NFL Previews 
MLB Previews 
NBA Previews 
NHL Previews 
Soccer Previews 
The New York Rangers visit the New York Islanders on Wednesday, January 28, 2026 at 7:00 PM ET at UBS Arena in Elmont, N.Y. It’s a rivalry game with real standings weight: the Rangers are 22-25-6 and trying to stabilize after another rough stretch, while the Islanders are 28-19-5 and protecting a top-three spot in the Metropolitan.
This one also has that weird “business side” feel. The Rangers just moved defenseman Carson Soucy to the Islanders, and now he could be in the building immediately for the first leg of a home-and-home. The market has the Islanders favored (Islanders moneyline -148, Rangers moneyline +126), and the handicap starts with one question that always matters in these games: who’s actually in the lineup, and who’s in net.
Follow the Top NHL Handicappers
Verified Records. Real Results.
New York Rangers vs New York Islanders Odds
These are the current betting lines, but bettors should always monitor updated latest NHL odds leading up to puck drop.
| Team | Moneyline | Puck Line | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York Rangers | +126 | +1.5 (-210) | O 6.0 (-120) |
| New York Islanders | -148 | -1.5 (+175) | U 6.0 (EVEN) |
Ottawa Senators
vs
Colorado Avalanche
Columbus Blue Jackets
vs
Philadelphia Flyers
New York Islanders
vs
New York Rangers
New York Rangers Betting Form
New York’s recent results scream “fragile,” even when they win. They’ve had long stretches where the puck management just isn’t clean, and when that happens, the whole game tilts toward defending instead of dictating. That’s a problem on the road in this building because the Islanders are comfortable winning ugly. For game logs and lineup context, the clean reference is the New York Rangers stats and results.
The bigger betting issue is availability. If Igor Shesterkin is still out, it changes how you price both the side and the total because the Rangers have less margin for error when they get sloppy in their own end. Adam Fox being out matters too, since he drives exits and keeps the power play from stalling. Availability matters here, so monitor the New York Rangers injury report before puck drop.
New York Islanders Betting Form
The Islanders have been the steadier team this season, and they tend to play a style that holds up in divisional games. They defend the middle, they don’t mind low-event stretches, and they’re perfectly fine turning it into a one-goal game late. When they’re right, the opponent feels like it has to earn every clean look. For home splits and recent results, start with the New York Islanders schedule and stats.
Injuries still shape how you bet them, though. Ryan Pulock’s status matters because it affects matchups and defensive pair usage, and they’ve already been dealing with key absences on the blue line. If the Islanders are missing bodies, they can still win, but the “easy” unders become a little less comfortable. Keep an eye on the New York Islanders injury report as the lineup shakes out.
New York Rangers vs New York Islanders Matchup Breakdown
This game usually lives at five-on-five. The Islanders want controlled pace and clean layers through the neutral zone. The Rangers can play fast, but lately it’s been inconsistent, and that’s where turnovers become goals against. If New York isn’t sharp with the puck, they’re going to spend too much time defending cycle pressure and scrambling on second chances.
Goaltending is the swing piece, and it’s not fully confirmed yet. The current expectation is Jonathan Quick for New York and Ilya Sorokin for the Islanders, but both are still listed as unconfirmed. If Shesterkin unexpectedly trends toward available, the Rangers price tightens fast. If it’s Quick again, you’re basically betting that New York can keep the game structured for 60 minutes, and that has not been a reliable ask.
Special teams can still decide it, but I think it’s more about opportunity than efficiency. Rivalry games tend to be choppy, and a couple power plays either way can flip the script. If you want a refresher on how to weigh power play variance, goalie value, and regulation angles, the NHL betting guide is a good quick framework. And if you’re the type who turns a game like this into a futures conversation, the Stanley Cup betting guide is the right place to anchor that thinking.
NHL Lines Before the Puck Drops
Beat the Books to Every Number
New York Rangers vs New York Islanders Predictions and Best Bets
I lean Islanders on the moneyline at -148. It’s not a steal, but it fits the matchup: better current profile, more stable defensive identity, and they’re at home. The Rangers can absolutely show up emotionally in this rivalry, but I’m not excited to pay for New York’s “ceiling” when the floor has been showing up too often, especially if Shesterkin and Fox remain out.
The puck line is the tricky part. Islanders -1.5 at +175 is tempting because the Rangers can spiral if they chase the game, but rivalry games also love landing 3-2 or 2-1. I’d rather keep it simple unless we get strong lineup clarity that points to a real goaltending gap.
On the total, I lean under 6.0 if the Islanders get Sorokin and their defense group is close to full strength. The Islanders want the game slow, and the Rangers don’t always generate clean volume when they’re forced into half-court offense. Still, I’m a little cautious because if it’s Quick and New York’s puck management turns messy, you can get “bad goals” that ruin an under even when the pace feels right.
Best Bet: New York Islanders moneyline (-148).
NHL Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats
If you’re betting NHL every day, it helps to compare your reads against volume. The easiest starting point is the full slate of today’s NHL picks, then use the NHL previews hub to scan matchup context quickly when lines move late.
The real edge is accountability. ScoresAndStats makes it easy to track performance and filter by style, not just hot streaks. You can sort through top sports handicappers and check the handicapper leaderboard to see who’s actually producing over time. And if you want to follow specific cappers more closely, you can always step up to buy expert picks for deeper card volume and higher-confidence positions.
