NFL Previews 
MLB Previews 
NBA Previews 
NHL Previews 
Soccer Previews 
Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Picks and Predictions – March 22, 2026
The Columbus Blue Jackets head to UBS Arena on Sunday night for a Metropolitan Division matchup that matters in the standings. Columbus comes in at 37-21-11, while New York enters at 39-26-5, so this is not just a routine late-season game between division rivals. The market sees it as tight, with only a small edge toward Columbus.
Unlock Predictive Models for NHL Betting
Proven value, low risk
Columbus brings the hotter form into this game. The Blue Jackets have stacked wins, and the recent 5-2 result over Seattle fits the bigger picture of a team that is generating offense in waves and getting enough goaltending behind it. New York is a little tougher to price after a rough defensive showing last time out, but the Islanders still have the profile of a home team that can drag opponents into a lower-event, tighter-checking game.
From a betting standpoint, this looks like a matchup where current form points one way, while venue and defensive style point the other. That usually creates value on whichever side can better impose its preferred pace, and right now Columbus looks more likely to do that.
Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Odds
The current market is close to a pick’em, and bettors should keep watching the latest NHL odds before puck drop in case this price shifts.
| Team | Moneyline | Puck Line | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Columbus Blue Jackets | -113 | -1.5 | 6.0 |
| New York Islanders | -104 | +1.5 | 6.0 |
Columbus Blue Jackets Betting Form
Columbus is playing some of its best hockey of the season. A four-game winning streak, plus the way the Blue Jackets handled Seattle, suggests a team that is not just sneaking by but creating real separation in games. This offense has been productive for most of the year, and the shot volume stands out for bettors because it gives Columbus a stable path to offense instead of relying on unsustainably high finishing. You can dig deeper into the Columbus Blue Jackets stats and results before betting this side.
The strongest angle with Columbus is that the form matches the record. Teams can get overrated on short winning streaks, but the Blue Jackets already had a strong season profile before this run. They have enough scoring depth to keep pressure on a defense for long stretches, and they have been a profitable favorite because they are not wasting these types of spots.
Health is not crushing them right now, which matters this late in the season. The lineup is in much better shape than New York’s, and that helps when you are betting a short road price in a divisional game. Still, it is worth checking the Columbus Blue Jackets injury report before locking in the moneyline.
New York Islanders Betting Form
New York’s overall record says this team deserves respect, especially at home, but the recent 7-3 loss to Montreal is the kind of result that gets bettors’ attention for the wrong reasons. The Islanders still have a very good defensive record over the season, and that matters more than one ugly game, but it does raise the question of whether they are as steady right now as the record suggests. The full New York Islanders schedule and stats show the profile of a team that has won a lot of close games and usually leans on structure more than pace.
This team still has enough offense to answer if Columbus pushes the tempo. Mathew Barzal and Bo Horvat give New York real top-end playmaking, and UBS Arena has been a useful edge in games where the Islanders can slow the opponent down and control matchups. That is the path here. They do not want this game turning into a back-and-forth shot trade.
The injury list is the bigger concern. Missing multiple regulars, including depth pieces and a goaltender, matters in a tight market. That does not automatically make New York a fade, but it does make the margin smaller. Bettors should keep tabs on the New York Islanders injury report before making a final decision.
Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Matchup Breakdown
This matchup starts at 5-on-5, where Columbus has looked sharper lately. The Blue Jackets are generating more volume, they are finishing chances with confidence, and they are not waiting around for the perfect game state. Against an Islanders team that usually prefers more control and fewer mistakes, that aggressive approach matters. If Columbus establishes offensive-zone time early, New York could spend too much of the night defending.
The Islanders still have a clear path, though. Their best version of this game is slower, heavier, and lower event. They want to lean on home ice, shorten the rush game, and force Columbus to grind through layers instead of skating into clean looks. If New York can do that, the under comes more into play and the game becomes a coin flip.
Special teams could tilt things, but the bigger angle for me is game flow. Columbus is carrying stronger momentum, and that usually matters in short-price matchups where neither team has a huge talent edge. New York has been better than the public sometimes gives it credit for, but this is not a great spot to back a team coming off a defensive collapse against a club riding this kind of rhythm.
UBS Arena is an indoor rink, so weather will not directly affect the side, total, or anything tied to ice conditions beyond the normal home-ice familiarity. Travel is modest here, but the real environmental edge is New York having last change. Even so, Columbus looks like the team more likely to dictate the pace.
Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Predictions and Best Bets
I lean to Columbus here. The Blue Jackets are in better current form, they have been more trustworthy as favorites, and they are bringing the stronger recent offensive profile into a game with a very short number. New York is good enough to win this outright, especially at home, but the current market is asking me to trust the Islanders at exactly the wrong time.
The side is clearer than the total. Both teams have under-friendly season profiles in the over/under market, and that fits what New York wants this game to look like. But Columbus has enough shot volume to threaten that script, and if the Blue Jackets score first, the pace probably opens up more than the Islanders want. That makes the under playable, just not as strong as the side.
I do not love laying a puck line in a divisional game this tight, so the cleanest angle is the Columbus moneyline. The Blue Jackets have the better momentum, the healthier overall setup, and the more reliable offensive floor right now. In a near pick’em, that is enough for me.
Best Bet: Columbus Blue Jackets moneyline (-113)
NHL Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats
If you want more angles before betting this matchup, the NHL picks page is a good place to compare sides and totals across the board. It also helps to browse the NHL previews hub if you are building out a bigger Sunday card.
For broader betting strategy, the NHL betting guide is useful for understanding when to attack moneylines, puck lines, and totals, while the Stanley Cup betting guide can help futures bettors think a step ahead.
If you prefer to follow proven performance, check the best handicappers and the current leaderboard. And if you want premium plays instead of just free leans, the buy picks section is worth a look before finalizing your card.
