Pittsburgh Penguins vs New York Islanders Picks and Predictions – February 3rd 2026

The Pittsburgh Penguins (24-21-6) head to UBS Arena Tuesday night to face the New York Islanders (25-20-9) in a Metropolitan showdown with postseason implications. Puck drop is set for 7:30 p.m. ET, and with both teams sitting in the Wild Card mix, every point matters. This won’t just be a midseason scrap — it could shape the playoff cut line come April.

The Penguins are coming off a gutsy win over Montreal, snapping a three-game skid, while the Islanders return home after an OT loss in Tampa. New York has been far better at home lately, while Pittsburgh has shown cracks on the road. The Isles are -1.5 puck line favorites at +196, with Pittsburgh getting +1.5 at -249. It’s a classic toss-up spot where matchup details — and goalie confirmation — will guide value.

Pittsburgh Penguins vs New York Islanders Odds

Here’s the current puck line for Tuesday night’s matchup. Always double-check the latest NHL odds for updated prices as goalie news or lineup changes hit the market.

Team	Puck Line
Pittsburgh Penguins	+1.5 (-249)
New York Islanders	-1.5 (+196)

Pittsburgh Penguins Betting Form

Pittsburgh remains one of the league’s more frustrating teams — capable of looking elite one night, then totally disjointed the next. Sidney Crosby is still the motor, leading the team in goals and driving possession. Jake Guentzel and Bryan Rust have chipped in, but depth scoring has dried up. Evgeni Malkin’s line hasn’t produced consistently, and without it, the Penguins struggle to control games at 5-on-5.

The power play has underperformed all year. They sit outside the top 20 in conversion rate, despite elite names on the top unit. Penalty killing is a strength, but they’ve also taken more penalties than they should — putting pressure on what’s already a taxed core.

Goaltending is a swing spot. Tristan Jarry has posted a .916 SV% over his last five starts, but he’s also been pulled multiple times this season when things spiral. The Penguins are 4–6 in their last 10 and have covered the puck line in just three of those games. They’ve also allowed 3+ goals in five of their last six.

For more form details, dig into the full Pittsburgh Penguins stats and results. Monitor the Pittsburgh Penguins injury report closely for updates to their second and third lines, which have rotated heavily.

New York Islanders Betting Form

The Islanders are the ultimate grind team — they don’t blow many opponents out, but they make you earn everything. At home, they’ve been solid: 6–2–2 in their last 10 at UBS Arena and playing with better structure in front of Ilya Sorokin. Mathew Barzal and Brock Nelson lead a balanced top six, and Bo Horvat is starting to heat up after a quiet stretch.

Defensively, the Isles are tough to break down. They limit high-danger chances better than most, and Sorokin gives them a legit goaltending edge. He’s posted a .923 SV% over his last six starts and has been lights-out against the Penguins historically. The penalty kill has rebounded after a shaky start to the year, and the Islanders remain one of the better home Under teams in the league.

The puck line isn’t often their friend — they’ve won a lot of close games — but when they do win by margin, it’s usually when their forecheck smothers weaker transition teams. Pittsburgh fits that profile when their breakout game stalls, and New York has been taking advantage of those kinds of matchups lately.

Check the New York Islanders schedule and stats for more trends. Injury-wise, keep tabs on the New York Islanders injury report — especially second-pair defensemen and checking line pieces.

Pittsburgh Penguins vs New York Islanders Matchup Breakdown

This is going to be a tempo battle. Pittsburgh wants pace, stretch passes, and rush scoring. The Islanders want to kill the game with neutral zone layers and extended offensive zone shifts. If New York wins the forecheck battle, they’ll control shot volume and tilt the ice.

The Penguins have struggled in physical games this season — especially on the road. They’re just 9-14-3 away from PPG Paints Arena and give up 3.4 goals per game as visitors. The Islanders, by contrast, are 15-7-4 at home and allow just 2.6 goals per game at UBS.

The special teams matchup slightly favors New York. Neither power play is elite, but the Isles are more disciplined. If Pittsburgh takes four or more penalties — which they’ve done in five of their last six — they could get punished.

Goaltending edge clearly goes to Sorokin. If Jarry is off his game early, things could unravel quickly. If he plays sharp, this likely turns into a 3–2 type of game.

Matchup angles:

• Home/road splits strongly favor Islanders
• Goaltending edge: Sorokin > Jarry
• Pittsburgh 4–6 last 10; NYI 6–3–1 in that span
• Islanders 6–1 in last 7 home games vs PIT

This type of game profile — slower pace, goaltending edge, and home efficiency — often delivers puck line value if the dog collapses late. And the Penguins have done that in multiple third periods lately.

Pittsburgh Penguins vs New York Islanders Predictions and Best Bets

The moneyline is likely steep for New York, but the puck line (+196) offers a compelling reward. The question is whether you trust the Islanders to finish the job. They rarely run away with games, but Pittsburgh’s road form and late-game breakdowns suggest this is a spot where it could happen.

If Sorokin starts (as expected), the Isles should control the crease battle. Combine that with their neutral zone play and better structure, and they become the sharper side — especially if you’re willing to take the risk on -1.5.

Totals lean Under, but we’ll wait for a number. If it’s 5.5 with standard juice, it’s a pass. If it’s 6, Under has value — especially if Jarry is confirmed.

First period also leans Isles. They’ve led after one in five of their last six at home, while the Penguins have started slowly on the road. That angle could be a sharp derivative look if the full-game line feels tight.

Still, we’ll ride the recent form, home edge, and goaltending here.

Best Bet: New York Islanders -1.5 (+196).

NHL Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats

For more NHL betting analysis, visit our free NHL picks page — updated daily with fresh insights from across the league. From totals and sides to player props, our team breaks it all down.

Want to know who’s producing long-term profit? The top sports handicappers on ScoresAndStats are ranked in our handicapper leaderboard — full transparency, no filters.

When you’re ready to get serious, go premium. Our premium NHL picks include exclusive plays from trusted experts — with all records fully tracked, so you know exactly what you’re buying.