NFL Previews 
MLB Previews 
NBA Previews 
NHL Previews 
Soccer Previews 
The Cincinnati Reds visit the New York Mets on Monday afternoon at Citi Field, with first pitch set for 4:10 PM ET. Cincinnati comes in at 27-25 and fourth in the NL Central, and while the Reds have been a little uneven, they did win their last completed game and have started to show more offensive life after a rough stretch earlier in May.
New York enters at 22-31 and fifth in the NL East. The Mets have lost three straight, were just swept by Miami, and now return home trying to stop another ugly slide before it gets worse. Their offense has gone cold again, and Juan Soto’s illness adds another layer of uncertainty to a lineup that already has several key injuries.
Nick Lodolo starts for Cincinnati, while Nolan McLean gets the ball for New York. The Mets are favored at home, but this game sits in a tricky spot on the broader MLB previews board because New York has the better starting-pitcher form while Cincinnati has the healthier power profile and more recent run-scoring upside.
Every Play Tracked. Every Line Verified.
Follow proven cappers and watch market shifts unfold live.
Cincinnati Reds vs New York Mets Odds
These are the current betting lines for Cincinnati vs New York, and bettors should always monitor the latest MLB odds before locking in a number.
| Team | Moneyline | Run Line | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cincinnati Reds | +135 | +1.5 (-165) | O 7.5 (-109) |
| New York Mets | -162 | -1.5 (+135) | U 7.5 (-111) |
Cincinnati Reds Betting Form
Cincinnati is not in perfect form, but the Reds do look a little more dangerous than they did earlier this month. They split Saturday’s doubleheader with St. Louis, losing 8-1 in the opener before winning 7-6 in 11 innings. That second game mattered because the offense had been stuck too often, and scoring seven runs in a tight game can help a lineup breathe a bit.
The Reds have legitimate power. Elly De La Cruz and Sal Stewart both bring home run upside, and Nathaniel Lowe added another long ball in the recent loss to St. Louis. Cincinnati ranks near the top of the league in homers and slugging, so even when the batting average is not special, this lineup can change the game with one swing. That is the part that makes the Reds a live underdog here.
Lodolo is the uncomfortable part of the handicap. His 7.20 ERA, 1.53 WHIP, and nine walks in 15 innings make it hard to trust him as the foundation for a road win. But he was better in his last start than the season number suggests, allowing three runs over 5 2/3 innings against Philadelphia. He has also handled the Mets well in limited career work. If his command is even average, Cincinnati can keep this close and put pressure on a struggling Mets offense.
New York Mets Betting Form
The Mets are back in a familiar bad stretch. They were swept by the Marlins, shut out Sunday, and have scored two runs or fewer far too often this season. It is one thing to lose games. It is another when the at-bats start feeling empty, and that is where New York is right now.
Soto’s status is the big swing factor. He has been the best bat in the lineup, and if he is out or limited again, the Mets lose a lot of middle-order stability. Francisco Lindor, Luis Robert Jr., Francisco Alvarez, Jorge Polanco, and others are already unavailable, so the lineup can get thin quickly. Bo Bichette has shown some power, and A.J. Ewing has given them a few competitive at-bats, but this is not a group I want to trust blindly at a favorite price.
McLean gives New York the stronger starting-pitcher case. His 3.57 ERA, 1.03 WHIP, and 69 strikeouts are solid, even after his rough outing against Washington. That start got away from him, and there were defensive mistakes involved, but he still has the swing-and-miss profile to handle a Reds lineup that can chase. If McLean limits the long ball, the Mets should have the pitching edge through the first five innings.
Cincinnati Reds vs New York Mets Matchup Breakdown
The starting pitcher edge belongs to New York. McLean has been better than Lodolo overall, and his strikeout rate gives him a real path to quiet Cincinnati’s power. That matters because the Reds are not a team you want to let extend innings. If they get free baserunners ahead of De La Cruz, Stewart, or Lowe, the game can flip fast.
The offensive edge is more complicated. New York has Soto, if healthy, and enough names that the market will still respect the lineup. But the actual production has not been good lately. Cincinnati has been inconsistent too, but the Reds have more recent signs of life and a stronger power profile. That makes laying -160 or more with the Mets feel a little uncomfortable.
Weather could matter slightly with light rain and a mild breeze in New York, but Citi Field still leans more neutral than hitter-friendly. The bigger total factor is command. Lodolo’s walks and home run risk point toward scoring chances, while McLean’s strikeouts and the Mets’ offensive slump pull the game back toward a lower total.
From an MLB betting guide perspective, this is the kind of matchup where first 5 innings and team totals may be cleaner than the full-game side. If you trust McLean, the Mets first 5 has some appeal. If you trust Cincinnati’s power to eventually break through, the Reds full-game run line becomes a reasonable angle.
Cincinnati Reds vs New York Mets Predictions and Best Bets
I lean Mets to win, but I do not love the moneyline price. McLean is the better current starter, and the Mets are back home after an ugly road sweep. That should matter. Still, asking this lineup to justify -162 when Soto is dealing with illness and the offense has gone quiet is not exactly comfortable.
Cincinnati +1.5 is the safer underdog look. The Reds have been strong on the run line away from home, and their power gives them backdoor cover ability even if McLean controls the early innings. I would rather take the run and a half than chase the Reds moneyline outright, mostly because Lodolo’s control issues create too much early risk.
The total is close, but I lean Under 7.5. McLean’s strikeout ability should play against Cincinnati, and the Mets’ offense is too cold to assume a big breakout. Lodolo is volatile, so this is not a perfect Under spot, but his history against New York and the Mets’ current lineup issues keep me away from the Over.
For bettors comparing this game with the full daily MLB picks board, the best angle is not forcing the Mets moneyline. The Under has a cleaner path if McLean rebounds and New York’s bats stay stuck in neutral.
Best Bet: Under 7.5 (-111).
The Home of Verified Handicappers
3,000+ monthly plays tracked live across all sports.
MLB Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats
MLB betting gets tricky when the favorite has the better starter but the worse recent offensive form. Reds vs Mets is a good example. New York has the pitching edge with McLean, but Cincinnati has enough power to make a short favorite sweat if the Mets keep wasting scoring chances.
The handicapper leaderboard helps bettors compare long-term results instead of reacting to one strong pick or one bad beat. That matters during the MLB season because volume is high, and a good handicapper has to win across sides, totals, run lines, team totals, and first 5 innings markets.
Bettors can also follow top sports handicappers to compare different styles before first pitch. Some experts are better with totals, some attack underdogs, and some specialize in starting-pitcher value. On a game like this, that difference matters.
