New York City Fc vs Inter Miami Cf Picks and Predictions September 24th 2025

Inter Miami vs New York City FC Picks and Predictions

The Eastern Conference playoff race heats up as Inter Miami, led by Lionel Messi, travel to face New York City FC at Yankee Stadium. A draw would be enough for Miami to clinch their postseason spot, while a win would lift them into third place, leapfrogging both NYCFC and Charlotte FC. For the hosts, the mission is to solidify their top-four standing and keep their strong form rolling. With Messi and Luis Suárez set to feature for Miami, and Alonso Martinez in top form for New York, this clash has the makings of a high-stakes thriller.

Score Big:3,500 Pro Picks for Just $9

New Members Only!

Get Free Trial

Inter Miami Can Win If…

Inter Miami come into this match on a roll, having won back-to-back home games against D.C. United and Seattle. Saturday’s 3-2 victory over D.C. saw Messi dominate once again, scoring twice and assisting another. He now leads MLS with 22 goals, continuing to prove why Miami’s attack is among the most feared in the league.

Manager Javier Mascherano emphasized performance over pressure, saying Miami’s focus is on climbing the standings while building momentum for the postseason. The return of Luis Suárez from suspension is a huge boost, giving Miami a veteran finisher to pair with Messi. Suárez’s presence should open up space for Josef Martínez and Leonardo Campana in the attack.

On the defensive side, Miami still have room to improve. They’ve allowed 38 goals this season, ranking middle of the pack, but Drake Callender’s consistency in goal has often kept them competitive. If Miami can control possession through Sergio Busquets and force NYCFC onto the back foot, they’ll have the upper hand.

New York City FC Can Win If…

NYCFC have surged since the Leagues Cup break, winning five of their last six, including a convincing 2-0 win over Charlotte FC that snapped their opponent’s nine-game winning streak. Their defense has been a major key, with new signings Raul Gustavo and Nicolas Fernández Mercau tightening things up at the back.

Offensively, Alonso Martinez continues to be the go-to option, leading the team with 17 goals. His combination play with Santiago Rodríguez makes NYCFC dangerous in transition. Against Miami’s backline, expect Martinez to look for early chances in behind.

Coach Pascal Jensen praised his squad’s mentality and depth, noting the added versatility from recent acquisitions. If NYCFC can frustrate Messi and capitalize on counterattacks, they have the formula to take all three points and solidify their playoff standing.

Team Comparison

The Lean

Oddsmakers are split, with Miami listed as slight underdogs at +145 and NYCFC at +165, while a draw sits around +230. Miami’s firepower led by Messi and the return of Suárez makes them tough to bet against, but NYCFC’s form and home advantage level the playing field. My model projects a 2-2 draw, with both teams finding the net.

The total is set at 2.5 goals, and the over looks like the best play here. Miami games have averaged 3.2 goals this season, and NYCFC have been scoring consistently at home.

Explore all MLS teams here.

Betting Trends

• Inter Miami are undefeated in their last 6 matches.
• NYCFC have won 5 of their last 6 games.
• Both teams have scored in 4 of the last 5 Miami matches.
• The over 2.5 has hit in 6 of the last 8 Inter Miami road games.

Read the full soccer betting guide.

Inter Miami Outlook

Miami’s focus is not only on clinching playoffs but also on building form for a deep postseason run. Messi’s brilliance is undeniable, and with Suárez back in the fold, Miami’s attack looks even stronger. Their challenge will be tightening up defensively against a sharp NYCFC side.

Check today’s soccer picks here.

New York City FC Outlook

NYCFC have been one of the hottest teams in the East since August, and their improved defensive structure has made them a genuine contender. With Martinez in top scoring form and a well-organized midfield, they have every reason to believe they can outlast Miami at home.

See the latest MLS odds.

Probable Lineups