NFL Previews 
MLB Previews 
NBA Previews 
NHL Previews 
Soccer Previews 
Turn MLB Results Into Smarter Bets
See what the data says next
The Pittsburgh Pirates and Toronto Blue Jays meet Sunday, May 24, 2026, at Rogers Centre, with first pitch scheduled for 12:15 PM ET. Pittsburgh enters at 26-26, fifth in the NL Central, but the recent form is moving the wrong way with two straight losses and a 3-7 record over its last ten games.
Toronto comes in at 25-27, third in the AL East, but the Blue Jays are playing their best baseball of the month. They have won four straight, are 7-3 over their last ten, and just beat the Pirates 5-2 on Saturday behind a strong pitching performance and enough power to separate late.
The roof at Rogers Centre should limit the impact of light rain, so this handicap is mostly about starting pitching and current form. Mitch Keller gives Pittsburgh a competitive arm, but Dylan Cease brings the higher strikeout ceiling for Toronto. That is the difference in a game where both offenses have enough contact ability, but neither side profiles as an automatic run producer.
Pittsburgh Pirates vs Toronto Blue Jays Odds
The current MLB odds have Toronto priced as the home favorite, which reflects the Blue Jays’ winning streak, Cease’s form, and Pittsburgh’s recent slide. The total sits low at 7.5, signaling respect for both starting pitchers.
| Market | Pick / Odds |
|---|---|
| Moneyline | Pittsburgh Pirates +135 / Toronto Blue Jays -161 |
| Run Line | Pittsburgh Pirates run line not provided / Toronto Blue Jays run line not provided |
| Total | Over 7.5 (-110) / Under 7.5 (-110) |
Pittsburgh Pirates Betting Form
The Pittsburgh Pirates are not in good recent form, but their offensive profile is stronger than the 3-7 stretch suggests. Pittsburgh ranks fourth in batting average at .251 and third in on-base percentage at .332, which gives the Pirates a real chance to create traffic even against a high-strikeout arm.
The issue is whether that traffic turns into damage. Bryan Reynolds gave Pittsburgh quality at-bats in Saturday’s loss, and Brandon Lowe’s 13 home runs give the lineup a power threat, but the Pirates need more than isolated production. Against Cease, they must avoid empty baserunners and force him into deep counts.
Mitch Keller gives Pittsburgh a reasonable path to an upset. He enters with a 4-2 record, 3.86 ERA, and 1.06 WHIP, which is good enough to keep the Pirates in the game if he limits extra-base damage. The Pittsburgh Pirates injury report still matters, though, with Ryan O’Hearn, Joey Bart, Jared Jones, and Chris Devenski unavailable.
Toronto Blue Jays Betting Form
The Toronto Blue Jays are riding a four-game winning streak, and the recent results are being driven by pitching as much as offense. Saturday’s 5-2 win showed the current formula well: quality starting work, enough extra-base contact, and a bullpen that did not have to survive constant pressure.
Dylan Cease is the main reason Toronto deserves favorite status. He enters with a 2.98 ERA and 84 strikeouts, giving the Blue Jays a swing-and-miss edge that Pittsburgh may struggle to neutralize. Toronto’s staff also ranks third in strikeouts with 481, which fits the current game script if the Pirates are forced into chase counts.
The lineup is not fully healthy, but there is still enough production to support Cease. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. leads Toronto with a .287 average and 22 RBIs, while Kazuma Okamoto adds power with 10 home runs. The concern is availability, as the Toronto Blue Jays injury report includes Anthony Santander, Alejandro Kirk, Addison Barger, Max Scherzer, José Berríos, Yimi García, and several other key pieces.
Pittsburgh Pirates vs Toronto Blue Jays Matchup Breakdown
The starting pitching matchup is competitive, but Cease has the clearer ceiling. Keller’s WHIP is strong, and he can keep Pittsburgh close, but Cease’s strikeout rate gives Toronto more ways to escape traffic. That matters against a Pirates offense that reaches base well but needs timely contact to turn those chances into runs.
Pittsburgh’s best path is forcing Cease to work. The Pirates have enough batting average and on-base ability to make him throw pitches, but that only matters if they avoid strikeout-heavy innings. If Cease gets early-count whiffs, Toronto can control tempo and keep Pittsburgh from turning its contact profile into scoreboard pressure.
Toronto’s offense does not need a huge day to justify the favorite price. The Blue Jays just produced 11 hits and six extra-base hits against Pittsburgh, and their current confidence is higher than the season record suggests. If Guerrero and Okamoto are creating middle-order pressure, Keller’s margin gets thin quickly.
The total at 7.5 is tight. Toronto’s last ten games lean under, and the starting pitching points in that direction. The problem is that both teams can reach base, and the Pirates’ injury-shortened lineup still has enough power to punish one mistake. The under is playable, but it requires clean bullpen work from two teams dealing with notable pitching absences.
Pittsburgh Pirates vs Toronto Blue Jays Predictions and Best Bets
Toronto is the right side, but the price is not a free square. The Blue Jays have the better recent form, the stronger starting pitcher, and home-field control inside a roofed environment. With Cease on the mound and Toronto winning four straight, the favorite role is justified.
Pittsburgh is live because Keller is not overmatched. His 3.86 ERA and 1.06 WHIP give the Pirates enough stability to hang around, especially if their top-of-the-order bats force Cease into longer innings. The concern is that Pittsburgh’s recent form is poor, and its offense has not consistently converted baserunners into runs during this slide.
The under 7.5 is a reasonable secondary lean, but the number is already tight. A 4-3 projection leaves very little cushion, and Toronto’s current extra-base form makes a late over push possible if Keller fades or the Pirates bullpen gets exposed.
The strongest angle is Toronto on the moneyline. The Blue Jays have the better starter, the better current rhythm, and the more dependable game script. The biggest risk is Keller matching Cease for six innings and turning -161 into a one-run coin flip late, but Toronto’s strikeout edge gives it the cleaner betting profile.
Best Bet: Toronto Blue Jays Moneyline -161
MLB Picks and Handicappers on ScoresAndStats
For bettors comparing this matchup with the rest of Sunday’s card, the MLB picks page is a useful place to track expert angles across moneylines, totals, run lines, and first-five markets. The MLB previews section also gives a broader game-by-game view of the daily board.
The MLB expert betting guide can help bettors sharpen how they evaluate starting pitchers, bullpen usage, park factors, and totals. You can also use the full MLB teams hub to compare team form and matchup data around the league.
ScoresAndStats also features best handicappers, a live handicapper leaderboard, and options to buy picks when you want premium betting opinions beyond your own card.
