Colorado Avalanche vs Pittsburgh Penguins Picks and Predictions March 16th 2026

Last Updated on

The Colorado Avalanche are locked in a high-stakes race for the top seed in the Central Division, holding a narrow lead that makes every point crucial as they prepare to host the Pittsburgh Penguins on Monday night at Ball Arena. Puck drop is scheduled for 9:30 PM ET on ESPN. While Colorado has dominated the standings for most of the season, a recent surge from the Dallas Stars has tightened the gap, meaning the Avalanche cannot afford a lapse against a desperate Pittsburgh squad. The Penguins, currently second in the Metropolitan Division, are fighting to keep their postseason position secure as they navigate a thin one-point cushion over the second wild card spot in the Eastern Conference.

Discover the Sharpest NHL Picks on the Market

Bet with confidence, backed by data

Pittsburgh Penguins vs Colorado Avalanche Odds

These are the current betting lines for tonight’s matchup, though you should always monitor the latest NHL odds before locking in your wagers to ensure you are getting the best value.

TeamMoneylinePuck LineTotal
Pittsburgh Penguins+194+1.5 (-129)O 6.5 (-118)
Colorado Avalanche-230-1.5 (+106)U 6.5 (-104)

Pittsburgh Penguins Betting Form

The Penguins arrive in Denver coming off a gritty comeback win against Utah, proving that this group remains resilient despite a laundry list of high-profile absences. Playing without captain Sidney Crosby—who has been sidelined since the Olympics—has forced the team to adopt a collective approach to scoring. While their depth has kept them afloat, the lack of top-tier offensive production is a concern when facing a juggernaut like Colorado. They will need another sharp performance from goaltender Stuart Skinner, who has been a steady presence in the crease throughout the year.

Betting on Pittsburgh requires weighing their underdog status against their ability to stay competitive in tight games. Their puck line record as underdogs has been impressive, which often makes them an attractive play for those looking for value in high-spread scenarios. However, bettors must be diligent regarding their health, as the Pittsburgh Penguins injury report remains a major factor in their nightly volatility. With key pieces like Evgeni Malkin and Justin Brazeau out, the rotation is thin, and it remains to be seen if they can maintain their recent momentum against one of the league’s most potent offenses. You can keep up with their performance throughout the season by checking out their Pittsburgh Penguins stats and results.

Ice Hockey
2026-03-16 19:00
Open
Boston Bruins
4 PICKS
New Jersey Devils
Ice Hockey
2026-03-16 19:00
Open
Calgary Flames
3 PICKS
Detroit Red Wings
Ice Hockey
2026-03-16 19:00
Open
Los Angeles Kings
3 PICKS
New York Rangers
Ice Hockey
2026-03-16 20:00
Open
Utah Mammoth
2 PICKS
Dallas Stars
Ice Hockey
2026-03-16 21:30
Open
Pittsburgh Penguins
1 PICKS
Colorado Avalanche

Colorado Avalanche Betting Form

Colorado returns home looking to shake off a 3-1 loss to the Winnipeg Jets. The Avalanche remain a force, ranking first in the league in goals, assists, and total shots, driven by an elite core headlined by Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar. Even with Gabriel Landeskog and Artturi Lehkonen out of the lineup, the team’s offensive depth has remained largely intact. MacKinnon continues to put up MVP-caliber numbers, and the team’s ability to dominate puck possession at 5-on-5 is why they consistently sit at the top of the Western Conference.

The Avalanche are comfortable playing a high-paced game, but their recent trend of hitting the under suggests they are capable of tightening up defensively when the situation demands it. For those tracking their progress, you can review the Colorado Avalanche schedule and stats to see how they have performed in similar high-pressure spots. While the team is eager to integrate Nazem Kadri back into his natural center position once their Colorado Avalanche injury report clears up, their current configuration has been more than enough to handle most opponents.

Pittsburgh Penguins vs Colorado Avalanche Matchup Breakdown

This game presents a classic contrast between a high-octane Colorado offense and a Pittsburgh team relying on grit and goaltending to survive. The primary edge for the Avalanche lies in their top-end talent; MacKinnon and Makar can dictate the pace of the game in a way that very few teams in the league can handle. Pittsburgh’s ability to hang around will depend heavily on Skinner’s performance and their ability to limit high-danger scoring chances at 5-on-5.

Special teams will also be a major narrative. Colorado’s power play has been lethal, and if Pittsburgh spends too much time in the box, it could be a long night for the visitors. For those looking to dive deeper into how these metrics translate to the betting window, exploring an NHL expert betting guide can provide context on how these specific roster configurations typically match up in the final stretch of the season.

Pittsburgh Penguins vs Colorado Avalanche Predictions and Best Bets

Colorado is the clear class of this matchup. While Pittsburgh’s resilience is admirable, the disparity in raw talent and current offensive output is too wide to ignore, especially at home. The Avalanche are well-positioned to bounce back from their loss to Winnipeg and control the tempo against a fatigued Penguins team that is missing its biggest stars. Betting the moneyline on Colorado feels like the right move, though the price is steep, so looking for value elsewhere might be necessary for some portfolios.

Regarding the total, I am leaning toward the under 6.5. Despite Colorado’s scoring prowess, their last five games have stayed under this mark, and Pittsburgh’s offensive ceiling is severely capped without Crosby. Expect a controlled game where the Avalanche play a disciplined, responsible style of hockey to avoid unnecessary risks. The pace should be fast, but quality goaltending and defensive structure should keep this one from turning into a total blowout.

Best Bet: Colorado Avalanche moneyline (-230).

UP TO $250 BONUS BET

The Best Live In-Game Betting

21+ Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

NHL Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats

Finding consistent success in the NHL requires more than just picking winners; it requires a deep dive into the numbers and a disciplined approach to bankroll management. At ScoresAndStats, our top sports handicappers provide a consistent volume of analysis to help you navigate the chaos of the long season. By following our handicapper leaderboard, you can identify which experts are hot and align your betting strategy with proven, long-term profitable records.

Whether you are looking for today’s NHL picks to sharpen your daily card or you want to buy expert picks for deep-dive analysis on the biggest matchups, our platform offers full transparency. Betting on the NHL is about identifying value in the noise, and our community of experts is dedicated to helping you make informed decisions every night of the week.

Top Winners – Yesterday
Sas Insider
$760
2. William Taylor
$445
3. Keylor Santos
$395
4. Sean Kuchman
$320
5. Sports Investors
$299
Top Winners – This Week
Sas Insider
$1,810
2. Randall Dickelman
$1,083
3. Tyler Williams
$750
4. Sean Kuchman
$629
5. Totals Guru
$400