SIERA (skill-interactive ERA) estimates the ERA that a pitcher’s strikeouts, walks and batted-ball mix deserve, on the same scale as ERA. Unlike FIP and xFIP, it does not ignore balls in play.
That last point is the whole case for the stat. FIP prices a pitcher on strikeouts, walks and home runs alone. SIERA keeps those inputs and adds ground balls, fly balls and pop-ups, so a pitcher who controls the type of contact he allows gets credit for it.
What SIERA measures
MLB.com’s glossary defines SIERA as a way to quantify a pitcher’s performance by trying to eliminate the factors he cannot control by himself. Unlike xFIP, it considers balls in play and adjusts for the type of ball in play. MLB’s example: a pitcher with a high xFIP who induces many grounders and pop-ups instead of line drives will post a lower SIERA than xFIP.
FanGraphs’ Sabermetrics Library entry, written by Piper Slowinski on July 27, 2011, sets out what the formula captures that simpler estimators miss:
- Strikeouts: they count for more than FIP suggests. High-strikeout pitchers allow weaker contact, a lower BABIP (batting average on balls in play) and lower home run rates.
- Walks: they hurt low-walk pitchers less than other pitchers.
- Batted-ball mix: a pitcher with a higher ground-ball rate gets a lower BABIP on his grounders, and a high fly-ball pitcher has a lower home run per fly ball rate.
A strikeout rate changes what a walk costs, and a ground-ball rate changes what a ball in play costs. FanGraphs also lists SIERA as park-adjusted.
The SIERA formula
MLB.com gives the formula as 6.145 – 16.986 (SO/PA) + 11.434 (BB/PA) – 1.858 ((GB-FB-PU)/PA) + 7.653 ((SO/PA)^2) +/- 6.664 (((GB-FB-PU)/PA)^2) + 10.130 (SO/PA) ((GB-FB-PU)/PA) – 5.195 (BB/PA)*((GB-FB-PU)/PA).
The terms: SO is strikeouts, BB is walks, PA is plate appearances, GB is ground balls, FB is fly balls and PU is pop-ups. Every input is divided by plate appearances, so the formula works on rates and not on counts. The squared terms and the two cross terms are what let strikeouts, walks and batted balls interact. FanGraphs credits the formula to Matt Swartz.
What a good SIERA looks like
SIERA runs on a scale similar to ERA. FanGraphs puts it simply: a good ERA is a good SIERA. Its rating scale is an estimate, and league average varies by year.
| Rating | SIERA |
|---|---|
| Excellent | 2.90 |
| Great | 3.25 |
| Above average | 3.75 |
| Average | 3.90 |
| Below average | 4.20 |
| Poor | 4.50 |
| Awful | 5.00 |
Role moves the number. Relief pitchers generally post lower SIERAs than starters, and FanGraphs finds that a pitcher moving from the rotation to the bullpen sees his SIERA drop by 0.37 on average. The reverse move raises it by about the same amount, so compare starters with starters.
Reading SIERA beside ERA
The useful reading is the gap. A pitcher whose ERA sits well above his SIERA has allowed more runs than his strikeouts, walks and batted balls suggest. A pitcher whose ERA sits well below his SIERA has allowed fewer runs than those same inputs support.
SIERA describes the season already pitched. FanGraphs calls it a backward-looking ERA estimator, and it is not a projection system. FanGraphs rates it only slightly more predictive than xFIP and advises using several statistics in place of one. Read it next to FIP and xFIP, and next to a hitting measure such as wRC+ for the lineup the pitcher faces.
For how pitching numbers feed into game calls, see our MLB predictions. For strikeout and hits-allowed markets on individual pitchers, see MLB player props today.