Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders Picks and Predictions – March 26, 2026

Last Updated on

The Dallas Stars open a four-game road trip Thursday night at UBS Arena in Elmont, New York, and they need the reset. Dallas is 43-17-11 and already locked into the postseason, but this team has dropped three straight and looked loose defensively in a 6-4 loss to New Jersey on Tuesday. The Islanders are 40-27-5, still chasing a playoff spot in the East, and they come in off a 4-3 loss to Chicago that followed the same ugly script: early defensive breakdowns, a hole too deep to climb out of, and a late push that came up short. Puck drop is set for 7:00 p.m. ET on ESPN+, and the market has Dallas as a modest road favorite with a low total of 5.5.

There is a little tension in this number, which makes the handicap interesting. Dallas still owns the stronger profile on paper and has been excellent on the road at 21-7-7, but the Stars opened a bit more expensive and the market has softened slightly toward New York. That usually tells you bettors are at least respecting the Islanders’ desperation, home ice, and goaltending path. Dallas is trying to clean up its structure before the playoffs. New York is trying to stay alive right now. Those are different motivations, and I think they matter here.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders Odds

These are the current betting lines for Thursday’s matchup, and bettors should always monitor the latest NHL odds before puck drop in case goalie confirmation or late injury news moves the board.

TeamMoneylinePuck LineTotal
Dallas Stars-122-1.5 (+205)O 5.5 (-120)
New York Islanders+102+1.5 (-250)U 5.5 (EVEN)

Track Every Line Move Before It Happens

Stay Ahead of the Public, Every Time

Dallas Stars Betting Form

Dallas is not playing its cleanest hockey, but the underlying strengths are still there. This team scores 3.37 goals per game, converts at 29.0% on the power play, and still has enough top-end skill to punish mistakes quickly. Jason Robertson and Wyatt Johnston continue to drive the offense, and Johnston’s power-play production has been a real edge lately. Even during this three-game skid, Dallas has not looked short on chance creation. The bigger issue has been puck management and defensive sloppiness, especially early in games. You can get a fuller look at the team profile on the Dallas Stars stats and results page.

That matters for bettors because Dallas is walking into a game where the market is still pricing them as the better team, just not by a huge margin. If the Stars tighten up in their own end, the road moneyline is very playable. If they keep giving away rush chances and breakaways, they become much harder to trust at favorite prices. Jake Oettinger was pulled Tuesday, but that sounded more like a message to the skaters than a true indictment of his form, and he was listed as the unconfirmed projected starter for Thursday. The injury picture is worth monitoring, too, with Roope Hintz out, Mikko Rantanen still on IR, and Tyler Seguin and Radek Faksa remaining unavailable. Availability matters here, so keep an eye on the Dallas Stars injury report before betting into this number.

New York Islanders Betting Form

The Islanders are in a tougher spot because every point matters and the margin for error feels thin. They have gone 3-4 over the past seven games, and all four losses in that stretch came in regulation. Still, this is not a team getting blown off the ice every night. Three of those defeats were by one goal, and when New York keeps the game compact, it can still make life difficult. The bigger picture on the New York Islanders schedule and stats page shows a club scoring only 2.85 goals per game, but one that remains live in lower-event games because Sorokin can steal them and the structure is usually better at home.

There are some real concerns on the blue line, though. Ryan Pulock has missed the last two games, Tony DeAngelo left Tuesday’s loss with a lower-body issue, and Alexander Romanov remains out. That leaves the Islanders leaning even harder on rookie Matthew Schaefer, who has been excellent and is producing like a difference-maker from the back end, but asking a teenager to carry that kind of load in a playoff race is a lot. Goalie confirmation was still unsettled Thursday after David Rittich started Tuesday and Sorokin came on in relief, and that uncertainty matters for the side and total. New York’s penalty kill is serviceable enough, but the power play sits at just 16.4%, which is not ideal against a Dallas team that can win the special-teams battle. Monitor the New York Islanders injury report before puck drop.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders Matchup Breakdown

This matchup starts with style. Dallas wants to lean on its skill and its special teams, and even in a rough patch the Stars have the more dangerous offensive ceiling. New York wants this game to stay tight, probably a little choppy, and decided by a handful of key shifts rather than a wide-open track meet. That is not a bad recipe against a Stars team that has been careless with the puck lately, but it is still a hard way to live against Robertson, Johnston, and a Dallas power play that can flip the game quickly.

The special-teams gap is one of the cleaner edges on the board. Dallas is running a 29.0% power play, while New York is down at 16.4%. The penalty kills are close enough that I would not call that side of the equation decisive, but if this game gets whistle-heavy, the Stars have the much more threatening unit. That is usually where an NHL betting guide becomes useful, because these lower-total games often swing on a single man-advantage chance rather than five-on-five volume alone.

The goaltending angle is a little murkier than usual because neither team had officially confirmed a starter early Thursday. Oettinger was the listed unconfirmed option for Dallas, and the Islanders had used both Rittich and Sorokin on Tuesday. If Sorokin starts, New York becomes much more attractive as a home dog and the under gets stronger. If Rittich goes again behind a thin defense group, the Stars’ team total becomes more appealing. That uncertainty is part of the handicap, honestly. It is also why I would not rush into the market too early if you are trying to squeeze the best number.

There is also a bigger-picture angle here. Dallas is still playing for rhythm and playoff sharpness, while the Islanders are playing for survival. Sometimes that favors the desperate team. Sometimes it leads to over-aggression and mistakes. I think New York’s urgency keeps this competitive, but Dallas still has the deeper forward group, the better road record, and a stronger chance to own the special-teams battle. If you are looking at futures context, that contrast is pretty much the difference between a legit contender and a team still trying to stay in the conversation, which is where a Stanley Cup betting guide can help frame things.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders Predictions and Best Bets

My lean is Dallas on the moneyline, though I do not love laying a big tax here, and thankfully the price is not huge anymore. The early move from around -130 to -122 matters because it gives a little more breathing room on the favorite. Even with the recent slide, Dallas still brings the better offensive profile, better power play, and better road resume into this game. I think the Stars are the more likely side to correct their mistakes because their issues lately have looked more like execution and attention lapses than a roster-level problem.

The total is where I am a little more cautious. A 5.5 naturally points bettors toward the under, and there is a reasonable case for it. New York does not score much, Dallas should want a stingier road game, and if Sorokin starts the Islanders can drag this into a 3-2 kind of night. But Dallas games have become a little sloppier lately, and both teams just allowed four goals in ugly Tuesday losses. So while the under makes sense on paper, I do not think it is as comfortable as the number suggests. One bad defensive period could wreck it.

If you want a secondary angle, I would rather look Dallas moneyline than Dallas puck line. New York has been living in close games, and the Islanders’ path to competing usually keeps the score tight even in losses. The Stars can absolutely win this by two, but the stronger value for me is still on the straight side, especially with the market pulling the price down a bit from the opener.

Best Bet: Dallas Stars moneyline (-122).

NHL Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats

If you are betting more than one game on the board, it makes sense to start with today’s NHL picks and the full NHL previews page. That gives you a broader view of the slate instead of forcing one game to carry all your action, and that matters on nights like this when goalie confirmation can still shift a number late.

ScoresAndStats is also useful because you can compare opinions instead of following one voice blindly. The top sports handicappers page and the handicapper leaderboard make it easier to track long-term performance, recent runs, and different betting styles across the board. That kind of transparency is a lot more useful than random hot takes, especially for NHL bettors who may prefer sides, totals, or more selective card-building.

And if you want a stronger conviction play instead of free content alone, premium NHL picks are part of the mix as well. The best way to use all of it is pretty simple: compare the board, find the cappers whose style matches your own, and look for spots where the number still leaves room for value.

Top Winners – Yesterday
Randall Dickelman
$912
2. Heather Williams
$641
3. Jhon Walsh
$430
4. Sports Investors
$400
5. Jimmy Liu
$376
Top Winners – This Week
Pro Picks – Ben
$1,362
2. Heather Williams
$1,191
3. Sports Central
$1,140
4. Randall Dickelman
$1,011
5. Sports Investors
$731