Cincinnati Reds vs Toronto Blue Jays Picks and Predictions September 2nd 2025

Cincinnati Reds vs Toronto Blue Jays September 2nd 2025

The Toronto Blue Jays will play against the Cincinnati Reds at the Great American Ball Park. The game is set for Tuesday, September 2, 2025, at 6:40 PM. The weather forecast predicts a warm day with clear skies and a calm wind blowing out.

The Blue Jays have a record of 79-59 and are first in the AL East. They recently lost their last game and have a 5-5 record in their last 10 games. The Reds hold a 70-68 record and are third in the NL Central. They are on a two-game winning streak but have struggled in their last 10 games with a 3-7 record.

Blue Jays vs Reds Key Information

• Sport: Baseball
• Teams: Toronto Blue Jays vs. Cincinnati Reds
• Venue: Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati, OH
• Date: Tuesday, September 2, 2025 at 6:40 PM
• Betting Odds: Blue Jays Moneyline -104, Reds Moneyline -114, Blue Jays Runline -1.5 (+154), Reds Runline +1.5 (-189), Total Over 8.5 (-115), Total Under 8.5 (-105)

The Blue Jays Can Win If…

The Toronto Blue Jays are coming off a close 5-4 loss to the Cincinnati Reds. Bo Bichette had a standout performance, going 4 for 4 with a home run and two doubles. Daulton Varsho also contributed with a home run, showing the team’s ability to generate power.

The Blue Jays have a strong lineup, leading the league with a .268 batting average and a .335 on-base percentage. They rank third in doubles, which indicates they can hit for extra bases. Their ability to get on base and hit for power gives them a strong chance to score runs.

José Berríos will start for the Blue Jays, bringing a solid 3.95 ERA into the game. The team ranks fourth in strikeouts, showing they can limit opposing offenses. With their strong batting and capable pitching, the Blue Jays have the tools needed to secure a win.

The Reds Can Win If…

The Cincinnati Reds are coming off a 5-4 win against the Toronto Blue Jays. Hunter Greene pitched 6 1/3 innings, allowing just one run and striking out seven. Ke’Bryan Hayes led the offense with three hits and two RBIs, while TJ Friedl and Noelvi Marte also contributed key hits.

The Reds have a strong chance to win with their solid pitching and batting stats. Their team ERA of 3.85 ranks 7th, and they have held opponents to a .234 batting average. On offense, they rank 9th in batting average at .247, showing they can get on base and create scoring opportunities.

Nick Lodolo will start for the Reds, bringing an ERA of 3.22 and a WHIP of 1.04. He has shown consistency this season, which can give the Reds an edge. With hitters like Elly De La Cruz and Noelvi Marte in the lineup, the Reds have the firepower to secure another win.

The Lean

The Blue Jays have a slight edge in hitting with a higher batting average and on-base percentage. Their pitching stats are also strong, making them a good pick. The moneyline for the Blue Jays is -104, and the model projects a score of Blue Jays 5, Reds 4. Therefore, the recommendation is to pick the Blue Jays to win straight up.

The total for the game is set at 8.5 runs. Both teams have solid pitching, but the Blue Jays’ offense could push the total higher. The model projects a total of 9 runs. Thus, the recommendation is to take the over at 8.5 (-115).

Score a Homerun!

With our Premium Handicapping Membership

Get Free Trial

Reds Keep Fighting in Wild-Card Race

The Cincinnati Reds continue to show resilience as they chase a postseason berth. After a thrilling 5-4 walk-off victory on Monday, Cincinnati looks to build on momentum when the three-game set with the Toronto Blue Jays resumes Tuesday.

The Reds remain within striking distance in the National League wild-card race, sitting four games back after winning two straight. That surge followed a damaging five-game losing streak, but closer Emilio Pagan emphasized that the team refuses to quit. The win not only energized the clubhouse but also kept the Reds relevant in the standings.

For more insights into MLB betting trends and matchups, check out the latest MLB previews

Hayes Providing a Spark Since Trade

One of Cincinnati’s key contributors has been Ke’Bryan Hayes, who joined the team from the Pittsburgh Pirates in late July. Since the trade, Hayes has found his swing, hitting .274 with a .796 OPS in 29 games. Three of his five home runs this season have come with the Reds, and he entered Tuesday riding a hot stretch, going 7-for-15 during the homestand.

His presence in the lineup adds depth for a team that has struggled to maintain consistency but still finds ways to deliver in clutch moments. Bettors tracking player performances can follow updated MLB game results for more context.

Pitching Matchup: Lodolo vs. Berrios

The Reds will turn to left-hander Nick Lodolo (8-7, 3.22 ERA), who is making his first career start against Toronto. Lodolo has been steady throughout the season and will be tasked with keeping the Blue Jays’ power bats in check.

Toronto counters with right-hander Jose Berrios (9-5, 3.95 ERA), who has a 1-2 record and 4.35 ERA in four career starts against Cincinnati. The Blue Jays are leaning heavily on their rotation to provide innings, with their bullpen showing signs of fatigue. Chris Bassitt highlighted the importance of starters going deep, and Berrios will be counted on to save the relief corps.

Explore different ways to approach these pitching matchups with the expert MLB betting guide

Blue Jays Need to Regain Momentum

While the Reds fight for survival, Toronto is looking to protect its position atop the American League East. The Blue Jays have lost five of their past eight games, allowing the Yankees and Red Sox to close within 2.5 games. Manager John Schneider believes his team is capable of bouncing back quickly, but Monday’s bullpen collapse was a costly reminder of the challenges ahead.

With the playoff race tightening, bettors can evaluate today’s board and see recommended MLB picks before placing wagers.

Betting Outlook

Tuesday’s matchup presents an interesting dynamic: a Reds team refusing to go away versus a Blue Jays club trying to avoid giving up ground in the division. Cincinnati’s momentum, coupled with Hayes’ hot bat, will be tested by Toronto’s need for stability on the mound.

For those looking to gain an edge, explore premium selections with buy picks or review the best handicappers leaderboard to see who’s delivering consistent profits across MLB.