New York Yankees vs Detroit Tigers Picks and Predictions September 11th 2025

New York Yankees vs Detroit Tigers September 11th 2025

The Detroit Tigers will visit the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium on Thursday, September 11, 2025. The game is set to start at 7:05 PM and will be broadcast on FDSDE. The Tigers come into this game with an 84-62 record, leading the AL Central, and are on a two-game winning streak.

The Yankees hold an 80-65 record and are ranked third in the AL East. They are looking to break a two-game losing streak. Tyler Holton will start for the Tigers, while Cam Schlittler will take the mound for the Yankees. The weather forecast predicts a warm day with scattered clouds and a light breeze.

Tigers vs Yankees Key Information

• Sport: Baseball
• Teams: Detroit Tigers vs. New York Yankees
• Venue: Yankee Stadium in New York, NY
• Date: Thursday, September 11, 2025
• Betting Odds: Tigers Moneyline +136, Yankees Moneyline -162, Tigers Runline +1.5 (-149), Yankees Runline -1.5 (+125), Total Over 8.5 (-121), Total Under 8.5 (-101)

The Tigers Can Win If…

The Detroit Tigers come into this game with momentum after a strong win over the New York Yankees, 11-1. Jack Flaherty pitched five innings, allowing only two hits and no runs, while striking out seven. Key hitters like Riley Greene, Kerry Carpenter, and Colt Keith each hit home runs, contributing to the team’s offensive display.

The Tigers have a solid batting lineup, ranking 7th in batting average at .251 and on-base percentage at .319. Their ability to hit home runs is evident, with 184 home runs this season, also ranked 7th. This power at the plate gives them a chance to score runs quickly and put pressure on opposing pitchers.

On the mound, Tyler Holton will start for the Tigers, with an ERA of 3.80 and a WHIP of 1.12. Holton’s ability to keep runners off base is a strength, and his performance can set the tone for the game. With a balanced approach in both hitting and pitching, the Tigers have the tools needed to secure another win.

The Yankees Can Win If…

The New York Yankees are looking to bounce back after a tough 11-1 loss to the Detroit Tigers. Despite the loss, Carlos Rodón showed skill on the mound with 6 innings pitched, allowing only 2 earned runs and striking out 6. Austin Wells was a bright spot in the lineup, hitting a solo home run.

The Yankees have strong stats this season that can lead them to victory. They rank 1st in slugging percentage (.453) and home runs (246), showing their power at the plate. Their on-base percentage is 4th in the league, which means they get on base often and can create scoring chances.

Cam Schlittler will start for the Yankees, bringing a solid 3.24 ERA to the mound. This gives the team confidence in their pitching. With Aaron Judge leading the lineup, hitting .319 with 44 home runs, the Yankees have the potential to turn things around and win this game.

The Lean

The Yankees are favored with a moneyline of -162. The Tigers are at +136. The Yankees have strong hitting stats, leading in slugging percentage and home runs. The Tigers rank lower in these areas. My model projects the Yankees to win 5-3. The recommendation is to pick the Yankees to win straight up.

The total for the game is set at 8.5. The Yankees’ offense is ranked first in slugging and home runs. The Tigers’ pitching has a decent ERA but struggles with strikeouts. My model projects a total of 8 runs. The recommendation is to pick the under 8.5.

Score a Homerun!

With our Premium Handicapping Membership

Get Free Trial

Tigers Bring Complete Game to the Bronx

The Detroit Tigers opened the season beating the New York Yankees with pitching in cold April conditions. Now, as September rolls on, the bats have joined the mix. Detroit enters Thursday night’s finale in New York with a chance to complete a three-game sweep and secure its first sweep at Yankee Stadium since 2008.

Detroit (84-62) has taken control of the season series, winning four of five games while outscoring the Yankees 37-9. In Wednesday’s 11-1 rout, the Tigers pounded out 16 hits and scored nine runs over the final three innings. It was their 16th double-digit scoring effort of the season and their third straight game with at least 10 runs. Bettors looking for value in spots like this can explore the latest MLB picks

Offense Fuels Detroit’s Surge

Former Yankee Gleyber Torres drove in three runs to set the tone before Detroit’s power bats broke things open. Riley Greene, Kerry Carpenter, and Colt Keith all hit two-run homers, while Parker Meadows added an RBI single and reached base three times. Greene finished with three RBIs as the Tigers posted their highest hit total in New York since 2018.

The balanced attack has come alongside strong pitching. Casey Mize and Jack Flaherty delivered quality starts to begin the series, helping Detroit to a 1.40 ERA against New York this season. Thursday will feature a bullpen game with left-hander Tyler Holton opening. Holton owns a 1.46 ERA in eight career outings against the Yankees. Sawyer Gipson-Long is expected to work in long relief. Fans can track matchups like this in the daily MLB previews

Yankees Search for Answers

The Yankees (80-65) are hitting just .198 against Detroit this year and have only 12 hits across the first two games of the series. Austin Wells homered Wednesday, but Aaron Judge grounded into two double plays, Giancarlo Stanton is mired in a 3-for-35 slump, and Trent Grisham along with Ben Rice continue to struggle at the plate.

New York’s bullpen has also been an issue, allowing 19 runs in the series and carrying a 7.53 ERA against the Tigers. Manager Aaron Boone admitted the late collapses have been frustrating but stressed the importance of resetting quickly. Bettors can lean on the expert betting guide to identify how slumps and bullpen struggles impact wagering opportunities.

Probable Pitching Matchup

Cam Schlittler (2-3, 3.24 ERA) will start for New York in his 10th career appearance. The young right-hander was knocked out in the second inning in his last outing against Toronto, giving up four runs on five hits. Before that, he had allowed just one run across three starts. Thursday marks his first career start against Detroit.

Detroit will rely on Holton and Gipson-Long to manage innings against a Yankees lineup desperate to find momentum. Bettors can follow plays from top performers on the handicapper leaderboard when evaluating pitching matchups like these.

Postseason Stakes

Despite the blowout losses, the Yankees remain three games behind the Toronto Blue Jays in the AL East and tied with the Boston Red Sox for the top AL Wild Card spot. Their upcoming series in Boston looms as a pivotal stretch.

The Tigers, meanwhile, are heating up at the right time. With a combination of timely hitting and dependable pitching, they are building momentum toward a potential postseason push. For fans tracking every win and loss, the MLB game results page provides updated outcomes.

For those looking to get in on the action, the latest buy picks are available from proven experts ahead of Thursday night’s finale in the Bronx.