Texas Rangers vs Oakland Athletics Picks and Predictions May 1st 2025

Dominant Mahle vs. Struggling Springs: Can the A’s Clinch Another Series Win?

The Oakland Athletics head into Thursday’s series finale with a surge of confidence and momentum, looking to secure their third consecutive series victory. After an explosive ninth-inning rally on Wednesday night, the A’s are poised to capitalize on the Texas Rangers‘ continued struggles. But with ace Tyler Mahle taking the mound for Texas, the challenge ahead is significant. Be sure to also check the MLB Expert Handicappers thoughts on the latest matchup

Athletics Eye Another Series Win

The Athletics are riding high after a come-from-behind 7-1 win Wednesday, sparked by two dramatic ninth-inning homers: a two-run shot by Brent Rooker and a grand slam from Lawrence Butler. That offensive burst sealed at least a split in the four-game set and showcased the team’s resilience and clutch hitting.

Oakland’s lineup has shown balanced production lately, collecting 11 hits in the win. Rooker, Butler, Jacob Wilson, and Shea Langeliers each posted multi-hit performances, signaling a well-rounded offensive effort.

Rangers Reeling Despite Strong Rotation

Despite a blowout 15-8 win on Tuesday, the Rangers have lost six of their last eight games, struggling with consistency at the plate and a failure to convert with runners in scoring position (RISP). In Wednesday’s loss, Texas stranded 11 runners, including six in scoring position, despite outhitting the A’s.

Adolis García and Josh Jung each registered two hits, but the rest of the lineup failed to capitalize. The inability to deliver clutch hits has been a recurring issue for the defending AL West champions.

Pitching Preview: Mahle vs. Springs

Tyler Mahle (Rangers)

• Record: 3-0
• ERA: 1.14
• WHIP: 0.89
• Last 2 starts: No-decisions despite allowing just 4 total runs
• Manager’s Comment: “He knows what he wants to do and executes,” said Bruce Bochy.

Mahle enters this matchup as one of the best starters in baseball, having allowed only four earned runs over 31.2 innings this season. His control and pitch selection have been nearly flawless. If the Rangers’ offense can provide even modest run support, Mahle gives them a strong chance to win.

Jeffrey Springs (Athletics)

• Record: 3-3
• ERA: 6.04
• Recent Form: 13 earned runs over last 2 starts
• First-Inning ERA: 16.50
• Career vs. Texas: 1-0, 2.77 ERA over 13 innings

Springs has had a roller-coaster season, struggling especially in the early innings. He’s allowed multiple runs in the first inning in several starts, putting the A’s in early deficits. However, his performance stabilizes later in games, with an ERA under 1.00 from the fourth to sixth innings. If Springs can overcome his early-inning woes, Oakland could stay competitive.

Industry’s Best MLB

Handicapping Membership

Get Free Trial

What to Watch For

Player Spotlight: Lawrence Butler

The rookie outfielder is gaining attention after his clutch grand slam, his second homer in the series. Butler has now driven in multiple runs in consecutive games and is quickly becoming a critical piece in Oakland’s young core.

Series Outlook: What’s at Stake?

For Oakland, a win means a third straight series victory and a morale boost for a rebuilding team. For Texas, it’s a chance to stop the bleeding and avoid further descent in the division standings. A loss would highlight ongoing concerns about run support and timely hitting despite a strong starting rotation.

Conclusion

Thursday’s series finale offers a compelling showdown: a dominant pitcher trying to halt a team’s skid against a surging, resilient underdog. The Athletics’ late-game magic and the Rangers’ elite starter set the stage for a dramatic close to the series. All eyes will be on whether Tyler Mahle can shut down Oakland’s bats—or if the A’s can spark another late rally to clinch the series.