Pittsburgh Penguins vs Edmonton Oilers Picks and Predictions December 16th 2025

Last Updated on

Match Facts

ItemDetail
MatchupEdmonton Oilers at Pittsburgh Penguins
DateTuesday
VenuePPG Paints Arena (Pittsburgh)
Pittsburgh trendFive-game slide (0-1-4), with repeated blown third-period leads
Edmonton storylineTristan Jarry returns to Pittsburgh immediately after the trade
Recent resultsPenguins: OT losses after leading by four vs. San Jose and by three vs. Utah; Oilers: split their last two (win at Toronto, loss vs. Montreal)

For current market numbers and live matchup navigation, use NHL scores and odds.

Line and Odds

  • Moneyline: Edmonton typically priced as the road favorite given form, top-end scoring, and goaltending stability with Jarry
  • Puck line: Oilers -1.5 is usually the plus-money derivative; Penguins +1.5 is the more common “insurance” angle
  • Total: commonly 6.5 in matchups with Edmonton’s scoring profile and Pittsburgh’s recent game scripts

This is a spot where perception and reality collide. Pittsburgh is generating enough to build multi-goal leads, but they’re leaking goals late and not closing games, which makes them hard to trust as a favorite and risky even as a “safe” underdog. Edmonton’s side is cleaner: elite finishers, a power play that can flip a game fast, and a goaltender with extra motivation. If you’re betting it pregame, focus on the angle that best matches your script rather than trying to cover every market.

For price shopping and alt markets, use NHL picks.

Ice Hockey
2025-12-18 19:10
Open
Edmonton Oilers
2 PICKS
Boston Bruins
Ice Hockey
2025-12-18 20:10
Open
New York Rangers
2 PICKS
St Louis Blues
sas logo

Bet Smarter with Verified Insights

Trusted Records, Winning Consistency

Movement Matchup

The game swings on two pressure points: Pittsburgh’s ability to protect the middle of the ice when the game tightens, and Edmonton’s ability to punish mistakes that turn into odd-man looks. The Penguins have repeatedly reached the third period in winning positions, then lost structure—missed assignments, failed clears, and stretched-out shifts that turn into extended defensive-zone time.

Edmonton is built to capitalize when opponents blink. If the Oilers get power-play looks or force Pittsburgh into loose puck management, they have enough top-end finishing to erase deficits quickly. On the other side, Pittsburgh can still create offense through Sidney Crosby’s line and their veteran puck movers, but they have to simplify late: get pucks deep, shorten shifts, and stop turning “protecting a lead” into “sitting back and absorbing pressure.”

For a quick snapshot of each roster and team profile, use NHL teams.

Breakdown Injury Reports

Pittsburgh Penguins

PlayerStatusNotes
Evgeni MalkinOutUpper-body injury (injured reserve)
Blake LizotteOutUpper-body injury (injured reserve)
Harrison BrunickeOutNot available
Peyton KettlesOutNot available
Caleb JonesOutLower-body injury (injured reserve)
Tanner HoweOutInjured reserve (non-roster designation)

Edmonton Oilers

PlayerStatusNotes
Jack RoslovicOutInjured reserve
Connor ClattenburgOutInjured reserve
Jake WalmanOutInjured reserve (LT)
Kasperi KapanenOutInjured reserve
Noah PhilpOutInjured reserve

Pittsburgh Penguins Recent performance

Pittsburgh’s stretch is as frustrating as it gets: they’ve scored enough to be ahead late and still haven’t been able to finish. Blowing a four-goal third-period lead against San Jose, then blowing a three-goal lead against Utah the very next day, creates a real identity problem—closing shifts, managing the puck, and staying connected through the neutral zone.

There are still positives in the offensive layer. They’re getting goals from different parts of the lineup, and they’ve shown they can dictate play for long segments. The issue is what happens when the game gets stressful. If Pittsburgh doesn’t tighten up its details—exits, clears, and defensive support—they can play 45 good minutes and still lose again.

Edmonton Oilers Recent performance

Edmonton’s path is familiar: the top-end stars drive the game, special teams can swing momentum, and when they get rolling they can put up goals in a hurry. Connor McDavid is producing again on a multi-game point streak, and Leon Draisaitl is sitting one point shy of 1,000 for his career, which is the kind of milestone that tends to add urgency to high-leverage offensive possessions.

The biggest new variable is Jarry in net. He looked sharp in his debut, and the emotional angle is real, but the on-ice angle matters more: if he gives Edmonton stable saves early, the Oilers can play more aggressively through the neutral zone and force Pittsburgh to defend speed.

The cleanest takeaway is volatility. Pittsburgh’s recent games are not staying “normal” late. If the Penguins score first or build a lead, that doesn’t automatically translate to a win right now, which changes how you should think about moneyline risk and live-betting opportunities.

Edmonton is the more stable side in terms of converting opponent mistakes into goals, and Pittsburgh has provided plenty of those mistakes late in games recently. The other key layer is special teams. When Edmonton gets power-play chances, the game can flip in minutes, and Pittsburgh’s recent collapses suggest they’re vulnerable when momentum shifts.

If you want a broader “how this game fits the season” lens, Pittsburgh’s landscape is best framed by Metropolitan Division odds, while Edmonton’s is tied to Pacific Division odds.

sas logo

Follow Top-Ranked Handicappers

Accuracy You Can Track, Wins You Can Count

Best bet and Prediction

Best bet: Oilers moneyline.

This is the best bet because it aligns with the most repeatable edge in the matchup: Edmonton is better equipped to punish late-game mistakes, and Pittsburgh has been consistently making those mistakes in the third period. Even if the Penguins generate enough offense to lead at some point, Edmonton has the top-end finishing and special-teams upside to erase deficits quickly, and Jarry’s presence raises Edmonton’s floor if he provides average-to-good goaltending.

Prediction: Oilers 5, Penguins 3.

Handicapper section

Keep your card script-driven. If you like Edmonton, you’re betting that the Oilers’ scoring pressure and Pittsburgh’s closing issues show up again, so avoid building a portfolio that requires the Penguins to play a clean, low-event third period. If you like Pittsburgh, the best case is a disciplined game where they manage the puck late, stay out of the box, and force Edmonton to beat them five-on-five.

Top Winners – This Week
Pro Picks – James
$1,220
2. Freudy Hockey
$1,133
3. Al Grant
$978
4. Jacob Hoffman
$882
5. Bobby Conn
$700
Top Winners – This Month
Sas Insider
$2,539
2. Evan Lewis
$1,704
3. Scott’s Picks
$1,345
4. Oskeim Sports
$1,180
5. Bobby Conn
$1,127