Rangers vs Blue Jackets Final Score: Blue Jackets Win 1-0 in Overtime Skip to content
Scores&Stats
ES
NHL · Saturday 17 October

Rangers vs Blue Jackets Final Score: Blue Jackets Win 1-0 in Overtime

Final: Columbus Blue Jackets 1, New York Rangers 0 in overtime, Saturday 17 October at Nationwide Arena.

Our call was no bet. Before the game this page said: “No bet on the Rangers at +114.”

What decided it

Columbus won the overtime by 1. Columbus had 29 shots to New York’s 29, and scored 0 power-play goals to 0.

TeamP1P2P3OTFinal
New York Rangers00000
Columbus Blue Jackets00011
Scoring by period, from ESPN.

The last DraftKings moneyline ESPN holds for the game is New York Rangers +114, Columbus Blue Jackets -135, with a total of 6.5. Columbus, the favourite, won. The 1 goals went under the total.

What comes next

New York plays next against the Anaheim Ducks on Monday 19 October. Columbus plays next at the Minnesota Wild on Sunday 18 October: our prediction.


The prediction, as published before the game

Everything below is the page as it stood before the game, kept unchanged as the record. It was titled “Rangers vs Blue Jackets Best Pick, Prediction and Odds”.

No bet on the Rangers at +114. The price has come in to where our number no longer clears the bar, and Igor Shesterkin, the Rangers’ first-choice goalie, is out.

The Columbus Blue Jackets are -135 and the New York Rangers +114 at DraftKings. With the margin out, that prices Columbus at 55.1% and New York at 44.9%. Our number has the Blue Jackets at 50.6% and the Rangers at 49.4%, a 4.5-point gap toward New York, short of the bar of 5.

Where 50.6% comes from

The number is the average of two 2025-26 rates: the home team’s win rate in its own arena and the visitor’s loss rate on the road. Overtime and shootout wins count as wins. Neutral-site games are left out of both. Columbus had none; the Rangers’ 5-1 win over Florida at a neutral site in Miami on 2 January is out of their road half.

The Blue Jackets went 20-13-8 at Nationwide Arena: 20 wins, 13 regulation losses, 8 after regulation, a 48.8% home win rate over 41 games. The Rangers went 19-19-2 on the road and lost 21 of 40, a 52.5% road loss rate. Average the two and Columbus is 50.6%, New York 49.4%.

That is the whole case. Columbus won fewer than half its home games, and the Rangers won almost half of theirs on the road. A price of -135 reads like a home side that won more often than that.

The margin is the extra a book puts into both prices so they add to more than 100%. At -135 and +114 they add to 104.2%. Taken out, the Blue Jackets are 55.1% and the Rangers 44.9%.

Our number gives Blue Jackets 50.6 percent, the market 55.1 percentRangers at Blue Jackets: chance to win, ours against the market'sOur numberlast season, home and roadRangers 49.4%Blue Jackets 50.6%The marketmoneyline, margin removedRangers 44.9%Blue Jackets 55.1%Moneylines: Rangers +114, Blue Jackets -135. A side is a bet when the two differ by 5 points or more.
Source: ESPN results, 2025-26 regular season, read 17 October 2026. Prices: DraftKings via ESPN, read 2026-10-17 12:24 UTC.

The objection is the rest of the Rangers’ season. New York finished with 77 points and went 14-20-7 at home, and the method never looks at that half. That is the design: the same two rates on every page, never the half that suits the pick. Our inputs are 41 Columbus home games and 40 Rangers road games, all from 2025-26.

This season has started for both and none of it is in the figures. The Rangers are 6-3-0 and lost 7-1 in New Jersey on Thursday. Columbus is 2-3-0 and has not played since a 7-3 home loss to Florida on Tuesday.

Columbus at home, New York on the road

The goals say the same thing as the records: two halves that were nearly even. Columbus at home scored 3.29 a game and allowed 3.07, a surplus of 0.22. The Rangers on the road scored 3.17 and allowed 3.12, a surplus of 0.05.

Blue Jackets at home and Rangers on the road in 2025-262025-26: Blue Jackets at home against Rangers on the roadGoals scored per gameBlue Jackets at home 3.29Rangers on the road 3.17Goals allowed per gameBlue Jackets at home 3.07Rangers on the road 3.12RecordBlue Jackets at home 20-13-8Rangers on the road 19-19-2Blue Jackets: 41 home games. Rangers: 40 road games. Neutral-site games are left out.
Source: ESPN results, 2025-26 regular season, read 17 October 2026.

The other halves, which the method does not use: Columbus on the road went 20-17-4, the same 48.8% win rate, scoring 2.88 and allowing 3.10. The Rangers at home went 14-20-7, 34.1%, scoring 2.59 and allowing 3.02.

Over the full season Columbus was the better team. The Blue Jackets finished 40-30-12 with 92 points and scored exactly as many goals as they allowed. The Rangers finished 34-39-9 with 77 points and were outscored by 12. Neither reached the playoffs.

2025-26 goal margin in every game, Blue Jackets and Rangers2025-26 regular season: goal margin in every gameBlue Jackets40-30-12+0.00 goals a gameRangers34-39-9-0.15 goals a gameColoured bars are wins, grey bars are losses, first game on the left. A shootout counts as one goal.
Source: ESPN results, 2025-26 regular season, read 17 October 2026. Record is wins, regulation losses, overtime and shootout losses.

Columbus played a lot of close games. The Blue Jackets went past regulation 24 times and won 12 of them, went 18-13-12 in one-goal games, and won 22 of their 40 games by two goals or more. The Rangers went 11-12-9 in one-goal games, won 9 of the 18 that went past 60 minutes, and won 23 of their 34 by two or more.

The two teams met three times in 2025-26 and Columbus won two. The Rangers won 2-1 in a shootout in Columbus on 15 November, and the Blue Jackets won 6-3 there on 19 March. Those two are the meetings in our number: Columbus home games and Rangers road games. Columbus also won 5-4 in overtime at Madison Square Garden on 2 March, which is in neither half.

Pick: No bet on the Rangers +114

Pass on the moneyline. The gap is 4.5 points toward New York, and the threshold is 5.

This call has changed. The line opened at Blue Jackets -155 and Rangers +130. At our first read, on 16 October 2026 at 15:38 UTC, it was -142 and +120, the gap was 5.7 points, and this page said bet the Rangers at +120. By 17 October at 12:24 UTC it had moved to Blue Jackets -135 and Rangers +114, DraftKings via ESPN, and the gap fell below the bar.

The goalie points the same way. ESPN’s injury list for this game, read 17 October 2026 at 12:22 UTC, has Igor Shesterkin on injured reserve, along with Joonas Korpisalo. Shesterkin played in 51 of the Rangers’ 82 games in 2025-26, more than any other goalie, and Dylan Garand has played all three Rangers games since Shesterkin went on the list on 11 October. In the road games Shesterkin did not play, the Rangers won 6 of 18: 5 of 16 in 2025-26 and 1 of 2 this season. Run through the same method, that is a 66.7% road loss rate and Columbus at 57.7%, a gap of 2.6 points toward Columbus. A pass either way, and 18 games are fewer than half the 40 the method normally reads for New York.

What makes it a bet

While Shesterkin is out, the number that counts is the one without him. Against New York at +114, Columbus would become the bet at -109 or longer; it is -135. New York would need +192 against Columbus at -135.

The rest of ESPN’s list, read at the same time: Joe Veleno, Aidan Thompson and Adam Sykora are on injured reserve for New York, and Columbus has no one listed. None of it is in our number. Check both lineups before you bet.

The total and the puck line

The total is 6.5, over +105 and under -125. The Blue Jackets’ games went over 6.5 in 37 of 82, the Rangers’ in 32 of 82. Columbus’s home games averaged 6.36 goals, New York’s road games 6.29.

2025-26 game totals for Blue Jackets and Rangers2025-26: total goals in every game, against this game's 6.5012345678910111213146.5Blue Jacketsover 6.5 in 37 of 82Rangersover 6.5 in 32 of 82Each dot is one 2025-26 regular-season game. Dots stack where games had the same total.
Source: ESPN results, 2025-26 regular season, read 17 October 2026. A shootout winner counts as one goal. Prices: DraftKings via ESPN, read 2026-10-17 12:24 UTC.

That is 45.1% and 39.0%, an average of 42.1% for the over. With the margin removed the over is priced at 46.8% and the under at 53.2%, so our number leans to the under, by 4.7 points. Short of 5. Pass on the total.

The puck line leans to New York. Columbus is -1.5 at +185 and New York +1.5 at -225, which is 33.6% and 66.4% without the margin. The Blue Jackets won by two goals or more in 22 of 82 games. The Rangers lost by two or more in 27 of 82. Averaged, Columbus -1.5 lands 29.9% of the time against 33.6% priced, a gap of 3.8 points toward Rangers +1.5. Short of 5, and our method bets the moneyline only. The call on this game is no bet.


Rangers at Blue Jackets, Saturday 17 October, 7:00 PM ET, Nationwide Arena. Prices: DraftKings via ESPN, read 17 October 2026, 12:24 UTC (first read 16 October 2026, 15:38 UTC). Injuries: ESPN’s game page, read 17 October 2026, 12:22 UTC. Goalies by game: ESPN box scores, read 17 October 2026. Results: ESPN, 2025-26 regular season and playoffs; 2026-27 games from ESPN’s team schedules, read 16 October 2026.

ScoresAndStats Members

Get our best bets first

Free membership: our best predictions with privileged access, a note when a new prediction is published, and content for members only.