Colts at Steelers Final Score: Steelers Win 34-22 Skip to content
Scores&Stats
ES
NFL · Sunday 11 October

Colts at Steelers Final Score: Steelers Win 34-22

Final: Pittsburgh Steelers 34, Indianapolis Colts 22, Sunday 11 October at Acrisure Stadium.

Our call won. Before the game this page said: “Take the over 44.5.” The over 44.5 won: the teams scored 56.

What decided it

Pittsburgh won the fourth quarter by 7. Pittsburgh turned the ball over 0 times to Indianapolis’s 0, and gained 352 yards to 332.

TeamQ1Q2Q3Q4Final
Indianapolis Colts676322
Pittsburgh Steelers71071034
Scoring by quarter, from ESPN.

The last DraftKings line ESPN holds for the game is PIT -3, with a total of 42.5. Pittsburgh covered as the favourite. The 56 points went over the total.

What comes next

Indianapolis plays next against the Tennessee Titans on Sunday 18 October: our prediction. Pittsburgh plays next at the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Sunday 18 October.


The prediction, as published before the game

Everything below is the page as it stood before the game, kept unchanged as the record. It was titled “Colts at Steelers prediction: Take the over 44.5”.

Take the over 44.5. Both seasons’ scoring puts this game above the number, and last season’s by more than a field goal.

Watch the Colts’ defence. Indianapolis has allowed 26.0 points a game this season, and two of its four games have gone past 60 total points.

What changed since the first version

The first version of this page, with prices read on 28 September, said: “No bet on Colts at Steelers at Pittsburgh -2.5.” It passed on the total too, at 47.5, and said this: “If the total drops to 45.5 or lower, the over comes into play.”

It dropped further than that. Seven of the 11 US sportsbooks in the read of 6 October 2026 have 44.5. BetMGM, BetRivers and MyBookie have 44, and FanDuel has 43.5.

Total from 46.5 to 44The total: the last time each number was on offer43444546474846.513 Sep 16:1047.513 Sep 17:1043.56 Oct 04:1044.56 Oct 04:10446 Oct 04:10Selected steps where more than five numbers were quoted.
Source: US sportsbooks via Nucleus, read 2026-10-06 04:20 UTC. Each point is the newest time any book quoted that line (times UTC).

I can’t see a result that explains three points. Pittsburgh’s game in Cleveland last week went 51 points against a closing total of 38. The Colts’ game in Washington went 43 against 46.5. That is one over and one under, and the number fell anyway.

How I make the call

Same working every week. Each team’s points per game from last season, averaged with what the other side allowed, gives me a score for the game. This season’s games through the same sum give me a second one. Home field is worth two and a half points. When the market sits outside both numbers, and a field goal or more from last season’s, I bet the side they both point to. When it sits between them, or close to last season’s number, I pass.

Last season, Indianapolis scored 27.4 a game and Pittsburgh allowed 22.8, so the Colts come out at 25.1. Pittsburgh scored 23.4 and Indianapolis allowed 24.2, so the Steelers come out at 23.8. Add them and the game is worth 48.9 points. The market is 4.4 below that.

This season, the Colts have scored 25.5 a game and Pittsburgh has allowed 21.75, so 23.6. Pittsburgh has scored 19.25 a game and the Colts have allowed 26.0, so 22.6. That adds to 46.25, still above 44.5.

Both numbers are over the market, and last season’s is clear of the field goal. That is the bet.

What the scores say

Last season the Colts’ games had a median of 52 points, and 12 of their 17 went over 44.5. Pittsburgh’s had a median of 47, and 11 of 17 went over.

2025 game totals for Steelers and Colts against a total of 44.52025: total points in every game, against this week's 44.5102030405060708044.5Steelersmedian 47Coltsmedian 52Each dot is one 2025 regular-season game. Dots stack where games had the same total.
Source: NFL 2025 results via Nucleus, checked game by game against ESPN. The line: median of the books quoting the game.

This season is split down the middle. The Colts’ games finished on 64, 63, 36 and 43, and Pittsburgh’s on 33, 23, 57 and 51. Four of the eight went over 44.5, and four did not. The market has priced this game below the middle of that, and I would not.

The one meeting finished 27-20 to Pittsburgh, at home, on 2 November last season. That is 47 points, over this number, though one game proves nothing on its own.

The side

No bet on the spread. Eight books have Pittsburgh -2.5, BetRivers and BetUS have -2, and FanDuel has -1.5.

Both seasons’ working puts Pittsburgh ahead by about a point and a half at home: 1.2 from last season, 1.5 from this one. The market is a point beyond that, short of the field goal I need. The moneyline, Pittsburgh -139 and Indianapolis +116, prices the Steelers to win 55.7% of the time.

Moneyline implies Colts 44.3 percent, Steelers 55.7 percentChance to win the game, as pricedColts 44.3%Steelers 55.7%From the median moneylines of 11 books, Colts +116 and Steelers -139, margin removed.
Source: US sportsbooks via Nucleus, read 2026-10-06 04:20 UTC.

Both teams are 2-2. Indianapolis lost 41-23 at home to Baltimore and 33-30 in Kansas City, then beat Houston 19-17 at home and won 30-13 in Washington. The Colts have covered three games in a row. Pittsburgh beat Atlanta 20-13 and Cincinnati 30-27 at home, and lost 20-3 in New England and 27-24 in Cleveland. Our Week 4 page took Pittsburgh -3 in Cleveland, and it lost.

Last season’s split

The Colts’ 2025 split in two. They were 7-1 through 26 October and scored 20 or more in every one of those eight games. From November on they went 1-8, and their last nine games added up to 196 points scored and 258 allowed.

2025 point margin in every game, Steelers and Colts2025 regular season, point margin in every gameSteelers10-7+2-14+7+3+14-2-10+7-15+22-3-19+5+13+5-7+2Colts8-9+25+1+21-7+34+4+14+24-7+6-3-4-17-2-21-6-8Blue bars are wins, grey bars are losses. Neutral-site games are included here.
Source: NFL 2025 results via Nucleus, checked game by game against ESPN.

Either version of that team helps the over. The early Colts scored, and the late Colts gave up 28.7 a game. Pittsburgh at home last season scored 23.4 a game and allowed 21.5, and the Colts on the road scored 25.5 and allowed 26.6, with the Berlin game left out.

Steelers at home and Colts on the road in 20252025: Steelers at home against Colts on the roadPoints scored per gameSteelers at home 23.4Colts on the road 25.5Points allowed per gameSteelers at home 21.5Colts on the road 26.6RecordSteelers at home 5-3Colts on the road 2-6
Source: NFL 2025 results via Nucleus, checked game by game against ESPN. Neutral-site games are left out of both.

The call

Take the over 44.5. Over 44 is better, at BetRivers (-108), MyBookie (-110) or BetMGM (-112), because a 44-point game is a push there instead of a loss. On the 44.5 the best price is -106 at William Hill.

What changes it

The price. At 45.5 I would still take it. At 46 the gap to last season’s number is under a field goal and I pass.

Who plays. This page prices no injury news, so read both teams’ reports before you bet.

Take the over 44.5.


Indianapolis Colts at Pittsburgh Steelers, Sunday 11 October 2026, 1:00 PM ET. Prices: median across 11 US sportsbooks via Nucleus, read 6 October 2026, 04:20 UTC. Results: Nucleus, the 2025 season checked game by game against ESPN, and 2026 through Week 4. Every Week 5 game: NFL Week 5 odds and predictions.

ScoresAndStats Members

Get our best bets first

Free membership: our best predictions with privileged access, a note when a new prediction is published, and content for members only.