cincinnati Reds vs Toronto Blue Jays, September 3rd, 2025

Blue Jays vs. Reds Prediction: Toronto Leans on Bieber in Cincinnati

The Toronto Blue Jays head to Great American Ball Park on Wednesday, September 3, 2025, to take on the Cincinnati Reds in a cross-league matchup between two clubs on very different trajectories. First pitch is set for 6:40 PM ET.

MLB’s Best Picks

Handicapping Membership

Get Free Trial

Toronto (80-59) sits atop the AL East and brings one of baseball’s most consistent offenses into this series. Cincinnati (70-69), meanwhile, continues to scrap for relevance in the NL Central but has struggled across its last 10 games.

Matchup Overview

• Venue: Great American Ball Park, Cincinnati, OH
• Date: Wednesday, Sept. 3, 2025
• Probable Starters: Shane Bieber (TOR) vs. Zack Littell (CIN)
• Betting Odds: Blue Jays ML -158, Reds ML +134, Runline TOR -1.5 (+104) / CIN +1.5 (-124), Total 8.5 (O -113 / U -107)

The Blue Jays Can Win If…

Toronto’s lineup is firing on all cylinders. In their last meeting with the Reds, the Jays exploded for 12 runs behind George Springer’s two-homer night and Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s three-hit performance. Toronto leads MLB in both batting average and on-base percentage, and they’ve tallied 251 doubles (3rd in MLB), a reflection of their gap-to-gap power.

The X-factor is Shane Bieber. The veteran right-hander has been sensational, posting a 2.38 ERA and microscopic 0.62 WHIP. His command and ability to neutralize rallies make him a prime weapon against a Reds lineup that thrives on extra-base hits.

For those looking to wager, our MLB Picks section breaks down the top betting angles every day.

The Reds Can Win If…

Cincinnati put up 15 hits in Monday’s slugfest, proving their bats can match Toronto’s when locked in. Austin Hays and TJ Friedl homered, while Noelvi Marte’s two doubles showcased depth beyond star Elly De La Cruz, who leads the club with 19 homers and 78 RBIs.

On the mound, Zack Littell (3.63 ERA, 1.12 WHIP) brings steady reliability. The Reds as a staff own an 11th-ranked ERA (3.90) and rank 4th in quality starts — the kind of consistency that could help them keep Toronto’s bats in check.

Check the latest MLB Scores and Odds to track how the market is viewing Littell and the Reds heading into first pitch.

Hit the home run every time!

Handicapping Membership

Get Free Trial

Handicapper Spotlight

If you’re betting tonight’s matchup, don’t just rely on the numbers — see who the pros are backing. Our top MLB handicappers are on fire, stacking winning streaks and profit across the board. Check the leaderboard below for the latest records and hottest cappers before locking in your Blue Jays vs. Reds wagers.

Betting Outlook

Oddsmakers lean Toronto at -158, and my projection model lines up with the market. The Blue Jays are favored to win 5-3, largely because their lineup generates more consistent run pressure than Cincinnati’s.

At a total of 8.5 runs, the under (-107) has value. Both rotations feature arms that can miss bats, and with Bieber in control, a slightly lower-scoring outcome is in play.

If you’re building a card today, don’t miss our in-depth MLB Expert Betting Guide for strategy and trends.