Sunderland vs Aston Villa Best Pick, Prediction and Odds
Our prediction for Sunderland at Aston Villa is no bet. Aston Villa carry the widest gap at 2.5 points, half the 5 a bet needs.
DraftKings has Aston Villa at -125, the draw at +285 and Sunderland at +340, read 19 November at 15:35 UTC. Those three prices carry a 4.3% margin: the extra a book builds in so the prices add to more than 100%. With the margin out, the market reads Aston Villa 53.3%, the draw 24.9% and Sunderland 21.8%.
We have Aston Villa at 55.8%, the draw at 24.7% and Sunderland at 19.5%. That puts Aston Villa 2.5 points above the market, the draw 0.2 below and Sunderland 2.3 below. The rule is 5 points. Nothing reaches it.
How 55.8% is reached
Each side’s expected goals start from the league’s average goals at that venue. That average is then scaled by the side’s scoring rate at its venue and the opponent’s conceding rate at the other venue, both measured against the league. A Poisson model on the two expected-goal figures gives the home win, the draw and the away win.
The number runs on 2025-26: 19 home games for Aston Villa, 19 away games for Sunderland, and that season’s league averages over 380 games, 1.53 goals a game for the home side and 1.22 for the visitor. Each club has 5 games at the relevant venue this season. Those are not in the number.
Aston Villa’s home attack comes out at 1.1 times the league rate and Sunderland’s away defence at 0.97. That gives Aston Villa 1.63 expected goals. Sunderland’s away attack sits at 0.73 of the league rate against an Aston Villa home defence of 0.95, which leaves Sunderland 0.85.
The method has two more limits, both stated before any pick. It never bets an outcome the market prices below 40%, because it has no adjustment for opponent strength and its underdog numbers have run above what those teams then did. On this card that rules out the draw at 24.9% and Sunderland at 21.8% before any gap is read. Aston Villa, at 53.3%, is the only outcome the method could stake, and 2.5 points is not enough.
Aston Villa at home, Sunderland on the road
At Villa Park in 2025-26, Aston Villa went 12-2-5 (wins, draws, losses) in 19. They scored 1.68 a game and conceded 1.16. Those are the two home rates the method uses.
Sunderland away in 2025-26 went 5-6-8 in 19, scoring 0.89 a game and conceding 1.47. A visitor scoring under a goal a game is most of why Sunderland sit at 0.85 expected goals.
The halves left out run the other way for each club. Aston Villa away last season scored 1.26 and conceded 1.42. Sunderland at home scored 1.32 and conceded 1.05, from a 9-6-4 record. A venue-split method reads neither.
This season so far
None of this season’s results feed the number. Aston Villa are 1-2-2 at home, with 6 scored and 7 conceded: 1.2 and 1.4 a game, against 1.68 and 1.16 last season. That is a weaker home side than the one in our number.
Sunderland’s away start is worse than their 2025-26 road record. They are 0-1-4 away, scoring 1.2 a game and conceding 2.6, where last season they conceded 1.47. Five games a venue is a thin sample. The two starts point opposite ways, and on their own they do not tell us which way the number would move.
The table, this season and last
Last season Aston Villa finished 4th of 20 with 65 points from 19-8-11, scoring 56 and conceding 49. Sunderland finished 7th with 54 points from 14-12-12, 42 scored and 48 conceded.
Ten games into 2026-27 the gap is wider. Aston Villa are 10th with 13 points from 3-4-3, 14 scored and 17 conceded. Sunderland are 19th with 8 points from 2-2-6, 8 scored and 17 conceded.
Pick: no bet
No bet on the result. Aston Villa’s 2.5-point gap is the widest of the three, against a 5-point threshold, at -125 on DraftKings, read 19 November 2026 at 15:35 UTC. The draw and Sunderland are below the 40% floor and cannot be bet whatever the gap.
What kills the bet
There is no bet to kill, so the question is what would make one. Aston Villa become a bet at -112 or longer, against -125 now. The draw would clear the gap at +387 and Sunderland at +562. The market prices both under 40%, so the method would still pass on them.
The availability of players. This page has no injury list for either side, and our number does not adjust for one. Check the lineups before you bet.
The sample. Each club has 5 games at the relevant venue this season, and the number still runs on last season’s 19. When it moves to this season’s records, the figures in the section above will start to count.
The total
The total is 2.5 goals, over -135 and under +110. Without the margin the market has the over at 54.7% and the under at 45.3%. Our number has the over at 44.9% and the under at 55.1%, a gap of -9.8 points on the over. The method never bets the goals, so this is for reference only.
Six of Aston Villa’s 10 league games this season went over 2.5, and 3 of Sunderland’s 10. Last season it was 20 of 38 for Aston Villa and 17 of 38 for Sunderland.
The last meetings
ESPN lists five meetings since January 2016. Aston Villa won 4-3 at Villa Park on 19 April 2026, and the two drew 1-1 at Sunderland on 21 September 2025.
The older three are further back. Aston Villa won 3-0 at Sunderland on 6 March 2018 and 2-1 at home on 21 November 2017. Sunderland won 3-1 at home on 2 January 2016. None of the five feeds the number, which reads venue records only.
Sunderland at Aston Villa, English Premier League, Saturday 21 November, 10:00 AM ET, Villa Park, Birmingham. Prices: DraftKings via ESPN, read 19 November 2026, 15:35 UTC. Results and tables: ESPN, 2026-27 and 2025-26 English Premier League. Nothing here states who is available.