NFL Previews 
MLB Previews 
NBA Previews 
NHL Previews 
Soccer Previews 
Colorado Avalanche vs Toronto Maple Leafs Picks and Predictions – Sunday January 25, 2026
Colorado gets the rematch it wanted, and the timing is interesting. The Avalanche are still the class of the West on record, but they’re coming off an ugly third period in a 7-3 loss that exposed some sloppy puck management and soft coverage in front. Toronto is not playing well either, winless in three since returning home, and the vibe has been more frustration than confidence.
This sets up as a “who cleans up first” game. Colorado’s ceiling is obvious, but the goaltending has not looked settled lately. Toronto’s talent can score with anyone, yet their recent issue is sustaining pressure when the game is there to be taken, especially late.
Puck drop is Sunday afternoon at Scotiabank Arena at 1:30 PM on NHLN.
Colorado Avalanche vs Toronto Maple Leafs Odds
These are the current lines, and bettors should keep monitoring updated NHL odds on the latest NHL odds board as goalie confirmation and any late scratches hit.
| Team | Moneyline | Puck Line | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Colorado Avalanche | -184 | -1.5 (+135) | 6.5 |
| Toronto Maple Leafs | +153 | +1.5 (-165) | 6.5 |
Colorado Avalanche Betting Form
Colorado’s overall profile is still elite. They drive play, they generate volume, and their best players can turn a game in one shift. The concern is the defensive urgency when they get stretched. That Flyers third period is the exact kind of tape coaches hate, and it’s also the kind of stretch that can show up again if the Avs start forcing offense on the road.
The other handicap variable is in net. If Colorado’s goaltending is still searching for rhythm, it changes how aggressive you want to be with laying a big price or leaning into a high total. The Avalanche can absolutely win 5-3 in this building, but that is a different bet than “Colorado controls the game and closes it out clean.”
For recent results and team splits, check Colorado Avalanche stats and results, then confirm availability with Colorado Avalanche injury report.
Toronto Maple Leafs Betting Form
Toronto is in a rough stretch, and the frustrating part is the pattern. They’ve had moments where the game tilts their way, then they lose momentum and stop playing like a team that believes it can dictate the third period. That’s a big deal against a club like Colorado, because if you give the Avs one window to flip the ice, they can score in bunches.
The Maple Leafs’ offensive talent is still the reason they’re live in any home game. They can win this with power-play execution and a cleaner third period, and they can also cover +1.5 even in a loss if the game turns into a track meet. The question is whether they can tighten the middle of the ice enough to keep Colorado from getting too many high-danger looks off rush chances and broken plays.
For a quick snapshot of home form and recent outputs, use Toronto Maple Leafs schedule and stats, and verify availability through Toronto Maple Leafs injury report.
Colorado Avalanche vs Toronto Maple Leafs Matchup Breakdown
At 5v5, this is about pace control. Colorado wants the game open, especially if they’re getting clean exits and turning neutral-zone touches into speed through the middle. Toronto’s best answer is layered support on breakouts and a strong backcheck, because once Colorado is attacking downhill, you’re defending with your feet, not your stick.
Special teams could decide the total. When Colorado is loose defensively, penalties often follow because they’re chasing. Toronto can also take momentum-killing minors when they get frustrated. If this game turns into a power-play heavy script, 6.5 is very reachable even if one goalie plays well.
Goaltending is the biggest unknown. Toronto has been juggling the crease recently, and Colorado has not looked sharp in recent starts either. If either team confirms a backup, the betting angles shift quickly toward offense and live overs. If both preferred starters go, I still think this plays faster than the average 6.5 because both clubs can create chances in transition.
The situational angle is solid for Toronto in the sense that they need this one badly and they’re at home, but Colorado’s motivation is obvious too after the earlier overtime loss and the way Friday ended. This should be a focused Avs start.
Colorado Avalanche vs Toronto Maple Leafs Predictions and Best Bets
Colorado is the correct favorite, but it’s a price that requires a fairly clean game. I’m more comfortable backing the Avalanche when they’re not bleeding third-period chaos and when their goalie looks settled. Right now, there’s enough volatility that I don’t want to lay -184 blindly.
Toronto at +153 is the value side if you believe the Leafs can keep the neutral zone from turning into a runway. Home ice matters most against speed teams when you can dictate matchups and avoid getting your third pair stuck in bad spots, and that’s where Toronto can make this uncomfortable for Colorado.
On the total, 6.5 is high, but the matchup supports it. Both teams can generate chances quickly, and both have shown recent moments where defensive structure disappears. I lean over if there’s any hint of a backup goalie or tired legs defensively, and I’m more cautious if both starters are confirmed and the whistle stays quiet.
Best Bet: Over 6.5 goals (-116)
NHL Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats
If you’re betting this game as part of a slate, compare your positions with the rest of the board on the NHL picks page and see how the market is treating similar big favorites and high totals.
For longer-term edges, I like tracking who’s consistently beating the number through the best handicappers hub, then checking current form on the handicapper leaderboard. If you want full-card coverage and packaged plays, you can also buy picks.
And if you’re bouncing between matchups, the NHL previews hub is a clean way to scan situational spots. For a fundamentals reset on sides, totals, and market behavior, the NHL betting guide helps, and the Stanley Cup betting guide is useful when you’re thinking beyond one night and pricing longer-range futures.
