Our number has the Lightning at 52.4%. They are a bet at +111 or longer, the Islanders at +135 or longer.

Tampa Bay Lightning
Upcoming games
The Lightning were underdogs only 11 times in 2025-26, and ten of those games beat the +1.5 line. In the other 71, as favorites, Tampa Bay went 43-28 and lost 2.2 units on the moneyline.
A favorite almost every night
Tampa Bay went 50-32, a record matched by Buffalo and Dallas and beaten only by Colorado and Carolina. The market priced the Lightning as favorites in 71 of 82 games; only Colorado and Carolina were underdogs fewer times. One unit on them in every game returned 1.18 units, and eleven NHL teams returned more.
As favorites they won 43 and lost 28, and the moneyline lost 2.2 units. On the -1.5 puck line those 71 games produced 28 covers. As underdogs they went 7-4 for 3.38 units, covering +1.5 ten times in eleven. Only Colorado, an underdog once, covered at a higher rate.
Two months made the season
November went 11-3 and returned 6.19 units. January went 11-2 and returned 5.09. The longest winning run, eleven games, ran from 20 December to 13 January. March went 8-8 and gave back 3.55 units, and October produced two puck line covers in eleven games.
Home ice and the puck line
Away from home the Lightning covered 22 of 41 puck lines. At home they covered 16 of 40; 22 teams covered more often at home. Both of the defeats at the shortest price came at home at -290: Chicago won 3-2 and Seattle won 4-3 in overtime. The remaining game, the Stadium Series at a neutral site, was a 6-5 shootout win over Boston.
Tampa Bay allowed 2.82 goals a game, fewer than every team except Colorado and Dallas, and scored 3.54. The total split 42 over, 40 under.
No covers against Buffalo
Buffalo won three of four meetings, and Tampa Bay covered none of the four puck lines, 2.51 units lost. Boston lost all four, but the Lightning covered only one of those puck lines. Columbus and the Islanders swept their three games with Tampa Bay, which cost three units per opponent. Philadelphia lost all three, with three covers.
Questions and answers
How did the Lightning fare in their 11 games as underdogs?
3.38 units from 11 games in 2025-26, a 7-4 record, with 10 covers at +1.5.
Was backing the Lightning on the moneyline profitable in 2025-26?
Barely: 1.18 units over 82 games, and a 2.2-unit loss in their 71 games as favorites.
How did the Lightning do against Buffalo?
1-3, no puck line covers in four games, 2.51 units lost.
NHL teams
Anaheim Ducks
Boston Bruins
Buffalo Sabres
Calgary Flames
Carolina Hurricanes
Chicago Blackhawks
Colorado Avalanche
Columbus Blue Jackets
Dallas Stars
Detroit Red Wings
Edmonton Oilers
Florida Panthers
Los Angeles Kings
Minnesota Wild
Montreal Canadiens
Nashville Predators
New Jersey Devils
New York Islanders
New York Rangers
Ottawa Senators
Philadelphia Flyers
Pittsburgh Penguins
San Jose Sharks
Seattle Kraken
St Louis Blues
Tampa Bay Lightning
Toronto Maple Leafs
Utah Mammoth
Vancouver Canucks
Vegas Golden Knights
Washington Capitals
Winnipeg Jets