Red Sox vs Athletics Picks and Predictions

Oakland Athletics vs Boston Red Sox September 10th 2025

The Boston Red Sox will visit the Athletics at Sutter Health Park in West Sacramento, CA. The game is set for Wednesday, September 10, 2025, at 3:35 PM. Fans can watch the game on NSPCA

Boston holds a record of 80-65 and is third in the AL East. They have won their last two games. The Athletics are 66-79 and sit fifth in the AL West. They have lost their last two games. The starting pitchers are Payton Tolle for Boston and Mason Barnett for the Athletics.

Red Sox vs Athletics Key Information

Sport: Baseball
Teams: Boston Red Sox vs. Athletics
Venue: Sutter Health Park in West Sacramento, CA
Date: Wednesday, September 10, 2025
Betting Odds:
- Red Sox Moneyline: -134
- Athletics Moneyline: +113
- Red Sox Runline: -1.5 (+114)
- Athletics Runline: +1.5 (-137)
- Total Over: 10.5 (-106)
- Total Under: 10.5 (-115)

The Red Sox Can Win If Their Offense Stays Explosive

The Boston Red Sox keep dominating the Athletics, powered by a lethal offense. Garrett Crochet’s shutout opener, followed by a four-run inning featuring a career-long 463-foot blast from Rob Refsnyder, set the tone. Trevor Story, Carlos Narváez, and Romy González (now on a 12-game hitting streak) are all contributing key hits.

When this offense—ranked 1st in doubles and 4th in team batting average—stays aggressive, Boston is hard to stop. If Payton Tolle gives them a few quality innings, the Red Sox are poised to complete the sweep.

The Athletics Can Win If They Capitalize on Close Opportunities

The Oakland Athletics are better than the lopsided scores suggest. They rank 4th in batting average and 3rd in slugging percentage. With hitters like Nick Kurtz (.301 AVG, 29 HRs) and rising star Jacob Wilson (.319 AVG), Oakland has the offensive tools to stay competitive — if they convert chances.

If Mason Barnett finds rhythm and the lineup overcomes Boston’s pitching early, the A’s could extend this series deeper emotionally and on the scoreboard.

The Lean

Moneyline Pick: Red Sox (-134)
Projected Score: Red Sox 6, Athletics 4

Best Bets:

Red Sox on the moneyline
Under 10.5 total runs – given recent tight run production despite offensive explosions

You can explore more expert analysis via our MLB picks page.

Expanded Analysis

Boston’s offense hasn’t just been good—they’ve been clinical. Their ability to deliver big innings is a real threat with boots on early. Oakland, on the other hand, had consistent hits but couldn’t cross the plate—10 hits with zero runs on Tuesday says it all.

Pitching Battle: Youth vs. Volume

Payton Tolle shows flashes—eight strikeouts in his debut—but remains untested. Conversely, Barnett offers experience, but has yet to find consistency. Whichever young pitcher settles first could tilt the game.

Momentum & Playoff Race Stakes

Boston is locked in a tight wild-card battle with the Yankees, making this road sweep essential for confidence and seeding. Oakland’s season may be near its end, but they’re playing for pride—and that can’t be underestimated.

For odds and live updates, check our MLB odds page.

FAQs

Who are the starting pitchers today?

Payton Tolle (Red Sox, 7.56 ERA) makes his third start. Mason Barnett (A’s, 9.00 ERA) gets the ball for Oakland.

What’s the betting line and projected score?

Red Sox are favored at -134. Total is set at 10.5. Prediction: Boston 6, Oakland 4.

Why the under on the total?

Despite Boston’s offensive firepower, both young starters can keep it close early, and Oakland’s inefficient run scoring suggests lower totals could be smart.

Who’s hitting well for Boston right now?

Romy González leads the streaking list (.455 over the last 12 games), while Story, Narváez, and Refsnyder are adding timely homers.

Where can I find more betting insights?

Head over to our Expert MLB Betting Guide for in-depth trends, picks, and predictive models.

Oakland Athletics vs Boston Red Sox Picks and Predictions September 10th 2025