St. John’s Red Storm vs Iona Gaels Picks and Predictions December 13th 2025

Last Updated on

Game Preview: Iona @ St. John’s

A unique nonconference showdown headlines Saturday afternoon in New York as the Iona Gaels visit the 22nd-ranked St. John’s Red Storm at Madison Square Garden, marking Rick Pitino’s first game against the program he rebuilt before returning to the Big East. St. John’s is closing out a demanding early schedule with its fourth game against a quality opponent in two weeks, while Iona looks to test itself against a ranked power-conference foe. The opening odds positioned St. John’s as a double-digit favorite with the total settling in the mid-140s, reflecting the Red Storm’s defensive upside and Iona’s efficient offense. With conference play approaching, this matchup carries betting relevance across the college basketball landscape tracked daily at ScoresAndStats.

sas logo

NCAAB Picks That Study the Stats for You

AI-powered. Expert-crafted.

Odds and Key Information

St. John’s opened as a 13-point favorite and the line has held steady, suggesting balanced action from both public and sharper bettors. The moneyline is heavily tilted toward the Red Storm, while the total has seen mild downward pressure after St. John’s most recent defensive performance. Early market indicators show the public leaning toward the favorite due to ranking and venue, while sharper positions appear more cautious given St. John’s recent offensive inefficiency. One notable analytical angle is pace control, as St. John’s has slowed games against stronger opponents while Iona prefers to push tempo. Pitino emphasized defensive progress following the Ole Miss win, while Iona coach Tobin Anderson has pointed to incremental defensive improvement as a focus after allowing fewer than 65 points last time out.

Basketball
2025-12-18 19:00
Open
Bradley Braves
3 PICKS
Indiana St Sycamores
Basketball
2025-12-18 19:00
Open
Western Carolina Catamounts
1 PICKS
Georgia Bulldogs
Basketball
2025-12-18 19:00
Open
Southern Utah Thunderbirds
1 PICKS
Northern Arizona Lumberjacks
Basketball
2025-12-18 20:00
Open
Georgia St Panthers
1 PICKS
Georgia Southern Eagles

St. John’s Outlook

St. John’s enters at 5-3 with clear signs of growth despite early-season turbulence. After allowing at least 80 points in each loss to Alabama, Iowa State, and Auburn, the Red Storm delivered their most complete defensive effort in a 63-58 win over Ole Miss. They held the Rebels to 36.4 percent shooting and controlled the paint, a promising indicator for a Pitino-coached team still building its identity. Zuby Ejiofor anchors both ends, averaging a team-high scoring mark while ranking among Big East leaders in rim protection. His eight-block performance last game highlighted St. John’s defensive ceiling. Offensively, consistency remains the concern, particularly from the perimeter, where the Red Storm are still searching for reliable spacing. Pitino’s decision to insert Ian Jackson into the starting lineup reflects an effort to spark shot creation and pace early.

Iona Outlook

Iona arrives with an 8-3 record and one of the most productive offenses in the MAAC, averaging 81.7 points per game. The Gaels have balanced scoring across the lineup, with four players averaging double figures, led by CJ Anthony at 16 points per game. Anthony’s ability to create off the dribble gives Iona a steady scoring option against pressure defenses. Toby Harris, Lamin Sabally, and Kosy Akametu provide complementary scoring and rebounding, allowing Iona to maintain offensive flow even when rotations shorten. Defensively, the Gaels have shown recent improvement, holding Bryant to 63 points while forcing 17 turnovers. That progress will be tested against St. John’s physicality and half-court pressure. Iona’s path to covering hinges on shot efficiency and limiting second-chance opportunities inside.

Key Matchup Table

Key FactorAdvantage
Defensive IntensitySt. John’s
Offensive BalanceIona
Rim ProtectionSt. John’s
Pace PreferenceIona
Coaching FamiliaritySt. John’s

Betting Trends

St. John’s has been inconsistent against the spread early, covering only twice in eight games as expectations adjusted following its preseason ranking. Totals involving the Red Storm have leaned under against power-conference opponents due to defensive emphasis and slower tempo. Iona has been profitable as an underdog and has covered in six of its last nine nonconference games. The Gaels have also trended toward the over when dictating pace against comparable competition. Bettors tracking matchup data and daily line movement can find updated projections through the college basketball odds and scores page. For a broader view of team profiles and trends, the NCAAB teams hub provides deeper context.

The Lean

This matchup sets up as a contrast between St. John’s defensive trajectory and Iona’s offensive rhythm. Expect Pitino’s group to emphasize ball pressure and interior defense, aiming to grind possessions and limit transition opportunities. Iona should find some success early through balanced scoring, but sustaining efficiency inside Madison Square Garden is a tall task. St. John’s offensive ceiling remains uncertain, which keeps the total in check despite Iona’s scoring profile. From a betting perspective, the Red Storm’s defensive edge and coaching familiarity point toward a methodical win rather than a runaway. Additional nonconference context and league-wide analysis can be found through the broader college basketball previews section.

Projected Final Score
St. John’s 74, Iona 62

Best Spread Pick
St. John’s -13

Total Lean
Under 145

Why You Need Expert Picks

Nonconference games featuring ranked teams often create inflated lines driven by public perception rather than matchup nuance. Expert analysis helps isolate value by incorporating efficiency metrics, pace projections, and situational angles that casual bettors miss. The ScoresAndStats college basketball picks leaderboard highlights proven handicappers who consistently identify sharp-side opportunities throughout the season. These projections are especially useful in games like St. John’s versus Iona, where coaching familiarity and tempo control play an outsized role. Bettors looking to refine their approach can also explore strategy insights and market education through the ScoresAndStats expert betting guide, which breaks down how professionals evaluate spreads, totals, and situational spots across the college basketball calendar.

Top Winners – This Week
Pro Picks – James
$1,220
2. Freudy Hockey
$1,133
3. Al Grant
$978
4. Jacob Hoffman
$882
5. Bobby Conn
$700
Top Winners – This Month
Sas Insider
$2,539
2. Evan Lewis
$1,704
3. Scott’s Picks
$1,345
4. Oskeim Sports
$1,180
5. Bobby Conn
$1,127