St. Louis Cardinals vs New York Mets Picks and Predictions May 3rd 2025

Last Updated on

The red-hot New York Mets are aiming to secure their 10th consecutive victory over the St. Louis Cardinals as the teams clash in the second game of a three-game set in St. Louis on Saturday. Riding high on elite offensive production and solid starting pitching, the Mets continue to establish themselves as a force in the National League East.

Offensive Firepower Leading the Charge

On Friday, the Mets unleashed a 17-hit assault on Cardinals pitching, cruising to a 9-3 victory. The team’s consistent hitting is a major reason behind their current win streak over St. Louis.

sas logo

Best MLB Handicapping

Membership in the Market

Brandon Nimmo’s Comeback Story

Brandon Nimmo, once mired in a slump and batting just .192 earlier this week, is now showing signs of a strong comeback. On Friday, he went 3-for-3 with two walks, hit a solo homer—his seventh of the season—and crossed the plate three times. It was his second standout performance in less than a week. In Monday’s 19-5 rout of the Nationals, Nimmo went 4-for-6 with two home runs and a career-best nine RBIs.

Manager Carlos Mendoza praised his consistency, saying, “He’s been locked in…a good hitter that finally is getting results.”

Juan Soto Keeps Smashing

Following a two-homer game on Thursday, Juan Soto delivered another high-impact outing. He ripped two hits, including a double with a season-high exit velocity of 114.3 mph, anchoring a crucial fifth-inning rally.

Supporting Cast Delivering

Francisco Alvarez also had a three-hit game, while Pete Alonso and Jesse Winker added two hits apiece. The Mets’ lineup is collectively firing, making them difficult to contain.

Pitching Preview: Tylor Megill vs. Erick Fedde

Tylor Megill (Mets)

  • Record: 3-2
  • ERA: 1.74
  • Last Start: 6⅓ IP, 3 H, 3 ER, 9 K (no-decision vs. Nationals)

Megill has been a reliable arm in the Mets rotation. Despite a no-decision in his last start, he showcased swing-and-miss stuff and allowed just one walk over 6+ innings. His career numbers against the Cardinals are modest (1-1, 7.00 ERA in 2 starts), but his current form paints a more favorable picture.

Erick Fedde (Cardinals)

  • Record: 1-3
  • ERA: 4.68
  • Last Start: 5⅔ IP, 10 H, 7 ER, 2 BB (loss vs. Brewers)

Fedde has struggled against the Mets throughout his career, posting a 1-5 record and 6.51 ERA in 17 appearances (12 starts). In 2024, he has yet to find consistency, highlighted by his recent outing where he was roughed up for seven earned runs.

Despite his performance, Cardinals skipper Oliver Marmol appreciated his grit, noting Fedde “dug down deep” to throw 100 pitches and preserve the bullpen.

Cardinals’ Glimmer of Hope: Masyn Winn

If there’s a silver lining for St. Louis, it’s the emergence of shortstop Masyn Winn. Moved to the No. 2 spot in the batting order, Winn is hitting .272 after going 3-for-4 on Friday, his third multi-hit effort in four games. His sharp uptick in batting average—from .231 to .272—signals his rising confidence at the plate. Don’t miss out on our Daily Baseball Picks from MLB Expert Handicappers


What to Watch For

  • Can Brandon Nimmo keep his bat hot and further boost his batting average?
  • Will Juan Soto continue his run of hard-hit dominance?
  • Can Tylor Megill maintain his elite ERA against a surging hitter like Winn?
  • Will the Cardinals find any relief in a Mets team that seems nearly unstoppable?

Conclusion

With all cylinders firing, the Mets are well-positioned to notch their 10th consecutive victory over the Cardinals. From a revitalized Brandon Nimmo to the consistently dangerous Juan Soto, New York’s depth and power are overwhelming their opponents. While the Cardinals show signs of life through players like Masyn Winn, their pitching must turn a corner to halt the Mets’ red-hot momentum.

By Rick Rockwell | April 27, 2025
By Rick Bouch | April 22, 2025
By Rick Bouch | April 18, 2025
spread
moneyline
over/under
St. Louis Cardinals
-
-
-
-
-
New York Mets
-
-
-
-
-
Bb Ultimatecapper Logo
Bobby Babowski
Premium Package
2W / 1L on Baseball
MLB
Money Line
S Central Logo
Sports Central
Premium Package
3W / 3L on Baseball
MLB
Money Line
Mjs Logo
Madjack Sports
Starter Package
1W / 1L on Baseball
MLB
Money Line
Sas Logo Logo
Sas Insider
Premium Package
6W / 4L on Baseball
MLB
Money Line
Scott Picks Logo
Scott's Picks
Starter Package
1W / 3L on Baseball
MLB
Money Line
4282 Service Photo Logo
Sal Michaels
Starter Package
0W / 1L on Baseball
MLB
Money Line
Mike Williams
Mike Williams | Handicapper

Free Pick found on BestBettor.com. Mike Williams is part of SportsCapping Group.

Mike uses his strong sports knowledge to analyze all the angles to find the most profitable wagers. Iron Mike handicaps MLB, college football, NFL, NBA, and NCAA basketball. I'm an actual sports and gambling junkie!

#1 Baseball
Yesterday
100
Last 7 days
300
Last 3 days
500
Last 30 days
554