Blue Jackets vs Islanders Best Pick, Prediction and Odds - ScoresAndStats.com Skip to content
Scores&Stats
ES
NHL · Tuesday 17 November

Blue Jackets vs Islanders Best Pick, Prediction and Odds

No bet on this game. Our number has Columbus 2.7 points better than the price, and we need 5 before we bet.

The Columbus Blue Jackets at New York Islanders comes down to one comparison. DraftKings gives the Islanders 55.1% once the margin is out. Our method gives them 52.4%. That gap of 2.7 points toward the Blue Jackets is too small to bet.

Blue Jackets and Islanders this season

Columbus is 7-11-0 and 1-5-0 on the road. The Blue Jackets have won 1 of their last 5: a 2-1 shootout win over Dallas on Thursday 5 November, then a 5-2 loss at Buffalo, a 4-1 loss to Florida, a 3-1 loss to Tampa Bay and a 4-3 loss to Philadelphia on Saturday 14 November. They score 2.39 goals a game and allow 3.22. Their power play runs at 18.2% and their penalty kill at 73.5%. Kent Johnson leads them with 8 goals and 18 points, and Zach Werenski has 13 assists. In goal, Jet Greaves has played 11 games with a .875 save percentage and a 3.42 goals-against average. Cam Talbot has played 9, at .909 and 2.51.

The Islanders are 9-6-4, 4-3-2 at home. They have won 2 of their last 5. They lost 5-3 to Carolina, 5-4 in overtime to New Jersey and 3-2 in a shootout at San Jose, then won 5-2 at Los Angeles and 6-2 at Anaheim on Saturday 14 November. They score 3.11 a game and allow 2.84. Their power play is at 17.2% and their penalty kill at 85.9%. Bo Horvat leads with 9 goals. Matthew Schaefer has 15 assists and 21 points. Ilya Sorokin has played 13 games, at .915 and 2.53, and Semyon Varlamov 6, at .899 and 2.61.

ESPN’s injury list, read 16 November 2026 at 17:49 UTC, has Sean Monahan out for Columbus with an upper-body injury. For New York it lists Logan Stanley, Jean-Gabriel Pageau and Bo Horvat as day-to-day. It lists Calum Ritchie and Alexander Romanov on injured reserve. None of this season’s figures is in our number.

The prices

DraftKings has the Islanders at -135 and the Blue Jackets at +114, read 16 November 2026 at 17:49 UTC. The two prices add up to 104.2%. That extra is the margin: the cut a book builds in so a pair of prices comes to more than 100%. Take it out and the Islanders are 55.1% and the Blue Jackets 44.9%.

The line opened at -125 and +105, which was 53.2% for New York. Since the opening the market has moved toward the Islanders by 1.9 points. Our rule is fixed before the price: a side is a bet when our number and the market’s differ by at least 5 points.

Pick: No bet

No bet. The gap is 2.7 points toward the Blue Jackets against a threshold of 5. Columbus at +114 is close to fair on our number. The Islanders at -135 are worse.

Monahan’s absence does not change this. The method is re-run only when a team is without its starting goalie, and both teams’ goalies are off the injury list.

How 52.4% is reached

Our home win chance is the average of two 2025-26 rates: the home team’s win rate in its own arena and the visitor’s loss rate on the road. Overtime and shootout wins count as wins. Neutral-site games are left out. The Islanders went 22-17-2 at UBS Arena, a 53.7% home win rate. The Blue Jackets went 20-17-4 on the road, a 51.2% road loss rate. The average is 52.4% for New York and 47.6% for Columbus.

Our number gives Islanders 52.4 percent, the market 55.1 percentBlue Jackets at Islanders: chance to win, ours against the market'sOur numberlast season, home and roadBlue Jackets 47.6%Islanders 52.4%The marketmoneyline, margin removedBlue Jackets 44.9%Islanders 55.1%Moneylines: Blue Jackets +114, Islanders -135. A side is a bet when the two differ by 5 points or more.
Source: ESPN results, 2025-26 regular season, read 16 November 2026. Prices: DraftKings via ESPN, read 2026-11-16 17:49 UTC.

The goal splits match. The Islanders at home scored 2.93 a game and allowed 2.98, a surplus of -0.05. Columbus on the road scored 2.88 and allowed 3.10, a surplus of -0.22. The method leaves out two halves. One is the Islanders on the road, 21-17-3 for a 51.2% win rate. The other is Columbus at home, 20-13-8 for 48.8%.

Islanders at home and Blue Jackets on the road in 2025-262025-26: Islanders at home against Blue Jackets on the roadGoals scored per gameIslanders at home 2.93Blue Jackets on the road 2.88Goals allowed per gameIslanders at home 2.98Blue Jackets on the road 3.10RecordIslanders at home 22-17-2Blue Jackets on the road 20-17-4Islanders: 41 home games. Blue Jackets: 41 road games. Neutral-site games are left out.
Source: ESPN results, 2025-26 regular season, read 16 November 2026.

Last season and the meetings

These two finished level in practice. Columbus went 40-30-12 with 92 points and a goal difference of 0. The Islanders went 43-34-5 with 91 points and a goal difference of -8. Neither made the playoffs.

2025-26 goal margin in every game, Islanders and Blue Jackets2025-26 regular season: goal margin in every gameIslanders43-34-5-0.10 goals a gameBlue Jackets40-30-12+0.00 goals a gameColoured bars are wins, grey bars are losses, first game on the left. A shootout counts as one goal.
Source: ESPN results, 2025-26 regular season, read 16 November 2026. Record is wins, regulation losses, overtime and shootout losses.

Close games split them. The Islanders went 27-11-5 in one-goal games and won 14 of their 19 that went past regulation. The Blue Jackets went 18-13-12 in one-goal games and won 12 of 24 past 60 minutes.

The Islanders won three of the four meetings in 2025-26. At UBS Arena they won 3-2 on 2 November and 1-0 on 22 March. Both of those games are in our number, in each half. In Columbus, the Blue Jackets won 4-2 on 28 December and the Islanders won 4-3 in overtime on 28 February. Those two games are in neither half.

What kills the bet

A longer price. The Blue Jackets become a bet at +135 or longer, whatever New York is priced at. The Islanders become a bet at +111 or longer, whatever Columbus is priced at. Neither side is ever a bet while the market gives it under 40% with the margin out, a price of about +150 or longer. The method has no adjustment for the strength of the opponent, and on underdogs its number has run above what the teams then did.

The rest is on the ice. The Islanders’ goal leader, Horvat, is day-to-day. Columbus is 1-5-0 on the road this season, and none of that is in our number. Check the lineups before you bet.

The total and the puck line

The total is 5.5, over -130 and under +110. The Islanders’ games went over 5.5 in 41 of 82 last season, 50.0%. The Blue Jackets’ went over in 48 of 82, 58.5%. Islanders home games averaged 5.91 goals and Columbus road games 5.98.

2025-26 game totals for Islanders and Blue Jackets2025-26: total goals in every game, against this game's 5.5012345678910111213145.5Islandersover 5.5 in 41 of 82Blue Jacketsover 5.5 in 48 of 82Each dot is one 2025-26 regular-season game. Dots stack where games had the same total.
Source: ESPN results, 2025-26 regular season, read 16 November 2026. A shootout winner counts as one goal. Prices: DraftKings via ESPN, read 2026-11-16 17:49 UTC.

Our over number is 54.3%, and the market’s is 54.3% with the margin out. The gap is 0.0 points. Pass on the total.

On the puck line, the Islanders are -1.5 at +190 and the Blue Jackets +1.5 at -230. Without the margin that is 33.1% for New York to cover. Last season the Islanders won by two goals or more in 16 of 82 games. Columbus lost by two or more in 17 of 82. On those rates Islanders -1.5 covers 20.1% of the time, a gap of 13.0 points toward Blue Jackets +1.5. Our method stakes the moneyline only, so this is a lean and not a bet. The call on this game stays no bet.


Blue Jackets at Islanders, Tuesday 17 November, 7:00 PM ET, UBS Arena. Prices: DraftKings via ESPN, read 16 November 2026, 17:49 UTC. Results: ESPN, 2025-26 regular season and playoffs. This season’s records, last five games, team stats, leaders, goalies and injury list: ESPN’s game page, read 16 November 2026, 17:49 UTC.

ScoresAndStats Members

Get our best bets first

Free membership: our best predictions with privileged access, a note when a new prediction is published, and content for members only.