New York Islanders vs Anaheim Ducks Picks and Predictions December 11th 2025

Last Updated on

Match Facts

ItemDetail
GameAnaheim Ducks at New York Islanders
VenueUBS Arena, Elmont, New York
Schedule spotBoth teams coming off shootout wins on Tuesday; Islanders at home, Ducks continuing strong start
Recent form – IslandersFour wins in last five; three recent wins vs Tampa Bay/Colorado plus comeback vs Vegas
Recent form – DucksFour wins in last five; 8-1 in OT/SO games, multiple comeback victories
Division standingIslanders third in Metropolitan; Ducks leading the Pacific by a small margin
Season narrativeBoth clubs bouncing back from disappointing seasons under revamped front offices and coaching staffs

For a full look at how both clubs stack up across the league, you can dig into their profiles on the NHL teams hub under the main NHL teams page, and see how this matchup compares price-wise on the live NHL scores and odds board.

Line and Odds

  • Moneyline: Islanders favored at home, Ducks priced as a short road underdog
  • Puck line: Islanders -1.5 at plus money; Ducks +1.5 shaded as the “safer” side in a projected one-goal game
  • Total: 6.0 goals, with shading toward the over given both teams’ recent scoring form and OT/shootout profiles

Movement Matchup

This is a market adjustment game more than a typical “buy low/sell high” spot. The Islanders and Ducks have both been upgraded by oddsmakers after proving their early results are not just a one-week heater.

New York’s profile is built on structure. With Mathieu Darche reshaping the roster and Patrick Roy doubling down on details, the Islanders have quietly stacked wins against legitimate contenders: three victories over Tampa Bay and Colorado in a five-day window, then a resilient shootout win over Vegas where they dug out of a 2-0 hole. The emergence of rookie Matthew Schaefer and pick-up Emil Heineman gives them scoring and energy beyond the usual core, exactly the kind of depth that shows up as a positive in longer-range Metropolitan Division breakdowns like the Metropolitan Division odds outlook.

Anaheim’s move up the board is driven by volatility in a good way. Joel Quenneville has them playing fast, aggressive hockey with enough structure to survive mistakes. Beckett Sennecke has broken out as the first rookie to reach 25 points, and Chris Kreider’s presence on the wing gives them a proven finisher in tight games. The Ducks have trailed in 10 of their 19 wins and are 8-1 in games decided in overtime or a shootout, which is why they’ve become a regular talking point in Pacific-focused futures pieces like the Pacific Division odds breakdown.

Because both are trending up at the same time, the market is forced to pick which form is more sustainable: the Islanders’ defense-first structure and home-ice edge, or the Ducks’ comeback-heavy, late-game magic. That tension is what keeps this line relatively tight despite UBS Arena being one of the tougher buildings for visitors when New York is rolling.

sas logo

Follow Winning Trends Across Every League

The Smartest Way to Bet Daily

Breakdown Injury Reports

New York Islanders injury report

PlayerStatusNote
Jonathan Drouin (F)Out / day-to-dayLower-body injury; has missed four straight games but remains an important middle-six playmaker
Matthew Schaefer (D)ActiveNo injury issues noted; thriving in big minutes for a rookie
Emil Heineman (F)ActiveHealthy and contributing in the middle six; scored the lone shootout goal vs Golden Knights
GoaltendingExpected regular tandemNo new injury news reported; usual starter expected for a key home spot

Anaheim Ducks injury report

PlayerStatusNote
Beckett Sennecke (F)ActiveRookie sensation; first NHL rookie to hit 25 points, scored the last-second equalizer in Pittsburgh
Chris Kreider (F)ActiveVeteran addition has stayed healthy and is providing secondary scoring and leadership
Leo Carlsson (F)ActiveDelivered the shootout winner vs Penguins; usage continues to rise in key situations
GoaltendingRegular rotationNo specific injuries noted in the report; standard rotation expected unless late news breaks

Given how both rosters are largely intact outside of Drouin’s absence, deeper matchup angles will lean heavily on systems and form, the kind of nuance that gets unpacked more thoroughly in the NHL expert betting guide.

New York Islanders Recent Performance

The Islanders’ current run is built on an identity that finally matches their roster. They’ve strung together wins over Tampa Bay and Colorado by sticking to a disciplined defensive shell, limiting inside looks and forcing elite offenses to the outside. That same template allowed them to weather an early 2-0 deficit vs Vegas and slowly drag the game back to their preferred pace before winning in a shootout.

Matthew Schaefer’s impact cannot be overstated. As a rookie defenseman, he is already driving play in both directions, adding a modern puck-moving element without sacrificing the physical and positional game Roy demands. Heineman’s arrival gives them another shooter and forechecker who can tilt individual shifts. Even without Drouin, New York suddenly have multiple lines that can win shifts territorially rather than just surviving.

At home, that style travels even better: last change lets Roy hunt matchups for Schaefer, and the Islanders can deploy their checking units to smother opposing top lines. That is why they are slowly easing into the conversation in Eastern-focused futures talk and long-view content like conference odds breakdowns, even if they’re not yet in the inner circle of favorites.

Anaheim Ducks Recent Performance

Anaheim’s recent stretch has been about refusing to die in games that used to bury them. They’ve trailed in more than half of their wins this season and still managed to climb back, and Tuesday’s last-second equalizer from Sennecke followed by a shootout victory in Pittsburgh is the perfect snapshot. Quenneville has given them structure, but he has not strangled their creativity; they still play with enough freedom to generate big plays when chasing a game.

Sennecke’s breakout as the first rookie to reach 25 points has given the Ducks a legitimate star-in-the-making. His size, hands and “slippery” game force defenders to respect both shot and pass, and that opens lanes for line-mates. Kreider’s arrival from the Rangers added a net-front presence and big-moment scorer who is used to playing in high-leverage games in tough buildings, something Anaheim lacked in previous years. Leo Carlsson’s shootout winner in Pittsburgh is another sign that young pieces are comfortable in pressure spots.

The concern, from a betting standpoint, is that relying on comebacks and OT/SO success is inherently volatile. Being 8-1 in extra-time games is a weapon, but it is not the kind of edge you can bank on every night. That is why, in broader championship conversations like the league-wide Stanley Cup odds picture, Anaheim still sits a tier or two below the truly elite despite their hot start.

Stylistically, this is a clash between a team that wants to control the game early and one that is remarkably comfortable chasing it. The Islanders have tightened up defensively and are confident that if they stick to their structure, the chances and wins will come over 60 minutes. They have already shown they can handle elite transition teams, which matters against a Ducks group that loves to turn loose pucks into rush opportunities.

Anaheim’s resilience and OT/SO record mean that they are never out of a game, but that profile tends to be more attractive at home or in big plus-money spots where you’re betting on chaos. On the road in a building where the Islanders are feeling increasingly comfortable, you need to decide whether the comeback magic and shootout proficiency can hold up against a team that rarely beats itself when locked in.

Totals are tricky here. New York’s structural improvements suggest the under is live, but both offenses have enough pop – and enough talent on the power play – to push the game into a 4-3 type script if penalties and odd-man rushes show up. That is the kind of nuance that handicappers will weigh alongside the rest of the Thursday board and the deeper analytical insights pulled into the broader NHL betting guide.

sas logo

Streamline Your Picks in One Dashboard

All Sports. All Experts. One Login.

Best Bets and Prediction

Projected score: Islanders 3, Ducks 2

The most likely script has the Islanders using home ice and matchup control to blunt Anaheim’s speed and rush game, forcing the Ducks to work through layers in the offensive zone. New York’s structure and recent habit of handling top-tier opponents make them slightly more trustworthy over 60 minutes than a Ducks team that has leaned heavily on late-game drama and extra-time success.

Anaheim still has a clear path to making this interesting: if they can get the first goal and drag the Islanders into a higher-tempo, trade-chances environment, their young skill and hot OT/SO profile come into play again. But in a straight handicap, New York’s combination of system, form and home-ice advantage gives them the edge.

For pure side value, the lean is Islanders on the moneyline, with the puck line more of a secondary angle if you think Anaheim’s comeback reservoir is finally due for some regression. The projected 3-2 score sits right on the fence at 5–6 total goals, so the total is thinner; the cleaner path is aligning with the Islanders as the more stable, repeatable side.

Handicapper section

From a handicapper’s perspective, this matchup is less about finding a big pricing mistake and more about choosing between two different kinds of hot streaks. The Islanders are winning the way playoff teams win: structured, repeatable habits, depth contributions, and the ability to dictate the type of game being played, especially at home. That profile fits neatly with how successful sides tend to rate in deeper-season strategy content like the NHL betting guide and divisional futures breakdowns.

The Ducks are winning in a way that is extremely fun but less bankable long term: constant comebacks, elite OT/SO results, and a rookie carrying a big share of the offensive load. That does not mean you fade them automatically, but it does mean you should be more selective. As a big home dog or in spots where the matchup clearly tilts toward their strengths, they can still be a sharp side. In a game like this – tight number, tough building, opponent with a strong structural edge – you are asking a volatile profile to thread the needle again.

Top Winners – This Week
Pro Picks – James
$1,220
2. Freudy Hockey
$1,133
3. Al Grant
$978
4. Jacob Hoffman
$882
5. Bobby Conn
$700
Top Winners – This Month
Sas Insider
$2,539
2. Evan Lewis
$1,704
3. Scott’s Picks
$1,345
4. Oskeim Sports
$1,180
5. Bobby Conn
$1,127