Toronto Fc vs Columbus Crew Picks and Predictions August 16th 2025

Columbus Crew vs Toronto FC – Picks and Predictions (August 16, 2025)

Rested Crew Take Aim at Djordje Mihailovic, Toronto FC

The Columbus Crew return to MLS action after an extended layoff, traveling north to face Toronto FC on Saturday at BMO Field.

Toronto (5-13-7, 22 points) will showcase Djordje Mihailovic in his home debut after acquiring the U.S. international from the Colorado Rapids. Mihailovic immediately made an impact, setting up DeAndre Kerr’s stoppage-time equalizer in a 1-1 draw against the Philadelphia Union.

Dominate with 3,000+ Monthly Picks

Win more, spend less

Subscribe Now

The Crew (12-5-8, 44 points) haven’t played an MLS match since July 25, when they fell 3-1 to Orlando City after conceding three late goals. Their Aug. 9 game against New York City FC was postponed, giving them extra rest ahead of this matchup. New signing Wessam Abou Ali, a prolific scorer from Egypt’s Al Ahly, has joined the squad but may not be available for Saturday.

Match Information

• Sport: Soccer (MLS)
• Teams: Columbus Crew vs. Toronto FC
• Venue: BMO Field, Toronto, ON
• Date: Saturday, August 16, 2025
• Kickoff: 7:30 PM ET
• Betting Odds:
  • Columbus Crew Moneyline: -110
  • Toronto FC Moneyline: +260
  • Draw: +250
  • Total Over 2.5 Goals: -120
  • Total Under 2.5 Goals: +100

Columbus Crew Can Win If…

The Crew need to shake off rust and rediscover their attacking rhythm. Cucho Hernández and Diego Rossi remain critical up front, while the return of defender Malte Amundsen from injury should stabilize the back line. If new signing Abou Ali features, he could provide a needed spark in the final third.

Toronto FC Can Win If…

Toronto will lean heavily on Djordje Mihailovic’s creativity to generate scoring opportunities. With Sean Johnson possibly returning in goal, defensive confidence should improve. Federico Bernardeschi and DeAndre Kerr must finish their chances to give Toronto a shot at ending their three-match winless streak.

Key Stats Comparison

The Lean

The Crew enter as the stronger, deeper team and should benefit from their extended break. Toronto’s Mihailovic adds intrigue, but Columbus’ firepower and defensive reinforcements give them the edge. Model projection: Columbus Crew 2 – Toronto FC 1.

• Pick: Columbus Crew Moneyline (-110)
• Spread Lean: Crew -0.5
• Total Lean: Over 2.5 Goals (-120)

For more detailed breakdowns of upcoming fixtures, visit the full Soccer Previews section before placing your bets.