St. Louis Cardinals vs Detroit Tigers Picks and Predictions May 19th 2025

Preview: Cardinals Kick Off Homestand vs. Tigers

The St. Louis Cardinals roll home fresh off a 7–2 road trip—arguably their best of the season—and now they’ll face a red-hot Detroit Tigers squad in a six-game series. From clutch homers to pitching duels, here’s a modern breakdown of everything you need to know before Monday’s first pitch.

Road Trip Recap

St. Louis rattled off wins in Washington D.C., Philadelphia and Kansas City, dropping only two games by 2–1 scores. Offense wasn’t always easy—Sunday’s 0-for-8 with runners in scoring position left 13 men on base—but sparkling defense and timely pitching carried the club.

Masyn Winn summed it up best after Saturday’s 1–0 triumph: “It feels like everybody on the field is locked in. Our defense is insane, fires us all up.” Jordan Walker’s solo shot provided the only run St. Louis needed, and stellar infield plays helped preserve Sonny Gray’s shutout bid into the late innings.

Offense and Defense in Focus

The Cardinals have found a winning formula on this trip: zero in on high-leverage at-bats and tighten up in the field. Despite some offensive hiccups, they’ve:

• Posted a .265 average with RISP over seven games
• Turned six double plays and made three highlight-reel stops

That blend of situational hitting and lockdown defense has them 15–6 at home this year—tied for the second-best home record in baseball behind only Detroit and the Mets (both 17–5).

Starting Pitchers to Watch

Sonny Gray (4–1, 4.50 ERA) gets the nod for St. Louis. After a rough outing against Philly—seven earned runs in 3⅔ innings—he proved he can bounce back, striking out four and helping the offense rally for a 14–7 win. Gray’s career numbers against Detroit are strong (4–2, 2.68 ERA in nine starts), so expect him to attack the zone early and rely on his slider-changeup mix.

On the bump for Detroit is Keider Montero (1–1, 4.68 ERA), making his first career appearance versus the Cardinals. Montero’s last outing saw him exit after 3⅓ innings, giving up three runs in a wild 10–9 extra-innings win over Boston. A previous eight-inning gem against Colorado (one run allowed) shows his upside, but consistency will be key.

Tigers’ Momentum

Detroit isn’t just along for the ride. The Tigers swept the Red Sox at home and then took two of three in Toronto to climb 15 games over .500. First baseman Spencer Torkelson has been a catalyst, going 4-for-13 with two homers and five RBIs over the last four games. “Games like these keep you locked in, on your toes,” he told FSN Detroit after driving in all three runs in Sunday’s 3–2 win.

With the majors’ best home record and an offense clicking against right-handers, Detroit brings plenty of firepower to Busch Stadium. Their bullpen depth—bolstered by matchup arms like Jason Foley—could be a decisive factor late in games.

Betting Insights and Odds

Oddsmakers have opened this series with St. Louis as a slight favorite, reflecting the Cards’ hot stretch and Detroit’s home dominance. Current lines on our MLB odds page show:

• Cardinals moneyline: –120
• Tigers moneyline: +110
• Over/under runs: 8.5

Two angles to consider:

1. Under Total Runs: With Gray’s bounce-back potential and Montero’s boom-or-bust profile, coupled with stellar defense on both sides, under 8.5 has cashed in 4 of the last 6 head-to-head matchups.
2. First Five Innings Moneyline: Back the Cardinals through the early frames—Gray’s F5 ERA sits at 2.30 on the season, and Detroit’s lineup has struggled with lefties away from Comerica Park.

For daily picks, props and parlay ideas, head to our MLB picks page. When you’re ready to level up, our expert betting guide breaks down advanced models, split data and in-depth prop strategies.

What to Watch: Key Matchups

• Winn vs. Torkelson: Rookie shortstop Masyn Winn (.308 career average) faces his first look at Spencer Torkelson, whose power bats have torched lefties at a .580 slugging mark this month.
• Bullpen Depth: Look for manager Oliver Marmol to mix in young arms like T.J. McFarland and Andrew Kittredge. Detroit’s bullpen ERA ranks top-10, but high leverage ISOs have ticked up lately.
• Defensive Shifts: Both clubs excel at run-saving shifts. Watch how often first-and-third situations turn into double plays—there were three kill-switch DP turns on St. Louis’s road trip.

Future Odds Shifting?

See Updated MLB Futures

Get Free Trial

Team Deep Dive

Beyond the series preview, dig into full rosters, injury updates and advanced splits at our team stats page. You’ll find:

• Player heat maps and spray charts
• Bullpen usage logs and high-leverage inning splits
• Roster shakeups and minor-league call-ups

Whether it’s monitoring Jordan Walker’s hot bat or tracking Detroit’s spring training invitees, this resource keeps you in the loop.

Expert Takeaways

Modern baseball hinges on context over raw numbers. The Cardinals’ road trip success showcased clutch situational hitting and championship-caliber defense. Meanwhile, Detroit’s home comforts and lineup balance make them a tough out, even in enemy territory.

Use live odds triggers—such as early runs allowed or in-game weather shifts—and remember to shop the lines for the best value. This homestand could define both clubs’ summer narratives: St. Louis aiming to cement its NL Central contention, and Detroit proving it can win anywhere.

Enjoy the series, bet smart, and catch all the action live. And don’t forget: for ongoing picks and deeper analysis, bookmark our expert betting guide and swing by the MLB odds page throughout the week.