Buffalo Sabres vs Columbus Blue Jackets Picks and Predictions April 9th 2026

Buffalo Sabres vs Columbus Blue Jackets Thu, Apr 9, 00:00 am.
Buffalo Sabres
ML: -125
0
0
Columbus Blue Jackets
ML: +105
Last Updated on

The Columbus Blue Jackets head to KeyBank Center on Thursday night in a game that still carries real pressure for both sides, even if the pressure is a little different. Columbus is 39-27-12 and still chasing the final playoff spots in both the Metropolitan Division and the Eastern wild-card race, while Buffalo is 48-23-8 and now sits alone in first place in the Atlantic. Puck drop is set for 7:00 p.m. ET on ESPN+, and the scheduling spot matters because the Sabres are coming off a road win over the Rangers on Wednesday night.

Columbus at least arrives with some life again after a 4-3 shootout win in Detroit snapped a six-game skid. Zach Werenski carried a huge load in that game, Adam Fantilli scored the late equalizer, and the Jackets kept their playoff hopes from slipping away entirely. Buffalo, meanwhile, keeps stacking meaningful wins. The Sabres rallied past New York 5-3 on Wednesday and are now trying to hold off both Tampa Bay and Montreal for the division crown.

Go Inside the Handicappers’ Playbook

All in one spot. Real-time line moves, sharp reads, and verified edges.

Columbus Blue Jackets vs Buffalo Sabres Odds

These are the current betting lines for this matchup, and bettors should always monitor the latest NHL odds before puck drop in case goalie confirmation or late lineup news moves the market.

TeamMoneylinePuck LineTotal
Columbus Blue Jackets+110+1.5 (-245)O 6.5 (+105)
Buffalo Sabres-130-1.5 (+200)U 6.5 (-125)

Columbus Blue Jackets Betting Form

Columbus is a little tricky to price right now because the recent record is messy, but the underlying desperation is obvious. The Blue Jackets are 3-6-1 over their last 10, yet they still own the season series against Buffalo 2-0 and just got the kind of emotional win in Detroit that can keep a late push alive. Offensively, they are averaging 3.05 goals per game, and they still generate a healthy 29.2 shots per night, which is enough to stay live as a road dog against almost anyone. The broader picture on the Columbus Blue Jackets stats and results page fits that idea pretty well.

The bigger question is whether Columbus can string together two strong efforts in a row after burning so much energy Tuesday. Werenski is the obvious engine, and Fantilli plus Kirill Marchenko give them enough finishing to threaten Buffalo’s defense, but the Jackets are still missing important depth. Damon Severson is out for the season after shoulder surgery, and that is not a small loss on the back end. Keep an eye on the Columbus Blue Jackets injury report before puck drop because this team is thin enough that one more absence can shift the matchup.

Ice Hockey
2026-04-09 21:10
Open
Minnesota Wild
Dallas Stars

Buffalo Sabres Betting Form

Buffalo has been one of the better stories in the league this season, and the current position is earned. The Sabres are 25-10-4 at home, they are scoring 3.42 goals per game, and they have paired that offense with a respectable 2.99 goals-against average. Wednesday’s win over the Rangers was a good snapshot of what makes them dangerous. They can get production from different lines, they can survive some swings in game state, and they still have enough firepower up top with Alex Tuch, Jason Zucker, Ryan McLeod, Tage Thompson, and Rasmus Dahlin. The Buffalo Sabres schedule and stats page reflects a team with fewer obvious weaknesses than Columbus.

The one thing worth respecting here is the fatigue angle. Buffalo is on the second half of a back-to-back after playing in New York on Wednesday, and late-season games can get strange when a contender comes home on short rest to face a desperate opponent. That said, the Sabres have still gone 5-3-2 over their last 10 and now have a chance to keep control of the Atlantic. Monitor the Buffalo Sabres injury report as well, especially with forward depth already affected, but this is still the more complete team and the market is reflecting that for a reason.

Columbus Blue Jackets vs Buffalo Sabres Matchup Breakdown

This matchup really starts with game script. Columbus would probably prefer something urgent and a little chaotic, because that is where its need and top-end defenseman usage can drag the game into a coin flip. Buffalo would rather play from ahead, roll deeper lines, and let its superior offensive balance take over. From a basic NHL betting guide perspective, Buffalo has the cleaner profile, but the spot is not quite as easy as the standings make it look because Columbus is still playing for its season.

The special-teams angle is also worth noting. Buffalo has the better penalty kill, 81.4 percent to Columbus’ 75.9 percent, while the power-play gap is much smaller. That nudges the matchup slightly toward the Sabres, especially if Columbus starts chasing the game and takes penalties. Still, the Jackets have already beaten Buffalo twice this season, and that matters just enough to keep me from treating this like a routine home favorite spot. If you zoom out to the bigger playoff picture through the Stanley Cup betting market, Buffalo is clearly the steadier team, but this individual game has more volatility than that suggests.

Columbus Blue Jackets vs Buffalo Sabres Predictions and Best Bets

My first lean is Buffalo on the moneyline, but I do not love it at this price. The Sabres are the better team, they have been better at home all season, and they are deeper offensively. That is the easy case. The harder part is whether this is the right spot to pay for them when they are coming off a road game the night before and facing a Columbus team that just saved its season, at least for one more night. Even so, Buffalo still feels like the more trustworthy side.

The total is more interesting to me. Six and a half feels fair, but I still lean over because both teams have enough offensive pieces to get there, and the situational setup can push games into late scoring. Columbus needs points, which makes it more likely to empty the net early if trailing, and Buffalo has been involved in several higher-event games lately. I would not call the over a slam dunk, though. Columbus has averaged only 2.1 goals over its last 10, so a lot of the burden may fall on Buffalo to drive the pace.

There is also a small case for Columbus plus the goal and a half if that is the preferred risk profile, because the Jackets have played Buffalo well and the desperation angle is real. I still think the cleaner betting lane is the Buffalo side because the Sabres have more ways to win the game. If you want to compare this one to the rest of the slate before locking it in, the latest NHL previews help frame where this number sits relative to the other late-season playoff-race games.

Best Bet: Buffalo Sabres moneyline (-130).

Every Pick. Every Sport. All Verified.

Follow sharp cappers across NFL, NBA, MLB, and more

NHL Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats

Late in the regular season, it helps to compare multiple opinions instead of betting the first angle that looks obvious. Schedule spots, goalie rotation, and playoff urgency can all shift prices quickly, so checking today’s NHL picks is useful when the board is full of teams playing for very different things.

It also helps to know which handicappers are actually winning over time. The top sports handicappers page and the handicapper leaderboard make it easier to compare styles, records, and long-term performance. For bettors who want a more aggressive approach during the playoff push, that is also where premium NHL picks fit naturally.

Top Winners – Yesterday
Brad Mullins
$658
2. Coach Rick
$600
3. Pro Picks – James
$582
4. Evan Lewis
$525
5. Sas Insider
$500
Top Winners – This Week
Brad Mullins
$1,884
2. Pro Picks – James
$1,820
3. Bang The Book
$1,319
4. Sports Central
$1,263
5. Jay Cooper
$1,136