Toronto Maple Leafs vs Tampa Bay Lightning Picks and Predictions December 8th 2025

Last Updated on

Game Preview Toronto Maple Leafs @ Tampa Bay Lightning

The Toronto Maple Leafs head south to face the Tampa Bay Lightning in a marquee Atlantic Division matchup at Amalie Arena on Monday, December 8, 2025. This contest features two high-powered offenses and deep playoff aspirations, with both teams jockeying for position in one of the NHL’s most competitive divisions.

Toronto enters the game riding a five-game winning streak, including a shootout win over Florida in their last outing. The Leafs have tightened up defensively while continuing to generate consistent scoring from their top six. Tampa Bay, meanwhile, is navigating an injury-plagued stretch but remains dangerous at home. After dropping two of their last three, the Lightning are looking to regain rhythm against a familiar divisional rival.

This matchup has significant betting implications, with totals, props, and puck line opportunities presenting value across markets. Bettors tracking trends, line movement, and goalie confirmations will want to monitor this game closely on the NHL scores and odds page.

sas logo

Access Thousands of Data-Driven Plays

From the First Pitch to the Final Whistle

Odds and Key Information Table

CategoryDetails
MatchupToronto Maple Leafs @ Tampa Bay Lightning
Date and TimeMonday, December 8, 2025 – 7:00 PM ET
LocationAmalie Arena, Tampa, FL
Opening LineMaple Leafs -115, Lightning -105
Over/Under6.5 goals
Toronto Record16-9-2
Tampa Bay Record15-11-1
TV BroadcastESPN+, TSN4
Last MeetingApril 2025 – Toronto 5, Tampa Bay 4 (OT)

Toronto Maple Leafs Outlook

The Maple Leafs are currently one of the hottest teams in the NHL, riding a five-game winning streak and surging into second place in the Atlantic Division standings. Toronto’s recent run has been fueled by strong goaltending from Ilya Samsonov, better defensive zone exits, and the return to form of its offensive core.

Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner continue to pace the attack, combining for 64 points through 27 games. William Nylander remains a critical secondary scoring piece, and the power play has been clicking at 27.2 percent, ranking fourth in the league. Toronto’s penalty kill has also improved and is now above 80 percent.

On the road, the Leafs have been solid with an 8-4-2 record and are 6-3 against the puck line in their last nine away games. Their expected goals for percentage has improved significantly since mid-November, showing that the Leafs are winning not just on talent, but structure.

For broader context on Toronto’s divisional outlook, check out the Atlantic Division predictions.

Tampa Bay Lightning Outlook

The Lightning remain a dangerous team despite a tough stretch filled with injuries and inconsistent goaltending. At 15-11-1, Tampa Bay sits fourth in the Atlantic Division but has been inconsistent in recent games, especially in transition defense.

Offensively, Nikita Kucherov is once again leading the league in points, and Brayden Point continues to be a difference-maker at even strength. However, the Lightning’s depth has taken a hit with injuries to Anthony Cirelli and Mikhail Sergachev. The power play remains elite at 28.3 percent but has cooled slightly over the last five games.

In goal, Jonas Johansson has held the crease while Andrei Vasilevskiy continues recovery from minor lower-body soreness. Tampa is just 3-4 in its last seven games but has remained competitive at home with a 9-5 record at Amalie Arena.

To see how Tampa Bay’s current trend compares with division rivals, visit the NHL Atlantic Division betting blog.

Key Matchup

Toronto’s power play versus Tampa Bay’s penalty kill could be the deciding factor. The Leafs have scored a power play goal in six of their last seven games, largely thanks to zone entries by Marner and net-front screens by Matthews. Tampa Bay’s penalty kill is average at 79.6 percent and has allowed four power play goals in its last three contests.

The speed and puck movement of Toronto’s top unit may stretch Tampa’s shorthanded forwards, especially with Sergachev out. If the Leafs generate multiple man-advantage chances, they could break this game open.

This special teams edge is worth considering for side and total bettors alike. For deeper analytics-driven breakdowns, refer to the expert NHL betting guide.

sas logo

Discover Where the Sharps Are Betting

Real Trends, Real Edges, Real Wins

Betting Trends

Toronto is 5-0 in its last five games and 6-2 in its last eight road games. The over has hit in four of their last five matchups, driven by elite scoring depth and improved puck movement through the neutral zone.

Tampa Bay is 2-4 in its last six games overall and just 1-5 against the spread when allowing three or more goals. At home, the Lightning are still profitable, going 7-2 in their last nine at Amalie Arena.

In head-to-head matchups, the Maple Leafs have won four of the last six meetings, including a thrilling overtime victory last April. The over has hit in five of the last seven games between these two Atlantic powerhouses.

For up-to-date betting angles and market shifts, visit the NHL picks and predictions section.

Prediction

This is a classic Atlantic Division rivalry that rarely disappoints. Both teams can score in bunches, but Toronto’s current form and the edge in goaltending give them a slight advantage. The Leafs’ ability to win at both ends of the ice makes them a solid pick, especially if Vasilevskiy is confirmed out.

Tampa Bay remains dangerous, particularly if Kucherov has space on the power play, but Toronto has more lineup balance and fewer defensive breakdowns over the past month. Expect a high-tempo game with plenty of scoring chances.

Final score prediction: Toronto Maple Leafs 4, Tampa Bay Lightning 3
Top play: Maple Leafs ML (-115)
Lean: Over 6.5 goals

Why You Need Expert Picks

This game features tight odds, injury news, and elite offenses that shift lines fast. Whether you’re betting on sides, totals, or player props, you need expert advice and data modeling to stay ahead of the market.

To get the most accurate NHL betting predictions, explore our full NHL picks section, updated conference outlook, and Stanley Cup predictions.

Track the best NHL cappers and their recent records on the Handicappers Leaderboard to see who’s delivering winning results this week.

Top Winners – Yesterday
Pro Picks – James
$1,251
2. Scott’s Picks
$722
3. Tyler Williams
$500
4. Sports Central
$454
5. Madjack Sports
$382
Top Winners – This Week
Pro Picks – James
$1,220
2. Freudy Hockey
$1,133
3. Al Grant
$978
4. Jacob Hoffman
$882
5. Bobby Conn
$700
Top Winners – This Month
Sas Insider
$2,539
2. Evan Lewis
$1,704
3. Scott’s Picks
$1,345
4. Oskeim Sports
$1,180
5. Bobby Conn
$1,127