Toronto Maple Leafs vs Ottawa Senators Picks and Predictions April 20th 2025

History Repeats? Revisiting Past Leafs-Sens Playoff Clashes

The Senators and Maple Leafs share more than just provincial proximity — they share playoff scars. From 2000 to 2004, these teams collided in the postseason four times. Each time, Toronto came out on top. That history lingers, especially for older Ottawa fans who remember heartbreak after heartbreak.

Back then, it was Mats Sundin and Ed Belfour crushing Marian Hossa and Daniel Alfredsson’s Cup hopes. Now, it’s Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner looking to do the same to Brady Tkachuk and Tim Stützle.

But Ottawa doesn’t just want redemption. They want revenge.

For Leafs fans, anything less than a deep playoff run is failure. The Stanley Cup Odds page currently lists Toronto as one of the top-five favorites to win it all — and with good reason. Their roster is deep, experienced, and coming in hot.

Spotlight: Auston Matthews vs. Brady Tkachuk

Matthews might not have hit 50 goals this season, but he remains one of the NHL’s most lethal threats. His ability to snap a shot from anywhere on the ice forces defenses to collapse. He’s also gotten more physical, a nod to the reality of playoff hockey.

If Matthews can generate space on the power play, as outlined in the NHL Expert Betting Guide, he’ll do major damage — especially against an Ottawa penalty kill that’s struggled at times.

Brady Tkachuk – The Emotional Engine

Brady isn’t just a scorer. He’s an emotional anchor. He crashes the net, lays out hits, and chirps with the best of them. His energy is contagious — and in a rivalry like this one, that edge could make a difference.

This is Tkachuk’s first playoff series, but it already feels personal. He’s been the face of Ottawa’s rebuild and now he’s leading them into battle.

The Importance of Special Teams

In tight playoff games, power plays often determine outcomes. Here’s where both teams stand based on data from the NHL Odds and Scores page:

• Toronto Power Play: 9th in NHL
• Ottawa Power Play: 12th in NHL
• Toronto Penalty Kill: 11th
• Ottawa Penalty Kill: 16th

That edge in both departments gives Toronto a cushion — but not a guarantee. Ottawa has proven that it can turn one opportunity into momentum.

Coaches Berube and D.J. Smith will need to make real-time adjustments. Watch how both teams react after the first special-teams battle of Game 1.

Tactical Preview: How They Match Up

The Leafs love puck possession. Their zone exits are clean, they stretch defenses with cross-ice passes, and their forwards — particularly Nylander and Marner — thrive in space.

Toronto’s best hockey this year has come when their top-six are flowing with controlled entries. Expect Berube to emphasize zone control and high shot volume against Ullmark, who has shown cracks under heavy traffic.

You can dive into Toronto’s offensive metrics via their Team Page.

NBA Matchups, Odds & Picks

Sign Up Today

Get Free Trial

Ottawa’s Game Plan

Ottawa thrives in chaos. They dump and chase, they hit everything that moves, and they love to draw penalties. In transition, Stützle and Batherson can burn defenders with speed.

But they’ll need discipline. If they take early penalties, it could turn the game before it even starts.

Their young defense core will be tested — and how they stand up to Toronto’s cycle game may decide the series.

Coaching Chess: Craig Berube vs. D.J. Smith

Berube is battle-tested. He led the St. Louis Blues to a Stanley Cup and brings playoff poise. Smith is more emotional, more reactive. He’s beloved by his locker room but has never coached a playoff game.

How they deploy matchups — especially whether Ottawa tries to keep Tkachuk away from Matthews or go head-to-head — will be fascinating.

Coaches and bettors alike can explore betting systems and trends in the NHL Picks Section, especially when thinking about coaching impact in Game 1s.

Emotional Stakes: Cities and Fanbases Collide

It’s not just about the teams. The Battle of Ontario is about the people.

Toronto fans have seen their team fall flat year after year despite talent. They’re hungry. They’re anxious. And they’re loud.

Ottawa fans are the opposite. They’ve waited patiently through rebuilds, top-10 picks, and playoff misses. Their return to the postseason feels like a reawakening. You can feel it in the city — flags, jerseys, chants.

This isn’t just hockey. It’s provincial pride.

Series X-Factors

• Jake Sanderson (OTT): A breakout game from the rookie defenseman could swing momentum. He’s poised beyond his years.
• Max Domi (TOR): If Domi gets going on the third line, Toronto’s depth scoring becomes nearly unstoppable.
• Anton Forsberg (OTT): Don’t be shocked if he replaces Ullmark mid-series if things go sideways.

Don’t Miss This Series

Bookmark these top resources to stay up to speed:

• NHL Team Page for rosters, stats, and injury reports
• Stanley Cup Odds for futures movement
• Atlantic Division Odds to compare Leafs and Sens standing all year
• Conference Winner Odds for deeper playoff context

Final Thought: Leafs in Six… But Don’t Count Out the Senators

The safe pick is Toronto in six games. They’ve got the talent, the experience, the goaltending, and home-ice. But Ottawa? They’re not here to be a warm-up. They’re here to shock the hockey world — and if they grab Game 1, don’t be surprised if they push this to the brink.

Want game-by-game previews and picks? Keep checking Scores and Stats NHL Picks for updates throughout the series.