Fc Cincinnati vs New York City Fc Picks and Predictions August 23rd 2025

Last Updated on

Shaky Nastions League Cup form, Confidence Rising in Cincinnati

The league-leading FC Cincinnati (16–7–4, 52 pts) return home Saturday evening as heavy favorites to take on New York City FC (12–8–5, 41 pts). Cincinnati leads the Supporters’ Shield race—a safe bet given they’ve earned a league-best nine road wins, translating to 29 away points

At stake: a crucial home stand against Eastern Conference playoff hopefuls, starting with NYCFC.

sas logo

Upgrade Your Game with Elite MLS Club

Handicapping Be part of the action.

Opening Odds

  • Moneyline: Cincinnati favored at approximately $1.70 (or -140); NYCFC priced around $4.25 (or +325)
  • Draw: Valued around $4.10 (implied ~24%)
  • Total Goals: Pundits lean the Over, projecting a typically high-scoring MLS contest

Want sharp soccer picks daily? Check top-inch experts right now → Expert Soccer Betting Picks

The Cincinnati Advantage

  • Momentum and Consistency: Cincy comes off a gritty 3–2 win at Portland, with All-Star midfielder Evander netting his 16th goal of the season—and it happened in Portland, the team that traded him
  • Home Fortress Factor: They leverage TQL Stadium—including intimidating elements like The Bailey safe standing section—to great effect
  • Mental Edge: Coach Pat Noonan knows the belt-tightening required for a Supporters’ Shield chase. “The margins are small… this is what the games are going to feel like going forward”

The NYCFC Upside

  • Playoff-Bound Form: NYCFC earned a 2–1 win over Nashville to keep their Eastern Conference playoff push alive
  • Unbeaten in Four: They’ve generated points in six of eight since June 12—solid form for a tricky road trip
  • Historic Danger: Forward Adrian Martinez leads the team with 13 goals and could be the difference in an upset †.
  • Motivational Coach Speak: Pascal Jansen emphasizes the team’s identity, knowledge of abilities and frailties—for a charged finish in the race to qualify

Key MLS Betting Trends

CategoryFC CincinnatiNYCFC
Supporters’ ShieldLeading (tied with San Diego)Trailing, playoff position
Road Wins9 (MLS-high)Moderately strong form
Goals ScoredHigh-scoring sideDependable goal-scorer in Martinez
Odds (Moneyline)1.7 favorite4.25 underdog
Total Goals BetOver leaning

The Lean

FC Cincinnati is the dominant choice here. Their form, combined with home advantage and motivation, outweighs NYCFC’s durable but patchier rhythm. I’m backing Cincinnati Moneyline (-140) and Over 2.5 Goals for a packed, high-energy matchup.

Model Projection: FC Cincinnati 2, NYCFC 1

Explore more MLS betting insights on our Expert Picks Page.


MLS Playoff Pushes Are Real

Make every bet count as tensions boil across MLS. Check who’s trending green on the leaderboards →