Milwaukee Brewers vs Chicago Cubs Picks and Predictions October 11th 2025

Last Updated on

Chicago Cubs vs Milwaukee Brewers NLDS Game 5 Betting Preview

The Milwaukee Brewers will lean on their home-field advantage at American Family Field as they host the Chicago Cubs in a decisive Game 5 of the National League Division Series on Saturday night. The winner advances to face the Dodgers in the NLCS, while the loser’s season ends.

sas logo

The Sharpest Picks in the Game

Cancel anytime. No risk.

Milwaukee looked in control after taking a 2–0 series lead, but the Cubs roared back with two wins at Wrigley Field, including a 6–0 shutout Thursday. Ian Happ’s three-run homer set the tone in Game 4, and Chicago’s bullpen dominated for the second straight night. The Brewers, who went 97–65 in the regular season, must rediscover the offensive rhythm that fueled their early success — 16 runs in Games 1 and 2 versus just three in Games 3 and 4.

Neither team has announced an official starter, though Milwaukee could opt for a bullpen game anchored by electric rookie Jacob Misiorowski, while Chicago might bring back Shota Imanaga on short rest. The Brewers opened as -136 favorites, with the Cubs at +116 and the total set at 7.5 runs.

Want sharp MLB postseason picks from verified experts? See who’s leading the handicappers leaderboard →

Line Movement and Odds

Milwaukee opened -130 and has drawn slight support from early bettors, pushing the line to -136. Around 58% of public bets are on the Brewers, while sharp money has leaned toward the Under 7.5 (-115) given both bullpens’ recent effectiveness. The total has stayed firm despite Game 4’s low-scoring trend, suggesting oddsmakers expect tighter pitching once again.

The Cubs have been lethal in the first inning this series, scoring 11 runs in that frame across four games. Meanwhile, Milwaukee has gone 2-for-13 with runners in scoring position during its two losses — a stat manager Pat Murphy acknowledged Friday, emphasizing “execution and composure” as keys to regaining control.

“I’ve learned a lot about this team, and one thing is it’s resilient,” Murphy said. “They bounce back.”

MLB
2025-10-12 17:03
Open
SEATTLE MARINERS
17 PICKS
TORONTO BLUE JAYS

Matchup Breakdown

Chicago Cubs Outlook:
The Cubs’ power surge has flipped the series momentum. Michael Busch has three homers, Ian Happ two, and Kyle Tucker continues to deliver timely hits. Chicago ranks top-10 in the majors in home runs (223) and slugging (.430), and their lineup depth has been the difference. Manager Craig Counsell’s aggressive bullpen management — using 11 pitchers across the last two games — has paid off, keeping Milwaukee’s lineup off balance. The question is whether that group can hold up for one more elimination game.

“We’ve got 11 pitchers to figure out how to get 27 outs,” Counsell said. “That’s how we’re treating it.”

Milwaukee Brewers Outlook:
The Brewers’ offense has gone cold, but their regular-season profile suggests a rebound. Milwaukee ranked second in batting average (.258) and on-base percentage (.341), fueled by Christian Yelich and William Contreras. Rookie sensation Misiorowski is expected to play a key role after tossing three shutout innings in Game 2, hitting 104.3 mph on the radar gun. The Brewers’ bullpen remains among the best in baseball (2.89 postseason ERA), and the home crowd should add energy to a team that thrives under pressure.

Injuries and Conditions

Chicago CubsMilwaukee Brewers
Shota Imanaga – Probable (Short Rest)Brandon Woodruff – Out (Shoulder)
Seiya Suzuki – Probable (Rest)Devin Williams – Probable (Shoulder)
Terrence Gore – Out (Ankle)Brice Turang – Slump (.125 in series)
Garrett Mitchell – Probable (Knee)
Cubs Team PageBrewers Team Page

Weather: Indoor venue (roof closed). No weather concerns.

Top Winners – Today
Computer Picks
$810
2. Sean Alvarez
$400
3. Jacob Hoffman
$340
4. Knup Sports – POTD
$310
5. Evan Lewis
$300
Top Winners – Yesterday
Computer Picks
$810
2. Sean Alvarez
$400
3. Jacob Hoffman
$340
4. Knup Sports – POTD
$310
5. Teddy Covers
$300
Top Winners – This Week
Computer Picks
$1,150
2. Sports Central
$605
3. Seth Cohen
$600
4. Robert Ferguson
$500
5. Ross Walker
$433
Top Winners – This Month
Rubi Chavez
$2,047
2. Ryan Davis
$1,400
3. Sean Alvarez
$1,358
4. Jimmy Boyd
$1,010
5. Coach Rick
$980

Best Bets and Prediction

Both bullpens will likely be heavily involved, creating volatility in live betting markets. Milwaukee’s home dominance (52–29 at American Family Field this season) and elite pitching depth give them a narrow edge. The Cubs’ hot bats make them dangerous early, but expect the Brewers’ pitching depth and crowd energy to tilt this one late.

Pick: Brewers ML (-136)
Projected Final Score: Brewers 4, Cubs 3
Best Bet: Brewers ML (-136)
Lean: Under 7.5 (-115)

For more Baseball Betting Advice, MLB Score Predictions, and Daily Picks, visit the ScoresAndStats MLB Previews.

October Baseball Means Opportunity

The postseason stage is set — maximize every pitch with data-driven betting insights. Explore the expert betting guide here →


CategoryDetail
Best BetBrewers ML (-136)
Confidence Rating★★★★☆
Projected ScoreBrewers 4, Cubs 3
Total LeanUnder 7.5 (-115)
Market Split58% bets Brewers, 61% sharp money Under

ScoresAndStats Handicappers and Picks

The ScoresAndStats Handicappers Leaderboard is the ultimate postseason betting resource — tracking verified expert records, ROI, and hot streaks across every sport, including MLB playoffs. With every pick timestamped and performance-verified, bettors can identify which analysts are thriving in October’s pressure-packed environment.

Smart baseball bettors use this data to understand market inefficiencies — such as fading inflated public favorites or targeting bullpen mismatches in elimination games like Brewers–Cubs. The Service Plays section offers premium picks and player prop breakdowns from top-performing cappers, many specializing in MLB postseason betting strategy.

Whether you’re hunting totals value, live-bet opportunities, or NLCS futures, ScoresAndStats gives you the analytical edge to profit when the stakes are highest.
Every pitch matters — follow the experts who win when it counts most.