Vanderbilt Commodores vs Georgia State Panthers Picks and Predictions September 20th 2025

No. 20 Vanderbilt seeks revenge vs. Georgia State in nonconference clash

The Vanderbilt Commodores are ranked in the AP Top 25 for the first time since 2017 after their 31-7 upset over South Carolina. Now sitting at No. 20, Vanderbilt (3-0) aims to prove its legitimacy and settle an old score against the Georgia State Panthers. The Panthers stunned Vandy 36-32 last season, marking one of the program’s rare Power Four victories. With revenge on the Commodores’ mind and bettors lining up at college football odds boards, Saturday’s matchup in Nashville carries both pride and playoff implications.

Betting Odds and Trends

The Georgia State Panthers Can Win If…

The Georgia State Panthers must lean on their passing attack to stay competitive. With the ground game sputtering — no player has topped 100 rushing yards in a single contest — quarterbacks TJ Finley and Cameran Brown need to create chunk plays through the air. Last week, the duo combined for 251 yards and four touchdowns in a win over Murray State, giving coach Dell McGee options at signal-caller.

Wide receiver Ted Hurst remains the offensive centerpiece. Averaging 15.3 yards per catch with two scores, Hurst has proven capable of stretching defenses. If Finley and Brown can buy time against Vanderbilt’s aggressive pass rush, Hurst could provide the spark needed for an upset bid.

Defensively, Georgia State has to play mistake-free. Penalties have been costly in losses to Ole Miss and Memphis, and another sloppy outing will be fatal against a disciplined Vanderbilt offense. Limiting turnovers and field position mistakes is the only way to keep the game within reach.

The Vanderbilt Commodores Can Win If…

The Vanderbilt Commodores must continue relying on their elite defense and efficient quarterback play. Clark Lea’s defense has been one of the nation’s best, allowing just 10 points per game while ranking in the top 20 in both rushing and total defense. With seven takeaways through three games, Vanderbilt’s secondary has proven opportunistic.

Quarterback Diego Pavia has been surgical to start the season, completing over 73 percent of his passes for 645 yards and seven touchdowns. His chemistry with receiver Martel Hight, who also contributes on special teams, makes Vanderbilt dangerous in all three phases. If Pavia maintains his rhythm on third downs — where Vandy is converting 60.7 percent — the Commodores will sustain drives and wear down the Panthers.

Home field adds another layer of advantage. Vanderbilt dominated time of possession against South Carolina and will look to replicate that formula by pounding the ball, playing turnover-free football, and letting their defense dictate terms.

The Lean

Vanderbilt is favored by 24.5, and their balance on both sides of the ball suggests they can cover. Georgia State’s inconsistency at quarterback and inability to establish the run makes them unlikely to sustain drives. The projected score of 41-10 leans toward Vanderbilt -24.5 as the smart play.

The total sits at 50.5, and Vanderbilt’s stingy defense combined with Georgia State’s offensive struggles make the under the better option. While Vandy is capable of hitting big plays, they’re more likely to grind the game down, keeping the combined score under the posted number.

Game Preview Recap

For Vanderbilt, this is about proving they belong in the Top 25 and avenging last season’s stunning loss to Georgia State. Coach Clark Lea has been vocal about the importance of this game, calling it a marker of his team’s maturity. With one of the SEC’s most disciplined defenses and a breakout quarterback in Pavia, the Commodores enter as heavy favorites.

Georgia State enters as a 24.5-point underdog and still searching for consistency. The Panthers’ offense has rotated quarterbacks and failed to generate a rushing attack, but Ted Hurst gives them a dangerous weapon on the outside. McGee knows his team must cut down on costly penalties and avoid “Panther-beat-Panther” mistakes.

This will be just the second meeting between the programs, with Georgia State owning the only win from last season. For Vanderbilt, Saturday is not just about protecting their ranking, but exorcising the ghosts of 2024.

Recent Matchup