New York Yankees vs New York Mets Picks and Predictions May 17th 2025

Juan Soto, Mets Attempt to Level Subway Series in Bronx

Soto Embraces Bronx Return Amid Boos

Juan Soto’s much-anticipated return to Yankee Stadium came with a chorus of boos from the crowd that once cheered him. In his first game back as a member of the New York Mets, Soto was held hitless but made an impact by drawing three walks and scoring a run.

“You gotta embrace it,” Soto said after the game. “Whatever they give you, it is what it is. You got to be a professional. You got to take it as a man. I was just enjoying the moment.”

Soto, who hit 41 home runs in his lone season as a Yankee last year, now dons the Mets uniform after signing a staggering 15-year, $765 million deal in December. On Friday night, he had a chance to deliver in the ninth but flew out with two men on, ending the Mets’ rally attempt.

Stay updated on every roster move—track all professional baseball teams.

Mets Search for Consistency

The Mets have been resilient early in the 2025 season, avoiding long losing streaks. However, Friday’s 6-2 loss to the Yankees marked their second straight defeat — something they’ve only done a handful of times through 45 games.

Despite collecting five hits, the Mets went just 2-for-11 with runners in scoring position, an area they’ll need to improve on if they want to even the series.

With Juan Soto and Pete Alonso in the heart of the lineup, Mets fans remain optimistic, especially with Griffin Canning (5-1, 2.36 ERA) taking the mound. Canning has been a steady force, coming off six strong innings against the Cubs in his last outing.

For those closely tracking this interleague showdown and looking for value in MLB betting picks, this matchup has all the ingredients for a tightly contested game. You can explore more insights and analysis with our expert-reviewed MLB predictions and picks.

Yankees Stay Hot Behind Star Power

The Yankees are starting to resemble the dominant force many expected heading into the season. With seven wins in their past nine games, New York is thriving thanks to major contributions from Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and Paul Goldschmidt.

Bellinger continued his tear with three hits on Friday, extending his hitting streak to 11 games. Meanwhile, Judge raised his league-leading batting average to .414 and reached base three times.

“It was a pretty great environment,” Yankees manager Aaron Boone said of Friday’s electric atmosphere. “Certainly one of those nights where you can really feel the energy in the building.”

Goldschmidt, acquired in the offseason, chipped in with run-scoring singles in both the third and fourth innings, helping the Yankees tally all six of their runs early.

Want Better Results From Your MLB Bets?

Our Picks Give You the Edge You Need

Check Them Out Now!

Everything You Need To Know About Sports Is On Our Blog—Check It Out.

Pitching Matchup: Schmidt vs. Canning

Clarke Schmidt (1-1, 4.73 ERA) will start for the Yankees, fresh off his first win of the season. He held Seattle to three hits and three runs over six-plus innings earlier this week.

Schmidt has a 2.45 ERA in two career appearances against the Mets, including a win in relief the last time he faced them in August 2022.

Griffin Canning, meanwhile, looks to match his win total from last year. He’s unbeaten in his last six starts and owns a 3.94 ERA in three prior meetings with the Yankees.