NFL Previews 
MLB Previews 
NBA Previews 
NHL Previews 
Soccer Previews 
The St. Louis Cardinals open a four-game road series against the Pittsburgh Pirates on Monday night at PNC Park, with first pitch set for 6:40 PM ET. St. Louis enters at 14-13 and fifth in the NL Central, which says more about how competitive the division has been than anything else. Every team in the division is above .500, so a four-game losing streak can move a club quickly in the wrong direction.
Pittsburgh is 16-12 and third in the NL Central. The Pirates were shut out 5-0 by Milwaukee on Sunday, but they still return home after a 3-3 road trip against Texas and Milwaukee. That is not bad, especially with this being a divisional series at PNC Park, where Pittsburgh took five of six from St. Louis last season.
The Cardinals turn to Dustin May, who has quietly started to settle down after a rough opening month. Pittsburgh will use Mason Montgomery to start what looks like a bullpen game. The Pirates are favored at home, and the total sits at 8.0 in a matchup where pitching depth and run prevention matter more than the records alone.
Go Inside the Handicappers’ Playbook
All in one spot. Real-time line moves, sharp reads, and verified edges.
St. Louis Cardinals vs Pittsburgh Pirates Odds
These are the current betting lines for Monday’s matchup, and bettors should always monitor the latest MLB odds before locking in a position.
| Team | Moneyline | Run Line | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| St. Louis Cardinals | +111 | N/A | O 8.0 |
| Pittsburgh Pirates | -131 | N/A | U 8.0 (-107) |
St. Louis Cardinals Betting Form
The Cardinals are not playing badly enough to panic, but they are losing the close ones right now. They were swept at home by Seattle, dropping three games by a combined four runs, and Sunday’s 3-2 loss was another one that slipped away late. That can be frustrating for bettors because the underlying performance has not been terrible, but the results are still not there.
There are some positives in the lineup. Nathan Church has been one of the better recent stories, hitting .406 over his last nine games while recording at least one hit in eight of them. JJ Wetherholt also went deep Sunday, and St. Louis ranks sixth in MLB with 34 home runs. The Cardinals are not a high-average offense, but they have enough power and a .322 on-base percentage to make this more dangerous than their losing streak suggests. For broader board context, the MLB previews and matchups page can help compare this spot with the rest of Monday’s slate.
May is the real swing factor. His season ERA is still ugly at 5.84, but that number is a bit misleading because he has allowed just one earned run in each of his last three starts and won all three. That is a massive turnaround from where he started. The concern is matchup history, since Pittsburgh tagged him for seven runs, six earned, in 5 1/3 innings last August. If this newer version of May shows up, St. Louis is a live underdog. If the command backs up, the Pirates can get into the Cardinals’ weaker pitching staff.
Pittsburgh Pirates Betting Form
Pittsburgh’s offense is coming off a rough day. The Pirates struck out 18 times and had only two hits in Sunday’s shutout loss to Milwaukee, which is not the kind of performance you want before opening a division series. Still, they have been better overall than that one game. The Pirates rank seventh in on-base percentage and have enough contact quality to create pressure when the lineup is not chasing.
Ryan O’Hearn has been the most stable bat, hitting .315 with four home runs, while Brandon Lowe adds real power with seven homers. Pittsburgh does not always overwhelm teams with offense, but this group can put runners on base and force pitching staffs to execute. That matters against a St. Louis team with a 4.87 ERA, one of the weaker staff marks in the league. This is the type of matchup where daily MLB picks often come down to whether you trust the better staff or the underdog power bats.
The Pirates will start Montgomery, but this is not a traditional starter spot. Montgomery is 1-0 with a 3.97 ERA across 12 appearances and has not allowed a run in his last seven outings. That current form is encouraging, though the bullpen-game setup always creates some uncertainty. Pittsburgh needs him to cover the first part cleanly, then let the deeper pitching staff control the middle and late innings.
St. Louis Cardinals vs Pittsburgh Pirates Matchup Breakdown
The Pirates have the better team pitching profile. Pittsburgh ranks fourth in ERA at 3.34 and third in opponent batting average at .218. That gives the Pirates a clear run-prevention edge, especially against a Cardinals offense that can hit home runs but still ranks only 15th in batting average.
St. Louis has the more interesting upside because May’s recent form has been much better than his season numbers. Three straight starts with only one earned run allowed is not nothing. If he keeps the ball on the ground and avoids the big inning, the Cardinals can absolutely win this game at plus money. The problem is that Pittsburgh has seen him before, and that prior meeting went badly for May.
The bullpen setup leans Pittsburgh, even with Montgomery starting. It may sound strange to back a bullpen game, but the Pirates’ staff has simply been more reliable. The Cardinals have lost too many tight games lately, and late-inning execution has been part of the issue. In a matchup projected around 4-3, that matters.
PNC Park and the weather also support a lower-scoring script. Mild conditions, scattered clouds, and a light breeze do not create an obvious boost for offense. The Cardinals have enough power to threaten the over, but Pittsburgh’s pitching profile and the park shape this more like a controlled divisional game. For bettors weighing bullpen games, starting-pitcher form, and park factors, the MLB betting guide is useful for understanding why the best side and the best total angle do not always come from the same team.
St. Louis Cardinals vs Pittsburgh Pirates Predictions and Best Bets
I lean Pirates on the moneyline. The price at -131 is reasonable, and Pittsburgh has the better pitching staff, the better bullpen profile, and home-field advantage in a division series where small edges matter. The Cardinals are not far off, but they are in a rough results stretch, and losing close games can become a real tax on the bullpen and lineup confidence.
The case for St. Louis is May. If he keeps pitching the way he has over the last three starts, the Cardinals can steal this game. Their lineup has enough power through Walker, Wetherholt, Church, and the rest of the order to punish a bullpen-game script if Pittsburgh’s relievers do not execute. I just do not love trusting the full St. Louis pitching staff right now.
The total leans under 8.0. Pittsburgh’s offense is coming off a shutout, and the Pirates’ staff has been one of the better groups in baseball at limiting hits. May’s recent form also points toward a more controlled game than his season ERA suggests. A 4-3 type of result feels realistic, which lines up with the market lean toward the under.
The best bet is Pittsburgh on the moneyline. The under is playable, but at a full 8.0, one bad bullpen inning can ruin it. The Pirates have the cleaner full-game profile, especially if Montgomery gives them a stable opening turn and the bullpen handles the rest.
Best Bet: Pirates Moneyline -131.
Analysis that actually matters.
Stop guessing and start winning.
MLB Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats
This is the type of MLB game where the handicap is not just about the starting pitcher. May’s recent form is better than his ERA, Pittsburgh is using a bullpen game, and the total is priced around a narrow divisional score. That is why comparing expert opinions through the handicapper leaderboard can help bettors see who is consistently finding value in these lower-margin spots.
ScoresAndStats gives baseball bettors a way to follow long-term results instead of chasing one pick at a time. The top sports handicappers page makes it easier to compare styles, records, and profit across the daily MLB board.
