Maple Leafs vs Islanders Best Pick, Prediction and Odds
No bet on the Islanders. Our number has New York 2.6 points better than the price, and we need 5.
The New York Islanders are -148 and the Toronto Maple Leafs +124 at DraftKings. With the margin out, that is 57.2% for New York and 42.8% for Toronto. Our number is 59.8% for the Islanders. The market already has almost all of it.
How 59.8% is reached
Our home win chance is the average of two 2025-26 rates: the home team’s win rate in its own arena and the visitor’s loss rate on the road. Overtime and shootout wins count as wins. Neutral-site games are left out of both.
The Islanders went 22-17-2 at home, a 53.7% win rate. The Maple Leafs went 14-21-6 on the road, a 65.9% road loss rate with overtime and shootout losses included. Averaged, that makes New York 59.8% and Toronto 40.2%. Against the price, that is a gap of 2.6 points toward the Islanders.
The margin is the extra a book builds into both prices so the pair comes to more than 100%. At -148 and +124 the two come to 104.3%. Taken out, they are the 57.2% and 42.8% above.
The rule is fixed before the pick. A side is a bet when our number and the market’s differ by at least 5 points. A side the market gives under 40% is never a bet, however wide the gap. The method has no adjustment for the strength of the opponent, and on underdogs its number has run above what the teams then did. A 2.6-point gap is under the line, so this game is a pass.
Every input is from 2025-26. This season is not in the figures. The Islanders are 11-6-5, 5-3-2 at home, and won 3-2 in Detroit on Saturday, 21 November. Ilya Sorokin has played 15 of their games and Semyon Varlamov 7. The Maple Leafs are 8-14-3, 4-4-1 on the road, and lost 4-3 to Columbus on Saturday. Sergei Bobrovsky has played 14 of their games and Anthony Stolarz 11. Both starts point the same way as our number, and neither is in it.
New York at home, Toronto on the road
At UBS Arena last season the Islanders scored 2.93 a game and allowed 2.98, a deficit of 0.05. That is close to break-even. The Maple Leafs on the road scored 2.88 and allowed 3.76, a deficit of 0.88 a game, and that half carries most of our number.
The halves the method leaves out: New York on the road went 21-17-3, a 51.2% win rate, scoring 2.76 and allowing 2.90. Toronto at home went 18-15-8, a 43.9% win rate, scoring 3.29 and allowing 3.54. The Islanders were about as good away as at home. The Maple Leafs were a weaker team on the road.
The season around it
Neither team made the playoffs. New York went 43-34-5 with 91 points and a goal difference of -8. Toronto went 32-36-14 with 78 points and was outscored by 46, allowing 3.65 goals a game.
Close games split them. The Islanders went 27-11-5 in one-goal games and won 14 of the 19 that went past regulation. The Maple Leafs went 14-4-14 in one-goal games and won 9 of 23 past 60 minutes. Toronto lost by two goals or more in 32 of 82 games; New York did in 23.
The Islanders won the three games between them in 2025-26. Two were at New York: 4-3 in overtime on 3 January and 5-3 on 9 April. Both are inside our number, in each half. The third, a 3-1 Islanders win in Toronto on 17 March, is in neither half.
Pick: No bet
No bet on this game. The gap is 2.6 points toward the Islanders, against a threshold of 5.
The line read Islanders -148 and Maple Leafs +124 on 22 November 2026 at 17:33 UTC, DraftKings via ESPN. It opened at the same prices, so the market’s chance for each side has not changed since opening.
What kills the bet
A longer Islanders price makes them the bet. At -121 or longer, New York is a bet whatever Toronto is priced at. Against Toronto at +124, the Islanders become a bet at -118 or longer. They are -148.
Toronto does not become a bet on any price here. For the gap to reach 5 points toward the Maple Leafs, the market would have to give them under 40%, about +150 or longer. The long-shot rule makes that no bet.
ESPN’s injury list has Ryan Pulock day-to-day with a lower-body injury and Alexander Romanov on injured reserve with a knee injury for New York. Toronto lists Colton Sissons, Kirill Marchenko and Cole McWard on injured reserve with lower-body injuries, Nick Blankenburg on injured reserve with an upper-body injury, and Jack Roslovic day-to-day with an upper-body injury. Neither list has a goalie. Check the lineups before you bet.
The total and the puck line
The total is 6.5, over -108 and under -112. The Islanders’ games went over 6.5 in 36 of 82, a 43.9% rate. The Maple Leafs’ went over in 46 of 82, 56.1%. New York’s home games averaged 5.91 goals and Toronto’s road games 6.64.
Averaged, the over is 50.0% on our number. Without the margin the market has it at 49.6%, with the under at 50.4%. That is a 0.4-point lean to the over. Pass on the total.
On the puck line, the Islanders are -1.5 at +154 and the Maple Leafs +1.5 at -185, which is 37.8% and 62.2% without the margin. Last season New York won by two goals or more in 16 of 82 games, and Toronto lost by two or more in 32 of 82. Averaged, Islanders -1.5 lands 29.3% of the time against 37.8% priced, a gap of 8.5 points toward Maple Leafs +1.5. Our method stakes the moneyline only, so this is not a bet. It also points the other way from the moneyline gap. No bet on this game.
Maple Leafs at Islanders, Monday 23 November, 7:30 PM ET, UBS Arena. Prices: DraftKings via ESPN, read 22 November 2026, 17:33 UTC. Results: ESPN, 2025-26 regular season and playoffs. Injury list, 2026-27 records and goalie appearances this season: ESPN’s game page, read 22 November 2026, 17:33 UTC.