Buffalo Sabres vs New York Rangers Picks and Predictions October 9th 2025

Last Updated on

New York Rangers vs Buffalo Sabres Betting Preview

The New York Rangers visit the Buffalo Sabres on Thursday night at KeyBank Center in a matchup between two Eastern Conference teams eager to set the tone early. The puck drops at 7:00 PM ET on ESPN+. Mike Sullivan, making his second appearance as Rangers head coach, looks to rebound from a 3-0 opening loss to Pittsburgh. Meanwhile, Lindy Ruff’s Sabres begin their season looking to snap a 14-year playoff drought.

sas logo

Smarter Picks, Better Results

Today’s Plays. Tomorrow’s Profits.

The latest betting odds show New York at -114 on the moneyline, with Buffalo priced at -105. The puck line lists the Rangers -1.5 (+211) and the Sabres +1.5 (-267). The total sits at 6.0 goals (Over -106 / Under -114).

Looking for verified NHL expert picks and hot handicappers? See who’s leading right now →

Line Movement and Odds

Oddsmakers opened this matchup around even, but early money has leaned slightly toward the Rangers after their competitive opener against Pittsburgh. Around 57% of bets and 61% of money are backing New York on the moneyline, while sharps are favoring the under at 6.0 due to both teams’ conservative early-season systems.

The Rangers’ Igor Shesterkin stopped 27 of 28 shots in that loss, maintaining elite form. Buffalo’s goaltending situation remains uncertain, with Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen ruled out and newcomer Alex Lyon likely starting.

“We’re going to deal with a goaltender being out,” said Sabres coach Lindy Ruff. “We’ve got a chance to prove what we can be by dealing with a little adversity right off the start.”

The Sabres enter 2025-26 with a 36-39-7 record from last season, while New York is 0-1 after dropping its opener under Sullivan.

NHL
2025-10-11 12:07
Open
NEW YORK RANGERS
7 PICKS
PITTSBURGH PENGUINS
NHL
2025-10-11 12:07
Open
OTTAWA SENATORS
3 PICKS
FLORIDA PANTHERS
NHL
2025-10-11 12:07
Open
TORONTO MAPLE LEAFS
5 PICKS
DETROIT RED WINGS
NHL
2025-10-11 13:07
Open
COLUMBUS BLUE JACKETS
5 PICKS
MINNESOTA WILD
NHL
2025-10-11 15:07
Open
ANAHEIM DUCKS
5 PICKS
SAN JOSE SHARKS
NHL
2025-10-11 15:07
Open
VEGAS GOLDEN KNIGHTS
4 PICKS
SEATTLE KRAKEN

Matchup Breakdown

New York Rangers Outlook

Sullivan’s debut behind the bench didn’t go as planned, but the Rangers played disciplined hockey, logging 34 hits and 17 blocks while holding Pittsburgh to one even-strength goal. Their defensive structure looks sharp, and Shesterkin remains the backbone. New York’s offense must ignite after going 0-for-2 on the power play and generating 25 shots on goal in the opener. With Mika Zibanejad and J.T. Miller leading the top line, puck possession and zone entries will be key to breaking through against Buffalo’s transitional defense.

Buffalo Sabres Outlook

Buffalo opens the year at home looking to build confidence and erase years of playoff frustration. Forward Tage Thompson (44 goals, 72 points last season) and Rasmus Dahlin (68 points) headline a dynamic top unit capable of pushing pace. Alex Tuch adds two-way reliability with 67 points and 113 blocks. Ruff’s offseason additions — Josh Doan and Michael Kesselring — add grit, though both are still adapting to his system. The Sabres will need a fast start, especially with Luukkonen sidelined and Lyon handling the crease.


Injuries and Conditions

Buffalo SabresNew York Rangers
G Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen – Out (lower body)F Filip Chytil – Questionable (upper body)
D Michael Kesselring – Out (undisclosed)D Ryan Lindgren – Probable (maintenance)
D Owen Power – Probable (undisclosed)G Igor Shesterkin – Starting
D Mattias Samuelsson – Probable (returning from injury)
Buffalo Sabres Injury Report
F Kaapo Kakko – Healthy scratch candidate
New York Rangers Injury Report

Weather: Indoors at KeyBank Center, no weather impact.

Top Winners – Today
Al Grant
$323
2. Sports Central
$300
3. Kyle Buchman
$220
4. Scott’s Picks
$200
5. Ryan Davis
$200
Top Winners – Yesterday
Al Grant
$323
2. Sports Central
$300
3. Kyle Buchman
$220
4. Scott’s Picks
$200
5. Ryan Davis
$200
Top Winners – This Week
Seth Cohen
$910
2. Coach Rick
$745
3. Heather Williams
$690
4. Will Rogers
$505
5. Pro Sports Picks
$500
Top Winners – This Month
Rubi Chavez
$1,947
2. Ryan Davis
$1,518
3. Coach Rick
$1,165
4. Geovanny Araya
$1,046
5. Dan Jones
$1,042

Best Bets and Prediction

The Rangers’ defensive foundation and elite goaltending give them a slight edge in a low-scoring contest. Buffalo’s offense has the potential to flash early, but with Lyon in net and key defenders easing back from injury, the Sabres face a tough task against a Rangers team eager to correct opening-night mistakes. Expect a structured game with limited scoring chances on both ends.

Pick: Rangers Moneyline (-114)
Projected Final Score: Rangers 3, Sabres 2
Lean: Under 6.0 (-114)

For more NHL Moneyline Picks, Game Forecasts, and Hockey Analysis, check the ScoresAndStats NHL Previews page.

The NHL season is heating up — stay ahead of the action. Get more expert NHL betting advice here →

CategoryDetail
Best BetRangers ML (-114)
Confidence Rating★★★★☆
Projected ScoreRangers 3, Sabres 2
Total LeanUnder 6.0 (-114)
Market Split57% bets Rangers, 61% money Rangers

ScoresAndStats Handicappers and Picks

The new NHL season means fresh betting edges. Track performance from verified experts using the ScoresAndStats Leaderboard to find the hottest NHL cappers.

For daily updates, betting news, and free hockey insights, visit the ScoresAndStats Blog — your go-to source for NHL predictions and betting strategy all season long.