Columbus Crew vs Toronto Fc Picks and Predictions September 20th 2025

Columbus Crew Seeking Stability at the Back

The Columbus Crew return home looking to bounce back after a 3-2 midweek defeat to New York City FC. Columbus has gone 1-2-2 in its last five matches and continues to slide defensively, conceding seven goals in its last two outings. Despite scoring five goals in an exciting 5-4 win over Atlanta, defensive lapses have become a recurring issue.

Head coach Wilfried Nancy acknowledged the problem, emphasizing that while his side can score, conceding goals at this rate will hinder postseason ambitions. Sitting seventh in the Eastern Conference with 49 points, the Crew remain just one point back of fourth-place Nashville, leaving plenty at stake down the stretch. For more MLS matchup previews, visit the soccer previews page

Latest Betting Trends

• Columbus Crew have seen the over hit in four of their last five matches, with 19 total goals scored in that span.
• The Crew are 1-2-2 in their last five games overall and have conceded seven goals in their last two outings.
• Toronto FC are unbeaten in their last five matches (0-0-5), with each contest ending in a draw.
• The Reds have scored exactly one goal in four of their last five games.
• The last three head-to-head meetings between Columbus and Toronto have finished in draws, including a 1-1 result on August 16.
• Toronto has not lost a league match since July 26, going seven straight without defeat.

Toronto FC Playing Spoiler Role

Toronto FC has already been eliminated from MLS playoff contention but remains a difficult opponent to beat. The Reds are unbeaten in their last five games (0-0-5) and secured a point last weekend with a 1-1 draw against New England, courtesy of a 75th-minute goal from Theo Corbeanu.

Head coach Robin Fraser has shifted focus to evaluating his roster for 2025, making these final matches an opportunity for younger and fringe players to prove themselves. Despite their struggles this season, Toronto has not lost since July 26 and will aim to frustrate the Crew again after a 1-1 draw between the teams on August 16. Stay updated with the latest MLS team news and stats

Make a Hat-Trick!

With our Premium Handicapping Membership

Get Free Trial

Key Matchup Factors

Columbus must find a way to protect leads and limit defensive breakdowns, especially with playoff seeding on the line. Toronto, playing pressure-free, is dangerous enough to extend its unbeaten streak and spoil the Crew’s push for a higher finish in the East.

This game promises a clash of motivations: Columbus balancing urgency for points and defensive composure, while Toronto tests its depth and development for next season. Bettors can explore deeper insights with the expert soccer betting guide

Latest Betting Insights

For bettors tracking MLS action, the Crew’s recent games have consistently delivered high-scoring results, while Toronto’s draw-heavy form points toward resilience. Columbus needs a win to stay in contention for top-four positioning, while Toronto has proven capable of forcing stalemates. Compare live markets and odds on the soccer scores and odds page

To make the most informed plays, consider expert analysis on the soccer picks page and evaluate performance records on the best handicappers leaderboard . Premium selections are also available on the buy picks page