NFL Previews 
MLB Previews 
NBA Previews 
NHL Previews 
Soccer Previews 
Ottawa Senators vs Toronto Maple Leafs Picks and Predictions – Saturday December 27, 2025
The Battle of Ontario is back Saturday night as the Ottawa Senators visit the Toronto Maple Leafs at Scotiabank Arena. Puck drop is set for 7:00 PM ET on Sportsnet, and it’s the first meeting of the season between two teams sitting outside the playoff line but playing like they still expect to get there.
Ottawa comes in with a five-game points streak (4-0-1) and a lot of the underlying stuff you want to see: better 200-foot play, more time in the offensive zone, and Tim Stutzle driving offense night after night. Toronto finally got a win before the break, beating Pittsburgh 6-3, but the Leafs have still been inconsistent over the last couple weeks and the power play has been a real problem for a roster with that much skill.
This matchup usually comes down to who handles emotion and pace better. Ottawa wants a fast game with pressure. Toronto wants cleaner exits, fewer odd-man looks against, and special teams that do not sabotage them.
Ottawa Senators vs Toronto Maple Leafs Odds
These are the current betting lines, and bettors should always monitor updated NHL odds leading into puck drop. Keep tracking the latest NHL odds as goalie confirmations and lineup decisions can move this market quickly.
| Team | Moneyline | Puck Line | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ottawa Senators | +138 | +1.5 (-198) | O 6.5 (-118) |
| Toronto Maple Leafs | -166 | -1.5 (+164) | U 6.5 (-102) |
Ottawa Senators Betting Form
Ottawa’s recent form is the kind that makes me take a dog seriously. They have points in five straight and the games have not felt fluky. The Senators are playing with pace, they’re getting into the interior more, and they’ve been competitive even when they are not finishing perfectly. Stutzle’s eight-game points streak matters because it’s not only power-play production. He’s creating at five-on-five, and that keeps Ottawa from needing a perfect special teams night to score.
From a betting perspective, Ottawa’s biggest improvement is that their defensive game has looked more connected. They’re tracking back with more urgency and they’re not bleeding as many odd-man rushes. That’s important against Toronto because the Leafs can still punish a single bad change. If Ottawa can keep the neutral zone from turning into a track lane, they’ll have a real chance to win this outright.
For a broader view of how their results have landed recently, check Ottawa Senators stats and results. Availability matters here, so monitor the Ottawa Senators injury report before puck drop.
Toronto Maple Leafs Betting Form
Toronto needed the break, but they also needed that Pittsburgh win. The Leafs have been in a stretch where a strong start still leads to a messy third period, and it’s been hard to trust them at a price. The good sign is William Nylander snapping the drought with a big game, plus getting Chris Tanev back in the lineup. Toronto is a different team when the defensive pairings look steadier and the exits are cleaner.
The betting issue is the power play. It’s been bottom of the league, and that’s a real edge leak. When a team has Auston Matthews, Nylander, and John Tavares, you expect special teams to be a weapon, not a weakness. Until it flips, Toronto has to win games at five-on-five, and that is where they can still drift into stretches of low intensity and loose coverage.
If you want the split trends and recent game results, start with Toronto Maple Leafs schedule and stats. Also keep tabs on the Toronto Maple Leafs injury report before you bet, because this roster’s value changes quickly if a top-six forward or a key defenseman sits.
Ottawa Senators vs Toronto Maple Leafs Matchup Breakdown
At five-on-five, Ottawa wants to pressure Toronto’s breakouts and force rushed decisions. If the Senators can turn Toronto’s exits into chipped pucks and 50-50 battles, they can tilt possession and keep Matthews from living in the offensive zone. Toronto’s path is the opposite: clean exits, controlled entries, and turning Ottawa’s aggressive forecheck into odd-man chances.
Special teams are where this gets interesting. Toronto’s power play has been a problem, while Ottawa’s recent scoring has not been dependent on man-advantage looks. That usually favors the underdog in a rivalry game, because it reduces the automatic “two power plays equals a goal” tax that favorites often carry. If Toronto’s power play wakes up, it changes everything. But you’re betting on a turnaround, not betting on a proven edge.
Goaltending is the other hinge point. Toronto and Ottawa both have scenarios where a confirmed starter can swing the number. If Toronto goes with its top option and Ottawa rotates, it pushes me closer to Leafs regulation. If Ottawa gets the goaltending edge on the night, the plus-money side becomes even more attractive, and the total leans up.
If you want a more systematic way to think about moneyline versus puck line in rivalry games, the NHL betting guide is a good reference for how to price variance and avoid overpaying for “home ice.”
Ottawa Senators vs Toronto Maple Leafs Predictions and Best Bets
My lean is Ottawa moneyline (+138). The number is giving Toronto a lot of credit for home ice and brand, and I get it, Toronto’s ceiling is higher when their stars are rolling. But Ottawa is playing better hockey right now. They’re defending with more purpose, they’re generating chances consistently, and they’re not relying on power play efficiency to get to three goals.
For Toronto, the easiest case is that Tuesday’s scoring burst carries over, Nylander stays hot, and the Leafs finally string together a cleaner 60 minutes. That can happen. But until the power play shows real life and the third-period slippage goes away, I’m not eager to lay -166 in a rivalry game where one mistake can flip momentum.
On the total, I lean over 6.5. Both teams can generate rush chances, and this rivalry tends to create extra penalties and extra chaos, even when the coaches would prefer structure. If the goaltending matchup ends up being stronger than expected, that over can feel sweaty late, but the pricing is reasonable and the path to seven goals is clear.
Best Bet: Ottawa Senators moneyline (+138).
NHL Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats
NHL betting is a grind, and nights like this are exactly why process matters. Rivalry games bring more variance, goalie confirmation moves the market late, and public narratives can skew prices. Checking today’s NHL picks is a good way to compare multiple viewpoints on the slate instead of relying on one angle.
It also helps to follow people with accountability over time. The top sports handicappers page makes it easier to find consistent performers, and the handicapper leaderboard keeps it transparent when you’re deciding who to tail.
If you want higher volume through the regular season, premium NHL picks can fit better than forcing action into every game yourself. And if you’re mixing nightly betting with futures positioning, the Stanley Cup betting guide is useful for judging whether a hot streak is actually sustainable. For more matchup coverage beyond this one, the NHL previews hub keeps the board organized.
