Milwaukee Brewers vs Cincinnati Reds Picks and Predictions September 27th 2025

Milwaukee Brewers vs Cincinnati Reds Baseball Sat, Sep 27, 18:10 pm.
Milwaukee Brewers
ML: -154
0
0
Cincinnati Reds
ML: 125
Last Updated on

Cincinnati Reds vs Milwaukee Brewers Betting Preview

The Cincinnati Reds continue their playoff push Saturday night against the Milwaukee Brewers at American Family Field. Cincinnati (82-78) pulled even with the Mets for the final NL wild-card spot with Friday’s 3-1 win, owning the tiebreaker thanks to a season series victory. Milwaukee (96-64) already has the NL Central crown but is still battling for the No. 1 seed.

sas logo

Elite Betting Intelligence for Less

You deserve sharper picks

Friday’s win featured clutch doubles from Gavin Lux and eight combined scoreless innings from Reds relievers Connor Phillips and Zack Littell. Manager Terry Francona credited his group’s grit, saying, “We beat a really good team. And now, when the song’s over, we’ll see if we can beat them again tomorrow.”

Milwaukee has dominated this matchup historically, winning 13 straight series against Cincinnati before this week. But the Brewers’ offense has gone quiet, scoring fewer than four runs in six of their last seven games. Manager Pat Murphy admitted, “It certainly hasn’t been a juggernaut… we haven’t played our typical ball-strike, grind-it-out game.”

Line Movement and Odds

  • Moneyline: Reds +127 | Brewers -151
  • Runline: Reds +1.5 (-174) | Brewers -1.5 (+145)
  • Total (O/U 7.5 runs): Over -114 | Under -107

The market opened Brewers -145, ticking up slightly with public money. Sharper plays have leaned to the Reds +1.5 runline and the Under, anticipating a tighter pitcher’s duel than expected.

MLB
2025-10-15 17:08
Open
TORONTO BLUE JAYS
1 PICKS
SEATTLE MARINERS
Want more MLB picks for every game? See today’s baseball previews →

Matchup Breakdown

Reds Outlook

The Reds are heating up at the right time, winning seven of their last 10. Andrew Abbott (9-7, 2.80 ERA) takes the ball Saturday. While his overall numbers are sharp, he’s hit turbulence late, posting a 4.03 ERA across his last seven starts. Against Milwaukee, Abbott has a 2-4 record with a 3.57 ERA lifetime.

Offensively, Elly De La Cruz leads with 21 HR and 85 RBI, while TJ Friedl and Noelvi Marte provide steady contact hitting. With Lux swinging a hot bat and Abbott keeping the Brewers off balance, Cincinnati has a clear path to another statement win.

Brewers Outlook

Milwaukee remains focused on postseason positioning. Robert Gasser (0-1, 6.00 ERA) makes his second start since returning from Tommy John surgery. He showed flashes in the minors (2.25 ERA at Triple-A Nashville) but allowed two runs in just three innings in his season debut last Sunday.

At the plate, Christian Yelich leads with 29 HR, while Brice Turang’s .287 average and table-setting ability are critical. But with Milwaukee’s recent struggles plating runs, the pressure falls on Gasser to keep them in it.

Key Battle

Abbott’s command vs. Milwaukee’s patient bats. The Brewers thrive when working counts, ranking among the league’s best in OBP. If Abbott avoids long innings, the Reds’ bullpen has proven capable of slamming the door.

Injuries and Conditions

Cincinnati RedsMilwaukee Brewers
• No major injuries reported• OF Garrett Mitchell (shoulder) out
• SP Nick Lodolo (arm fatigue) out• RP Devin Williams (back) day-to-day
• RP Ian Gibaut (elbow) out• SP Wade Miley (elbow) IL

Weather: Roof expected closed in Milwaukee, eliminating weather impact.

Best Bets and Prediction

This is a must-win spot for the Reds, and Abbott’s steady presence gives them an edge. Milwaukee’s offense has been inconsistent, and Gasser is still working back into form. Expect Cincinnati to scrap out another close victory while keeping the wild-card race alive.

  • Pick: Reds ML +127
  • Projected Score: Reds 4, Brewers 3
  • Reasoning: Abbott outduels Gasser, bullpen carries Reds late.
  • Lean: Under 7.5 (-107)
CategoryDetail
Best BetReds ML +127
Confidence★★★☆☆
Projected ScoreReds 4, Brewers 3
Total LeanUnder 7.5 (-107)
Market Split58% tickets Brewers, 52% money Reds

Handicappers and Picks

Playoff urgency is often the hidden edge this late in the MLB season. The Brewers have seeding motivation, but the Reds are in survival mode, making this a prime betting angle. Our Leaderboard highlights which cappers are cashing in high-leverage spots like this one.

Premium recommendations are available in Service Plays, where experts release sides, totals, and player props with documented ROI. Free insights are always posted in our MLB Picks section, from runline leans to strikeout props.

For strategy refinement, the Bettors Handbook explains how to approach late-season variance, including bullpen fatigue, playoff motivation, and public bias. These small angles separate sharp bettors from the field.

Make smarter MLB bets. Back your card with SAS data.